Our top pick: Nationwide
- A+ Superior rating
- On Your Side auto repair network
- Plenti rewards program
Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our content.
Nationwide vs. American Family: Which provider is right for you?
Nationwide vs. American Family car insurance
Having a hard time deciding between getting car insurance through Nationwide or American Family?
It can be frustrating trying to choose, as most providers offer similar discounts and similar rates. For example, both Nationwide and American Family offer a defensive driver discount. And both companies do well in the customer satisfaction department. So how is one to choose?
We’ve lined up the two companies side by side in a comprehensive comparison so you can get the facts you need to make the best decision for your personal situation.
|
|
|
|---|---|
| Nationwide is among the nation’s top ten car insurance providers, offering the full range of service and a promise to be “on your side” with stellar service. | American Family Insurance aims to gain the trust of their customers through top-notch customer service and protection. |
| All states except AK, HI, LA, MA | AZ, CO, GA, ID, IL, IN, IA, KS, MN, MO, NE, NV, ND, OH, OR, SD, UT, WA, WI |
| Optional | Optional |
| Yes | Yes |
| Yes | Yes |
| No | Yes |
| Yes | Yes |
| Online Phone |
online phone |
| 12 months 6 months Monthly |
12 months monthly custom |
| Yes | Yes |
| Yes | Yes |
| No | No |
| No | Yes |
| No | Yes |
| Yes | Yes |
| Yes | Yes |
| Yes | Yes, up to 10% |
| No | No |
| Yes | Yes |
| Yes, 5-40% | Yes |
|
|
|
Bottom line
Both companies have been in the insurance industry for a long time and have solid reputations. When comparing discounts, remember to keep your personal situation in mind. The company that offers the most discounts won’t necessarily be the best choice for you. It’s the one that has the most discounts that apply to you that will provide the most cost savings.
Also keep in mind that American Family only provides insurance in 19 states. If you don’t live in one of those states, it’s not even an option for you.
Compare your car insurance options to find the best insurance company for you.
Compare alternatives to Nationwide and American Family
More guides on Finder
-
Coinbase vs Robinhood
Discover which exchange is better suited to cryptocurrency trading after comparing things like fees, security and features.
-
Savvy car insurance review
This insurance shopping tool compares 100+ companies and prefills your quote forms.
-
6 reasons why you’ll want the Luxury Card Mastercard® Black Card™
Because your time is priceless.
-
UBS Resource Management account review
The UBS Resource Management account offers nationwide ATM rebates, but its annual fee is comparatively expensive.
-
7 best military banks and credit unions
The 7 best military banks and credit unions for vets, reservists and active-duty personnel.
-
GM OnStar car insurance review
Existing users can get a discount, but coverage is only offered in Arizona for now.
-
Coinbase vs Coinbase Pro
We compare Coinbase and Coinbase Pro side-by-side so you can see the differences in fees, features, supported cryptocurrencies and more.
-
Upgrade Rewards Checking review
The free Upgrade Rewards Checking account offers 2% cashback, but you can’t deposit checks.
-
Cheese Rewards Checking review
A digital bank built for Asian-Americans. Earns up to 10% cash back and up to 3% APY.
-
Lemonade car insurance review for 2021
Safe drivers and electric car owners could see cheap rates, but its claims process isn’t perfect.