We value our editorial independence, basing our comparison results, content and reviews on objective analysis without bias. But we may receive compensation when you click links on our site. Learn more about how we make money from our partners.
Car Insurance Finder
Compare all your options in one place and save up to 52%
Last updated:
Finder’s insurance team has spent thousands of hours researching policies and analyzing hundreds of thousands of quotes (for real!) from different car insurance brands all over the US, to help you find the best deal. In our research, we’ve found discounts that could lead to up to 52% off what you’re currently paying – many drivers save at least $500 a year by switching. You can easily compare companies or keep reading our guides to find the best discounts, coverage, perks and more to cover your ride for less.
Compare car insurance
What's in this guide?
How much does car insurance cost?
The average cost of car insurance is $1,065 per year, or $89 a month, but rates vary based on your car, driving record, demographics and other reasons. The biggest factors that affect your rate include:
- Your car’s make and model and the year you bought it are the biggest factors in your insurance rates. Its current value and whether you own it will also affect your coverage costs and how much coverage you need.
- Your location is the second biggest factor for rates. Each state sets minimum insurance requirements, and even rates in different ZIP codes in the same city can vary by hundreds of dollars. Living in a high risk area can drive your rates up, like a big city or an area with a high rate of uninsured drivers.
- Your demographics affect your rates more than you might think. Your rates are based on your age, gender, marital status, credit score and other factors that have nothing to do with your driving. Insurance companies use these factors to predict your risk level and set your rates.
Car insurance rates
If lowering your car insurance premium is your main priority, switching car insurance could be one of the best ways to save. Compare how much price differs between insurers with sample auto insurance rates for California drivers.
| Company | Average annual rate | Average monthly rate |
|---|---|---|
| Geico | $394 | $33 |
| USAA | $416 | $35 |
| Progressive | $536 | $45 |
| Grange | $557 | $46 |
| Mercury | $564 | $47 |
| Esurance | $609 | $51 |
| Kemper | $615 | $51 |
| 21st Century | $651 | $54 |
| Allied | $666 | $55 |
| Nationwide | $666 | $56 |
| Allstate | $666 | $59 |
| Liberty Mutual | $709 | $59 |
| State Farm | $726 | $61 |
| The Hartford | $727 | $61 |
How to compare auto insurance
Ever wonder why insurance policies and quotes are different for every provider? You might not be comparing equivalent rates. Make sure you’re comparing apples to apples to get the best insurance quotes.
- Consider the biggest discounts. To get your business, many providers quote lowest possible price. It might, say, include a hefty 25% car insurance discount for buying online. However, other insurers might offer the same discount but not include it in your quote. While it’s good to consider discounts in your initial search, make sure you’re also considering the final price too.
- Make sure you’re comparing apples to apples. When you’re comparing quotes, make sure you put in the same amount of info on each quote. Check to see if you’re getting any extra coverage or missing any discounts, and that the deductible and pay schedule are the same.
- Look for specialist insurance. Driving for business, rideshare drivers and adding on coverage can all affect your premiums. If you’re not getting good rates from the big national companies, look for a company that specializes in the coverage you need.
- Balance the best coverage with the cheapest rates. The goal is to get the right coverage for you with the best deal. But consider every factor that might be important, such as how easy it will be to make claims, or whether you’ll pay extra for perks you need. It’s helpful to consider at least two to three of the cheapest quotes with the same level of coverage you need.
- Consider customer satisfaction. While price is a big reason many people switch insurance, issues with billing or customer service are another big reason drivers shop around. When your’e comparing quotes, look into each company’s customer satisfaction ratings to avoid denied or lengthy claims
Compare car insurance where you live
Car insurance rates across the US can vary a lot based on where you live. The national average is $1,300 per year, but drivers in Maine pay only about $864, while drivers in Michigan see premiums averaging $2,394. Shopping for car insurance starts with finding your state minimum required coverage and then adding extra coverage you’d like. Compare auto insurance rates by state and even by ZIP code.
Compare car insurance for your state
Join the millions of people who trust Finder to help them save on car insurance.
10 tips for getting cheap car insurance
No one wants to overpay for car insurance. And it’s hard to compare policies to get enough coverage at the right price. The best way to save is by shopping around. In a study done in New York, the average driver can save up to $625 by switching car insurance.
1. Start with customized quotes.
Different people can pay drastically different prices for car insurance even at the same company. Compare car insurance companies that can offer you the best deal for you individually, not across the board. You can also compare local insurance companies, which tend to have higher customer satisfaction rates than their big-name counterparts and could potentially have lower rates.
2. Hunt for discounts.
Some insurers offer discounts to drivers for a variety of reasons such as having a clean record, paying an annual premium all at once or being a safe driver for a certain period of time. If the insurance company you’re with offers more than just auto insurance, consider bundling all your insurance through them, like home and car insurance. Most companies offer a group discount, even if it’s just for more than one car.
3. Get the right coverage for your car.
Make sure you are getting the appropriate coverage for the car you’ve driving. Consider skipping collision or comprehensive coverage for an old car. The value of your car determines your maximum payout if it’s stolen or totaled, meaning these policies are not very useful for older vehicles.
4. Raise your deductible.
A higher deductible means lower premiums, your monthly or annual price. But if you get in an accident, you will have to pay more than if your deductibles were lower. For example, if you have a $500 deductible on a $2,000 accident, you’d pay $500 before your insurance company covers the other $1,500. With a $1,000 deductible, you’re paying $1,000 and your insurer covers the remaining $1,000.
5. Look into pay-per-mile insurance.
If you drive under a certain amount of miles every year, you can tell your insurance company and possibly qualify for a low mileage discount. This is a common discount that many drivers actually qualify for but are not aware of. If you only use your car for occasional short trips, you can sign up for a usage-based insurance program that determines your rates based on how much you drive.
6. Avoid accidents and tickets.
These two are surefire ways to make your premium go through the roof. If you live in a high risk area or are prone to getting in accidents, look into a provider that offers accident forgiveness, where your first accident won’t make your premiums go up.
7. Take a defensive driving course.
If you have a less than stellar driving record, sign up for a defensive driving class. Most insurers will give you a discount on your premiums. Your local DMV can point you in the right direction.
8. Combine policies with your parents or spouse.
Look into being a nominated driver on your parents’ insurance. Their rates might go up, but it could be less than keeping your solo policy. And because married drivers tend to file fewer claims, you’ll often get a discount on your premium just for getting engaged or married. Married couples can also save by combining their insurance on one policy to save money.
9. Check and maintain your credit history.
Most auto insurance companies take your credit history into account for your pricing, unless you live in CA, MA or Hawaii. The reasoning behind it? Research actually shows that people with a higher credit score tend to make fewer claims.
10. Choose the right car.
Newer, cheaper cars tend to be cheaper to insure. Luxury cars have a higher sticker price and tend to cost more for as long as you use it. It’s worth buying a cheaper car, especially if you’re a young driver. If you haven’t purchased a car yet or are getting ready to shop for a different car, compare insurance prices for car models you’re interested in. The insurance price differences might surprise you.
Explore in-depth car insurance guides
Ask an expert: What mistakes should I avoid?
Kirby George
Farmers, Licensed Insurance Agent
The biggest mistake I see people make is shopping for price.
When shopping for a car, a house or even a sweater, the average consumer understand they’re going to get what they pay for. If you want a Cadillac, you’re going to have to pay more than you would for a Ford.
If you want a brand new 2500sf home, you expect to pay more than you would for a 20yr old mobile home. When you shop for clothes, you pay more for new than you do at a thrift shop. Insurance is no different!
Your car insurance questions answered
Ask an Expert