We value our editorial independence, basing our comparison results, content and reviews on objective analysis without bias. But we may receive compensation when you click links on our site. Learn more about how we make money from our partners.
A to Z list of car insurance companies
List of 60+ car insurance reviews
Compare the top 60 car insurance companies with the comprehensive list of brands that offer car insurance in the US. Read reviews on any company you’re considering to find the right insurance for you.
- Licensed broker
- Fast, online quotes
- Compare 10+ policies at once
Our top pick: Gabi
Get free quotes from top insurers for the exact coverage you need in minutes.
- Licensed broker
- Quick quotes
- Bundling discounts
- Convenient account management
- Personal advisors
The US has over 500 car insurance companies to choose from. If you wanted to get a quote from every single one of them, it would take you about 125 hours! You can compare insurance and get quotes in a fraction of the time with comprehensive reviews from the top insurance brands on finder.com.
Get car insurance quotes
Compare the full list of car insurance brands
Who has better customer service for making insurance claims? What kind of vehicle and driver discounts can you get? Which company is more reliable? Compare car insurance companies to find out who’s best for you and your car.
Compare companies side by side
Car insurance comparison chart
Who has the best car insurance? Compare some of the top brands to see how they stack up.
|Company||States served||AM Best rating||Premiums Written ($bn)||Market Share|
|Allstate||All 50 states||A+||$21.40||9%|
|American Family||19 states||A||$4.40||2%|
|Farmers||All 50 states||A||$10.40||4%|
|Geico||All 50 states||A++||$29.60||13%|
|Liberty Mutual||All 50 states||A||$11.60||5%|
|Progressive||All 50 states||A+||$22.80||10%|
|State Farm||All 50 states||A++||$41.80||18%|
|USAA||All 50 states||A++||$13.20||6%|
List of digital startup car insurance companies
Looking beyond the big brands? Compare the top digital startups aimed at making car insurance easy to buy with fair rates based on your actual driving.
How much should I pay for car insurance?
Ask an Expert