Get the cheapest quotes on your auto insurance
Enter your ZIP code to see insurers near you.
Your information is secure.
Get the cheapest quotes on your auto insurance
Enter your ZIP code to see insurers near you.
Your information is secure.
Finder’s insurance team spent thousands of hours analyzing over 165 car insurance companies to help you narrow down your options. Rely on our unbiased reviews to cut out days of research about each company’s coverage, discounts, free or optional perks and customer reviews.
These top 10 car insurance companies make up nearly 75% of the personal car insurance market. Taking up such a huge part of the market shows that most drivers trust these companies for their car insurance. Dive in to our reviews of the largest auto insurers to see what the hype is about.
Choose the letter from our alphabetized list that corresponds with the name of the company you’re interested in, such as S for State Farm. Then, choose the company name to read our review.
See how the top companies compare against each other, based on their market share, financial strength and customer service ratings. What these ratings mean:
Car insurance company | Market share | Finder star rating | AM Best financial strength | BBB rating |
---|---|---|---|---|
State Farm | 16% | 4 of 5 stars | A++ | A+ |
Geico | 13.5% | 4 of 5 stars | A++ | A+ |
Progressive | 13% | 4 of 5 stars | A+ | A+ |
Allstate | 9% | 4 of 5 stars | A+ | A+ |
USAA | 6% | 4 of 5 stars | A++ | A |
Liberty Mutual | 5% | 4 of 5 stars | A | A+ |
Farmers | 4% | 4 of 5 stars | A | A- |
Nationwide | 2% | 4 of 5 stars | A+ | A+ |
American Family | 2% | 4 of 5 stars | A | A |
Travelers | 2% | 4.5 of 5 stars | A+ | A+ |
Compare the best car insurance companies
The big brands like Geico and Progressive can offer great perks, prices and availability across states. However, smaller local companies like Arbella or Bear River may offer better customer service or unique perks for your area, career or car.
Compare the full list of companies that offer car insurance coverage directly to any driver:
Lendzi lets you compare multiple business loan options in one place. Here’s how it works.
These are the best trading platforms for beginners, according to Finder’s comprehensive analysis.
AI is one of the most exciting industries on the market. Here’s some of the top artificial intelligence stocks to watch.
What you need to know about the future of catch-up contributions.
These are the best ETF brokers of 2023, according to Finder’s comprehensive review.
Strategies for saving better while inflation is high.
Find out how to invest in startups, how long it could take to get your money and why startup investing is so risky.
Same-day business loans can get you funds the same business day as you apply, rather than making you wait 24 hours or more.
Learn how to buy and store crypto with a few checklists to keep in mind.