Finder makes money from featured partners, but editorial opinions are our own. Advertiser Disclosure
This article was reviewed by Andrew Flueckiger, a member of the Finder Editorial Review Board and certified insurance counselor and licensed insurance agent in five states.
Get your most compatible insurance options via a "smart matching" method aimed at finding you value.
Getting cheap car insurance looks different for every driver because it depends on what you’re looking for. Do you want your state’s minimum coverage, which is the bare minimum required for you to legally drive? Or are you balancing price with coverage and service?
State minimum is the cheapest of the cheap but could cost you big bucks after an accident. Full-coverage costs more than state minimum car insurance, but you can shop around for the cheapest full-coverage policy and find other ways to cut down costs.
State minimum coverage, meaning the legally required amount of liability car insurance your state requires in order to drive, is the cheapest car insurance coverage available.
We pulled state minimum coverage for a man living in California to give you an idea of how the monthly rates for state minimum coverage vary between six major companies.
| Company | State minimum coverage |
|---|---|
| Geico | $39.12 |
| Progressive | $49.73 |
| State Farm | $63.26 |
| Allstate | $76 |
| The General | $83.39 |
| Liberty Mutual | $84.92 |
Buying state minimum coverage costs less upfront than adding options like collision or comprehensive coverage. But minimum coverage could cost you more out of pocket in the long run if you don’t have enough insurance to pay for car damage or injuries.
When you’re buying liability coverage, you choose the maximum dollar amount that your insurance pays if you cause damage or injuries to someone else. This maximum is called your coverage limit. After your insurer pays the coverage limit towards damages, you’re required to pay the rest. This means you could end up paying more out of pocket after an accident than what you save by opting for state minimum coverage.
Jordan Peagler from MKP Law Group talked with Finder about the pitfalls of buying your state’s minimum liability limits.
In LA there are many people who are driving cars that are easily over $100K. If you get the minimum insurance limit in LA for $5,000 in property damages, you could be left footing the remaining $95K+ for a wrecked car, and that’s assuming no associated injuries.”
Rather than opting for the lowest liability limits allowed, Eagler suggests, “Don’t get the state minimum liability coverages — choose liability limits of at least 100/300/100.”
It’s not just large accidents that can cost you. Let’s say you go with Geico’s minimum coverage instead of full coverage. You’re saving around $82 bucks a month or $979 a year. You get in a fender bender, and the other driver’s car has multiple scratches that require cosmetic repairs totaling $7,500. According to Consumer Reports, each scratch repair costs anywhere from $150 to $2,500.
You file a claim, and your insurer pays up to your state minimum coverage limit towards damages, $5,000. Now, you’re left on the hook for $2,500 in repairs. You have to weigh whether your savings with state minimum are worth the risks of what you may have to pay out of pocket after an accident.
We pulled full coverage car insurance rates for a man living in California to give you an idea of how the monthly rates vary between six major companies. Geico is the cheapest with rates starting around $121 monthly.
| Company | Full coverage |
|---|---|
| Geico | $120.69 |
| Progressive | $154.91 |
| State Farm | $191.58 |
| Allstate | $208 |
| The General | $286.86 |
| Liberty Mutual | $304.92 |
We recommend buying full coverage, which is a policy with at least liability, comprehensive and collision coverage. Meaning, you’ll have higher coverage to protect you from paying out of pocket for the other driver’s injuries or property damage. Plus, coverage for your own car’s repairs and any damages caused by a storm, theft or incidents that don’t include hitting another car.
Full coverage costs as much as three times the price of state minimum coverage, based on our analysis of car insurance rates from six major companies. But for that price, you’re raising your liability limits by more than double the state’s minimums, while adding collision and comprehensive coverage.
This way, if you’re in an accident, big or small, there is less of a chance you’ll have to cough up cash out of pocket. Your insurance does what it’s supposed to do, foot the bill after an accident.
You can get cheaper auto insurance rates and not completely sacrifice your coverage levels, no matter which type of policy or company you choose:
If your car is worth close to what your annual premium for collision and collision deductible is combined, you can probably get rid of it. So if your car is worth $2,000, and you have a $1,000 collision deductible plus $400 in annual premiums for collision, you might not benefit enough from having collision to justify the cost.
Dr. Jacquie Carroll, an Accredited Financial Counselor told Finder, “When you increase your deductible, your premiums (the amount you pay each month/quarter/year) will go down, meaning your monthly bills are lower.” This means you’ll have monthly savings from choosing a higher deductible compared to what you’ll pay monthly for a lower deductible.
Dr. Caroll suggests drivers, “pocket the savings each month and you will have enough in one year to cover the higher deductible. Anything after that, is pure savings!”
If you play with raising liability limits or adding coverage, you may be surprised how much extra coverage you can get for a little extra cost. Jordan Peagler from MKP Law Group suggests,
“Good car insurance coverage may amount to a difference of $10-15 more each month, but could hugely benefit you if you get into a serious or even minor accident. Always look at the big picture when considering how much you spend on your car insurance.”
Updating the mileage you drive each year is something you might not remember to update with your insurer or during the quote process, but making sure the amount of miles you drive each year is accurate assures you’re being charged accurately.
Most insurance companies give 10% to 20% discounts for low mileage, so regardless of what type of coverage you have — lower miles driven each year means lower rates.
You may not have qualified for a homeowner discount or for bundling your car, home or other policies when you originally purchased your insurance. If you’ve recently gotten married or purchased a home, check to see if your current insurer can apply any new discounts or shop around for an insurer who will to see if you qualify for better rates.
These programs set your premiums based on how safely you drive, shaving up to 50% off your rates. But they work best if you’re a safe driver that’s okay with giving permission to track your trips and store your driving data.
The cheapest car insurance is state minimum coverage, but that’s because you’re getting the bare minimum coverage available. It’s always best to balance cost with value, to make sure you’re not left with extensive out-of-pocket costs after an accident. The best way to get cheap car insurance, regardless of which type of policy you choose, is to compare your options from a variety of car insurers to find the right policy at the right price.
Your rates may be different based on details like your ZIP code, location, job and annual mileage.
Find out everything you need to know about Know Your Customer (KYC) processes including what information is required, how to pass, and more in Finder’s KYC guide.
Compare car insurance rates and features that serve Stockton.
California is one of the deadliest states in the US for car accidents. No joke.
These 4 best car insurance picks are a good starting point for shopping around in Modesto.
Compare top car insurance companies in Bakersfield, plus see why you need extra coverage here.
Shop for car insurance in Sacramento with the best coverage, rates, service and local reputation.
Car insurance isn’t optional in San Jose. Compare insurers that serve San Jose, California.
Compare insurers that serve Fresno, California, side by side.
These top 4 companies should narrow down your car insurance options in San Diego.
See our 4 best picks for car insurance in Denver, plus a few more to consider.
