Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our opinions or reviews. Learn how we make money.

Airbnb versus a savings account

Short-term rentals can come with high rewards — and high risks.

Updated

Buying or renting an Airbnb investment property can potentially be a profitable move if it’s in the right location. But if you aren’t booked as often as you want, you could end up with a second mortgage you can’t afford to pay.

What is an Airbnb investment property?

An Airbnb investment property is a house or apartment used solely for short-term renting on the Airbnb platform.

For an investment property to be potentially successful, it’ll need to be located in an area that’s likely to get visitors. The idea is to generate enough money to pay off the property’s mortgage and begin to turn a profit, but how quickly you do that depends on the amount of work you put into your acquisition.

The rise of peer-to-peer platforms

In January 2009, the Airbnb team received their first funding of $20,000, followed by massive injection of $7.2 million in November 2010. Since then Airbnb has continued to attract investors eager to cash in on this unique business model. The biggest investment was a one-off $1.5 billion, the highest amount in one of the largest funding rounds in startup history. Today Airbnb offers more than six million homes in 191 countries.

Investing the time

Besides the financial investment, there’s also the time commitment to consider. Upkeep, day-to-day management and tenant relations take a lot of work, especially if you’re renting more than one property. Some investors choose to hire someone to clean the rental unit between guests or even a full-service management company, but that will eat into your potential profits.

The risk factor

Buying a new house or apartment to use as an Airbnb rental is a risky investment. You’ll face all of the usual risks of buying real estate, like the chance of the market worsening or the property needing expensive maintenance, plus additional risks. Talk with an accountant before investing in an Airbnb property to make sure you’re financially stable enough to face the risks. For example, can you pay the mortgage if you don’t get as many renters as you’re anticipating? What if you don’t get any renters for the first few months?

Airbnb reviews

Another risk factor with an Airbnb investment property is the review system. Travelers can comment on the state of your property, whether or not you were helpful and friendly and whether or not they’d recommend you to other Airbnb users. One or two negative comments can be enough to dissuade travelers, which would likely have a significant impact on your ability to attract future guests.

Savings accounts

Savings accounts offer a low-risk way to grow your investment. While they don’t have the same potential for gain as an investment property, they also don’t have the same potential for loss.

Risk-averse investors may prefer keeping their money in an account where the return on investment (ROI) is predictable. If you are ready to jump into the world of Airbnb, you may still want to consider setting aside a portion of your savings into a savings account so that you have a cushion if your rental isn’t immediately successful.

Alternative options

Other options for growing your money include:

  • Stocks. Investing in stocks also means taking on risk, though you can mitigate that somewhat by building a diverse portfolio.
  • CDs. Certificates of deposit are a low-risk way to grow your money and often offer higher interest rates than traditional savings accounts.

Example: Francine and Roy

Francine and Roy recently inherited $100,000 each from their late grandfather. Roy plans to use his money as a down payment on a $300,000 home he’ll rent out on Airbnb, while Francine decides to put hers in a savings account that pays 2.45% APY.

Roy

Roy takes out a 15-year mortgage on the remaining $200,000 for the home at 4.10% APR. This leaves him with a monthly payment of $1,489.

He rents the home out for $150 a night — after Airbnb fees, he keeps $145.50. He also need to pay state and local sales taxes plus a hotel/motel tax, which adds up to about 10% in his city, leaving Roy with about $130/night. In order to break even, he’ll need to keep the home rented for about 11-12 nights a month.

The first year, Roy is only able to keep the home booked on the weekends, so he loses about $4,350 dollars. By the second year, though, his property is booked about 15 nights a month, and he turns a profit of about $5,500 — but he’s still doing all of the cleaning and the maintenance himself. If he wants to hire someone to manage or clean the home, it’ll eat into his profits.

Francine

Francine decides to put her money in a savings account so she doesn’t have to worry about it. She compares accounts and finds one she likes that offers 2.45% APY. The first year she makes $2,479.67. The second year she makes an additional $2,541.16.

Becoming a host: How it works

As a host, you’ll be asked to list details about your property, including availability, accommodation type, location, the number of people it can accommodate, price and whether or not you offer cleaning services for an additional fee. Travelers can then get in touch with you and if you agree to host them, the payment transaction is conducted wholly on the Airbnb platform.

Airbnb takes a percentage of the payment from both the guest and the host, though the exact amount can vary. In some locations, Airbnb may also be able to charge tax directly to the guests. In others, you may be required to calculate any necessary taxes and pay them. The laws regarding renting out property differ from state to state and even by county or city, so make sure you understand the implications.

Which should I choose?

It depends on your situation. Airbnb is a long-term financial engagement and requires consistent effort to turn a profit. While the potential for clearing a decent profit is high under the right circumstances, choosing a property in the wrong location or getting a few bad reviews could lead to a major loss.

A savings account takes much less effort and almost no upkeep. While the potential gains aren’t quite as high, you’re unlikely to face losses of any kind, and you can generally predict how much money you’ll make over time.

But that doesn’t mean you need to choose one or the other. If you’re interested in starting an Airbnb, it may be a good idea to keep a savings account as financial padding. Talk with a professional to find out more about the best way to manage your finances.

Compare some of the top savings accounts

$
$
months
Name Product Interest rates (APY) Fee Minimum deposit to open Interest earned More info
Citibank® Account Package

0.13% on $500,000+
0.08% on $25,000 to $99,999.99
0.04% on $0 to $24,999.99
$25 per month
(can be waived)
$0
Go to site
View details
Earn a $400 bonus after opening new eligible checking and savings accounts and completing required activities.
American Express® Personal Savings High Yield Savings
0.60%
$0
$0
Go to site
View details
Enjoy no monthly fees and a competitive APY with this online-only savings account. Accounts offered by American Express National Bank, Member FDIC.
CIT Bank Money Market
0.60%
$0
$100
Go to site
View details
A savings account with a higher-than-average rate and minimal fees.
Chase Savings
0.01%
$5 per month
(can be waived)
$0
Go to site
View details
A simple savings account with low, waivable monthly fees and a $150 signup bonus when you meet deposit and balance requirements.
Aspiration Spend & Save Account

1.00% on $0 to $10,000 but you’ll need to be enrolled in Aspiration Plus and make at least $1,000 in debit card purchases a month
$0
$10
Go to site
View details
A spend and save combo account with no monthly service fees, free access to every ATM in the world, unlimited cash back rewards and deposits insured by the FDIC. The Aspiration Spend & Save Account is a cash management account offering of Aspiration Financial, LLC, an SEC-registered broker-dealer. Aspiration is not a chartered bank.
CIT Bank Savings Builder High Yield Savings Account

0.55% on $25,000+ or set up a direct deposit of $100+ each month
0.31% on $0 to $24,999
$0
$100
Go to site
View details
No account opening or maintenance fees. Daily compounding interest. Earn one of the nation's top rates
loading

Compare up to 4 providers

Bottom line

Airbnb can be a great investment for some people. In other cases, it can lead to major losses. Talk with a professional about your plans to learn more about the risks and rewards of investing in real estate. And whatever you decide, consider opening a savings account to provide a financial safety net.

Frequently asked questions

Image source: Getty Images

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder.com provides guides and information on a range of products and services. Because our content is not financial advice, we suggest talking with a professional before you make any decision.

By submitting your comment or question, you agree to our Privacy and Cookies Policy and finder.com Terms of Use.

Questions and responses on finder.com are not provided, paid for or otherwise endorsed by any bank or brand. These banks and brands are not responsible for ensuring that comments are answered or accurate.
Go to site