Get the cheapest quotes on your auto insurance
Enter your ZIP code to see insurers near you.
Your information is secure.
Finder makes money from featured partners, but editorial opinions are our own. Advertiser Disclosure
Compare car insurance in New Jersey
Get the cheapest car insurance in New Jersey for 2022
New Jersey drivers pay an average of $1,500.58 per year for car insurance according to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), that’s about $125.05 per month. New Jersey drivers pay about 26% more than the countrywide national average of $1,189.64.
The NAIC takes into account all car insurance policies within the state such as drivers who select only state minimum coverage, as well as policies that include various levels of comprehensive and collision coverage. Because car insurance rates are influenced by personal factors, you could find yourself paying significantly less.
New Jersey car insurance quick facts
Minimum liability requirements
15/30/5
Average annual car insurance cost according to the NAIC
$1,500.58
No-fault state
In no-fault states, each driver pays for their own injury-related expenses.
New Jersey state minimum car insurance requirements
Jersey handles insurance regulations a bit differently compared to other states. To meet the legal minimums, drivers can choose a basic or standard policy. We’ll break down your options for each.
New Jersey bodily injury liability
Basic policy
- $10,000 bodily injury for all people per accident, not required
Standard policy
- $15,000 bodily injury per person
- $30,000 bodily injury per accident
New Jersey lets you choose your bodily injury liability limits with an option between a basic or standard plan. Choosing a basic plan means you don’t have to purchase bodily injury, but have the option of at least $10,000. Choosing the standard plan means you’re required to carry at least $15,000 in bodily injury per person and $30,000 in bodily injury per accident.
If you choose to buy bodily injury liability with the basic policy your insurer will pay $10,000 total for anyone injured by you in an at-fault accident. If you choose the standard plan your insurer will pay up to $15,000 per person or up to $30,000 per accident if you injure someone in an at-fault accident. Any costs outside of your bodily injury limit are required to come out of your pocket.
New Jersey property damage liability
Basic and standard policy
- $5,000 property damage liability
New Jersey requires drivers to carry $5,000 of property damage liability to legally drive, regardless of whether you choose the basic or standard plan. This is the lowest required property damage limit across the US, with only two other states with required limits this low.
This means $5,000 is the maximum amount your car insurance company will pay towards damages you cause to another person’s car or property, such as repairs to a car, fence or building. You’ll have to pay out of pocket for any costs beyond your property damage liability limit.
New Jersey personal injury protection
Basic and standard policy
- $15,000 personal injury protection
New Jersey drivers are required to carry $15,000 worth of personal injury protection to legally drive, regardless of which plan they choose.
This coverage helps pay your or your passenger’s medical expenses if you’re injured in an accident, regardless of fault.
Finder tip: State minimum coverage isn’t enough
These state-mandated requirements are the lowest amount of coverage you need to legally drive in New Jersey, but may fall short if you’re in a major accident. To avoid high out-of-pocket costs after an accident, consider raising your liability limits by balancing coverage, your budget and what you can afford to pay out of pocket for certain damage.
In New Jersey, drivers pay for their own injury expenses
New Jersey is a no-fault state, which means that you pay for your own medical bills, lost income and other injury expenses after an accident, no matter who’s at fault. File a claim under your personal injury protection for these expenses. However, New Jersey’s no-fault laws don’t apply to property damage like car repairs, according to the legal website Nolo.
For property damage, New Jersey considers whether drivers are partially at fault under a law called modified comparative fault. Under this law, both drivers are assigned a percentage of fault. Drivers with less than 50% of fault can get reimbursed for damage caused by other drivers.
For example, if you’re 80% responsible for an accident, your insurance will pay 80% of the other driver’s property damage. However, since you’re over 50% at fault, the other driver isn’t required to pay for your property damage.
Cheapest rates by age in New Jersey
Young drivers under age 25 will pay a pretty penny for car insurance in New Jersey. Allstate and USAA run the most competitive rates for most age groups until age 44. However, drivers above age 44 may want quotes from Progressive and Geico.
| Age | Allstate | Progressive | Geico | USAA |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16-24 | $228.56 | $267.82 | $259.21 | $218.86 |
| 25-34 | $162.30 | $189.51 | $168.66 | $152.45 |
| 35-44 | $142.06 | $174.58 | $165.90 | $150.56 |
| 45-54 | $156.79 | $148.47 | $147.24 | – |
Cheapest rates by gender in New Jersey
Men may find their best bet getting a quote from Geico or USAA. However, women could save over $20 per month by going with Allstate, according to these sample quotes.
| Company | Allstate | Progressive | Geico | USAA |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Men | $178.45 | $193.31 | $173.55 | $167.86 |
| Women | $152.91 | $186.29 | $188.02 | $175.01 |
Sample rates in New Jersey from major car insurance companies
Major brands in New Jersey may cost more than what’s average for the state. However, you could go with Allstate and join its Drivewise or rewards programs to lower your costs further.
Drivewise tracks your driving and sets a discount according to how a safe a driver you are.
| Company | Allstate | Progressive | Geico | USAA |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rate | $165.68 | $189.48 | $180.79 | $170.92 |
Best car insurance in New Jersey
Car insurance rates vary wildly in New Jersey, based on your exact car, driving record and address. To get the best value, shop around with both local and national companies. Also, consider a pay-per-mile policy if you use public transportation or don’t drive much.
We recommend starting with these insurance companies. We chose these companies by looking at ratings from J.D. Power, the Better Business Bureau and National Association of Insurance Commissioners. We also considered companies with ample coverage and significant discounts for the best value.
Best for safe drivers: Progressive
Progressive
Finder rating 4 / 5 ★★★★★
Progressive is a big name in car insurance with a myriad of coverage options, including extras for custom vehicle parts, gap or rideshare coverage. It also offers the convenience of keeping all your insurance in one place. If you need something insured, Progressive probably covers it — auto, home, RV, classic car, valuable belongings, business insurance and more.
We've also found Progressive's car insurance rates competitive with other national brands, especially if you're a safe driver. For instance, having a claim-free history could shave up to 31% off your premiums.
Pros
- Third-largest US car insurance company, making it a popular choice
- Competitive rates
- Pricing tool helps you buy a policy that fits your budget
- Save 30% or more by tracking driving or staying claim-free
Cons
- Average customer service
- Slow to respond to complaints
- Must be a 5-year customer to qualify for accident forgiveness
| Telematics | Snapshot |
|---|---|
| Gap insurance | loan/lease coverage |
Best for low mileage: Allstate Milewise
Allstate
Finder rating 4 / 5 ★★★★★
Allstate's pay-per-mile policy could shave 20% off your premiums if you drive under 10,000 miles per year — or over 50% if you drive significantly less than that. Milewise charges a base rate as well as a rate per mile. You'll plug a device into your car to track your driving, and then monitor your mileage in the Allstate app.
Aside from possible savings, you also get a policy backed by one of the largest US auto insurance companies. Allstate brings decades of experience and strong finances to the table.
Pros
- Save 20% or more for driving under 10,000 miles per year
- Pay by the mile and track your mileage in the app
- Offered by a company with 90 years' experience in the industry
- Plugin device alerts you about car maintenance
Cons
- Plugin device uses your car battery
- Not compatible with some older vehicles
- Android users give the app low ratings
| Telematics | Drivewise |
|---|---|
| Gap insurance | Yes |
Best local company: New Jersey Manufacturers (NJM) Insurance
NJM
Finder rating 4 / 5 ★★★★★
New Jersey Manufacturers takes pride in not wooing customers with commercials. Instead, it offers top-notch service at a value that keeps customers happy, a point proven by thousands of nearly 5-star customer ratings.
You won't miss out on coverage either. NJM offers everything from gap and rideshare insurance to extended medical expense limits or a combined single liability limit. Plus, NJM is known for paying dividends regularly — an average of 5% of your premiums each year.
Pros
- High customer satisfaction
- Competitive rates
- Lenient with driving record and credit score
- Pays dividends to customers if NJM makes a profit
Cons
- Slow to respond to some customer complaints
- No app for policy management
7 factors that affect New Jersey car insurance rates
Factors are characteristics specific to you that car insurance companies use to set how much you’ll pay for car insurance. The less risky each of your factors is the less you pay, the riskier you are the more you’ll pay. We’ll break down New Jerseyan’s rating factors to keep in mind.
| Factor | How it affects your rates |
|---|---|
 Age | How old you are is a top factor in determining your car insurance rates. With each passing year, you earn more experience on the road. More experience can equal cheaper rates. Teen drivers pay the most, but rates begin to level off around your 20’s with drivers over 50 paying the least. |
 Gender | New Jersey takes gender into account when determining your rates. Our analysis of Quadrant data found that men under 18 pay 17% more for car insurance compared to women of the same age. But, between 31 and 45, women see rates 5% higher than men. After 45, rates differ between men and women by only 1%, with women on the higher end. |
 Location | Where you live affects your rates, including where you park your car. High theft rates, high traffic and a high number of uninsured drivers could mean higher rates. New Jersey’s vehicle theft rate stands at 115.7 vehicle thefts per 100,000 inhabitants, according to the FBI’s most recent report on vehicle theft rates. That’s well below the national average of 246 vehicle thefts per 100,000 inhabitants. As for uninsured drivers, 3.1% of New Jerseyans on the road are uninsured. That’s the lowest percentage of uninsured drivers in a state across the US according to Insurance Information Institute. |
 Vehicle and mileage | Your car’s make, model and trim directly affect how much you’ll pay for car insurance. Things like its cost, safety ratings, the likelihood of theft and sportiness all help insurers determine its cost to insure. Safer and cheaper vehicles score the lowest rates, with luxury vehicles with higher repair costs resulting in higher premiums. And, the more you’re on the road, the more at-risk you are to get in an accident, which means higher premiums. However, according to the Bureau of Transportation, New Jerseyans drive an average of 42.3 miles per day, that’s higher than the average across the US of 36.1 miles per day. |
 Credit score | New Jersey is one of five states that can’t use your credit score against you when setting rates. This means you won’t be penalized for bad credit, but you also won’t see any favorable rates for holding a high credit score. |
 Coverage | The more coverage you get and the higher limits you choose, the more protection you’ll have and the more you’ll pay in monthly premiums. And, if you opt for full coverage car insurance that includes comprehensive and collision, the amount of your deductible weighs into your costs too, higher deductibles mean lower monthly premiums. |
 Driving Record | The better your driving record, the lower your premium. If you’re in an at-fault accident you could see rates increases from 20% to 50%. And DUI’s in New Jersey can increase your rate by around 47%. These types of violations typically stay on your record for about three years. |
Does New Jersey require SR-22 insurance?
An SR-22 form serves as proof that you’re meeting your state’s minimum insurance requirements, and is typically required if you have serious driving offenses or are deemed a high-risk driver. New Jersey does has minimum liability insurance requirements to be on the road, but doesn’t require SR-22 insurance after violations. Instead, you may be required to pay an annual surcharge for a minimum of three years if you have six or more points on your license, are caught driving without insurance, are convicted of a DUI, or have other serious violations. Learn more about New Jersey’s annual surcharge for high-risk drivers.
Coverage to consider in New Jersey
New Jersey is a no-fault state, and on average, and New Jerseyans drive more than the average American. Understanding the risk factors in your state and knowing your needs can help you choose the right coverage.
New Jerseyans may want more personal injury coverage
In New Jersey, you’re required to carry $15,000 worth of personal injury protection to legally drive – but realistically, this may not be enough to cover serious injuries. To avoid paying excessive out-of-pocket health costs in the event of an accident, more coverage may be wise.
Is comprehensive coverage necessary in New Jersey?
New Jersey has the lowest rate of car theft in the U.S., so adding comprehensive coverage for the sole purpose of protecting yourself from theft doesn’t make much sense. However, comprehensive coverage does more than protect against carjacking. It can help in events such as animal strikes, floods, explosions and fires, falling objects, and much more. Additionally, if you’re financing your car, comprehensive coverage is almost always required anyway.
Consider comprehensive coverage if . . .
- You drive a lot.
- You live in a state with harsh weather.
- You live in a rural area with lots of wildlife.
- You’re financing and your lender requires it.
Collision coverage is worth considering if you drive a lot
New Jerseyans drive more than the average American – and when you drive more, it can mean a high risk of collison. Collision coverage can help repair or replace your vehicle in the event of a vehicle accident, and it’s required by most lenders if you have a car loan.
- You drive a lot.
- You can’t cover major vehicle repairs out of pocket.
- You heavily rely on your car.
- You’re financing and your lender requires it.
Top 10 auto insurance companies in USA that serve New Jersey
We’ve pulled the top 10 companies by market share that offer coverage in New Jersey according to S&P Global. Compare top companies by three major rating agencies along with our overall score.
- Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating measures how a business interacts with its customers, with the highest rating being A++.
- J.D. Power determines customers’ overall satisfaction with their car insurer’s price, billing, claims and customer support. The higher the J.D. Power score out of 1,000, the better.
- NAIC complaint index shows how a company’s number of complaints compares to similar companies of its size. Scores lower than 1.00 show the company receives less than the average number of complaints, and scores above 1.00 show more complaints than average.
- Finder’s score shows you an overall look at the company by taking into account scores from each of these agencies as well as the coverage and discounts each company offers.
 | ★★★★★ 4/5 | |||||
 | ★★★★★ 4/5 | |||||
 | ★★★★★ 4/5 | |||||
 | ★★★★★ 4/5 | |||||
 | ★★★★★ 4/5 | |||||
 | ★★★★★ 4/5 | |||||
 | ★★★★★ 4/5 ; | |||||
 | ★★★★★ 4/5 | |||||
 | ★★★★★ 4/5 | |||||
 | ★★★★★ 3/5 |
Cheapest car insurance in New Jersey
| Company | Average annual rate | Learn more |
|---|---|---|
 | $490 | |
 | $659 | |
 | $705 | |
 | $1,420 | |
 | $1,427 | Read review |
 | $1,728 | |
 | $1,734 | Read review |
 | $7,798 | Get a quote |
Which city has the cheapest car insurance in New Jersey?
Of New Jersey’s largest cities, Toms River has the cheapest rates and Passaic has the most expensive car insurance rates. Passaic drivers could face rates 4 times more than Toms River drivers.
Car insurance quotes in Toms River
| Company | Annual car insurance rate |
|---|---|
| Allstate | $1441 |
| Mercury | $1861 |
| Geico | $969 |
| StateFarm | $1002 |
Car insurance quotes in Lakewood
| Company | Annual car insurance rate |
|---|---|
| Allstate | $1441 |
| Mercury | $2406 |
| Geico | $1154 |
| StateFarm | $1591 |
Car insurance quotes in Passaic
| Company | Annual car insurance rate |
|---|---|
| Allstate | $2277 |
| Mercury | $3067 |
| Geico | $1446 |
| StateFarm | $1876 |
Car insurance quotes in Bayonne
| Company | Annual car insurance rate |
|---|---|
| Allstate | $1905 |
| Mercury | $2137 |
| Geico | $1007 |
| StateFarm | $1522 |
Car insurance quotes in Union City
| Company | Annual car insurance rate |
|---|---|
| Allstate | $2231 |
| Mercury | $2848 |
| Geico | $1306 |
| StateFarm | $1876 |
Compare car insurance providers in New Jersey
Insurance help for low-income drivers
If you meet certain requirements, you might qualify for Special Automobile Insurance Policy (SAIP), New Jersy’s low-cost medical coverage-only policy. The cost is just $360 a year if you pay the entire amount upfront, or $365 if you pay in two installments. Drivers who are enrolled in Federal Medicaid with hospitalization are eligible. And you can obtain a policy through most insurance providers.
Bottom line
Car insurance is legally required in New Jersey and provides a financial safety net in case of a serious accident. Look into your coverage options to find out what’s best for you once you’ve met the legal minimums.
To learn more, from the best discounts and deals on auto insurance to the different rules and regulations across the country, visit the comprehensive guide to car insurance.
- Average Premiums and Expenditures, NAIC, 2018
- Automobile Financial Responsibility Limits By State, III, October 2021
- New Jersey No-Fault Car Insurance, Nolo
- New Jersey Car Accident Laws, Nolo
- Motor vehicle theft rate in the United States in 2020, by state, Statista, 08 October 2021
- Top 10 Highest And Lowest States By Estimated Percentage Of Uninsured Motorists, 2019, III
- State Transportation by the Numbers, BTS
- Largest private auto insurers posted combined ratios under 100% in 2020, Spglobal, May 4 2021
Questions about New Jersey car insurance
More guides on Finder
-
HELOC and home equity loan requirements
Here’s what you need to qualify for a HELOC in 2022
-
How much does gas cost?
Find out gas costs based on your city, state or make and model.
-
Compare crypto lending rates for investors and borrowers
How to get the best crypto rates for your needs and risk tolerance.
-
Utah car accident statistics
Get the scoop on Utah’s latest car crash stats, plus the factors involved.
-
Car insurance costs, affordability by state
Trek through 10 factors that affect car insurance costs and which states have the best and worst affordability.
-
Compare pay-as-you-go and telematics companies
Compare 19 usage-based insurance companies and their key features side by side.
-
The Zebra car insurance review
See real prices from brand name insurance companies in this site’s user-friendly quote tool.
-
Texas car accident statistics
Take care when driving in Texas, the deadliest US state for car accidents.
-
New York car accident statistics
Dive into statistics about fatalities and the types of accidents happening in New York.
-
California car accident statistics 2022
California is one of the deadliest states in the US for car accidents. No joke.
Ask an Expert
Do you insure imported cars?
Hi Fred,
Thanks for reaching out.
You can find imported car insurance by getting several quotes from standard insurers with cover for special vehicles. Then compare these with the quotes provided by specialist insurers.
On the table displayed on the list of car insurance, you should see providers that might cover your imported car.
Cheers,
Joanne