Vanguard vs Nutmeg: Fees, features, and more

Ever wondered who would come out on top in a battle between Vanguard vs Nutmeg? Well, read on to find out how they compare for fees, accounts and plenty more.

Vanguard and Nutmeg are two of the most well-established investing providers available to UK retail investors. They’re slightly different in their approach as Nutmeg is basically a robo-advisor, where as Vanguard offers a platform where you get to hand-pick your index funds or exchange-traded funds (ETFs). However, there is some crossover, so we’re going to pit Vanguard vs Nutmeg against each other in a head-to-head battle.

Both Vanguard and Nutmeg offer a limited range of investments and plenty of account options, including a stocks and shares ISA and a self-invested personal pension (SIPP). So, check out our breakdown of Vanguard vs Nutmeg and hopefully this will help you pick who’s best, depending on what’s most important to you – whether that’s fees, investment choice, account types or anything else.

Nutmeg vs Vanguard: At a glance

NutmegVanguard
Finder score★★★★★★★★★★
Customer satisfaction survey★★★★★★★★★★
Fees score★★★★★★★★★★
Stocks and shares ISA available?
FSCS protected?
Go to site
More Info
More Info

Vanguard and Nutmeg are pretty neck and neck when it comes to their Finder score, with Nutmeg scoring a solid 4.1 out of 5, and Vanguard scoring a slightly higher 4.3 out of 5.

Both platforms offer stocks and shares ISA, and both come with full Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) protection of up to £85,000.

Vanguard and Nutmeg are also both pretty even when it comes to their most recent Finder Investing Customer Satisfaction Awards 2024 results.

However, where the platforms go slightly different ways is with the fees score. When you look at Nutmeg fees vs Vanguard fees – Nutmeg has a score of 4.1 vs Vanguard’s 4.7 score for fees (both out of 5).

Round 1: Products

NutmegVanguard
General investment account
Stocks and shares ISA
Lifetime ISA (LISA)
Pension (SIPP)
Junior ISA (JISA)/Junior SIPP (JSIPP)
Interest on cash balances
Keep in mindCapital at riskCapital at risk
Go to site
More Info
More Info

Both Nutmeg and Vanguard offer a wide range of account options, with plenty of tax-efficient options available.

The only key difference between the two is that Nutmeg offers a lifetime ISA (LISA), but this is something Vanguard doesn’t have in its account lineup.

However, one thing Vanguard has going for it that Nutmeg doesn’t is that Vanguard will pay interest on cash in your accounts. But, this isn’t enough to tip the scales in its favour.

Winner: Nutmeg

Round 2: Investment choice

NutmegVanguard
Investment choice score★★★★★★★★★★
Available markets 1 (global funds)
4+
Number of investments3885+
Number of ETFs/funds3885
Fractional shares
Min. initial deposit£500£500 lump sum (or £100/month)
Min. investment£1 (after initial investment)£100
Keep in mindCapital at riskCapital at risk
Go to site
More Info
More Info

Both Nutmeg and Vanguard offer a limited range of investments. Vanguard has funds you can pick yourself (or a managed stocks and shares ISA for an added fee that basically works like a robo-advisor).

Nutmeg mostly offers ready-made portfolios of funds, as a robo-advisor platform but it did recently add the ability to customise your portfolios by picking from a few thematic investment options.

Nutmeg actually has one of the largest range of portfolios for a robo-advisor, but its investment choice (which is all made up of funds) pales in comparison to Vanguard. The drawback with Vanguard is that you can only use Vanguard funds, but these are some of the cheapest and the best around anyway.

It is a bit easier to get started with Vanguard because you can set up a £100 monthly investment, but you need a £500 lump sum to kick off your Nutmeg portfolio.

Winner: Vanguard

Round 3: Portfolios

NutmegVanguard
Portfolios rating★★★★★★★★★★
Risk assessment quiz
Number of portfolios on offer3821
Ethical portfolios on offer
Managed portfolios on offer
Go to site
More Info
More Info

If we’re just looking at Nutmeg vs Vanguard for the ready-made portfolios available, Nutmeg edges it with 38 options in total.

Vanguard has 5 managed portfolios, 5 LifeStratgey portfolios and 11 target retirement options. Whereas Nutmeg has 10 fully managed portfolios, 10 fixed allocation portfolios, 10 socially responsible portfolios, 5 Smart Alpha portfolios, and 3 thematic portfolios.

Winner: Nutmeg

Round 4: Fees

NutmegVanguard
Fees score★★★★★★★★★★
Platform fees0.25% - 0.75%0.15%
US sharesN/A£0
UK sharesN/A£0
International sharesN/AN/A
Funds/ETFs0.21% – 0.36% (ongoing, plus market spread of 0.04% – 0.09%)
£0
Foreign exchange fee0%0%
Regular investingYesYes
Withdrawal fee£0£0
Deposit fee£0£0
Inactivity fee£0£0
Keep in mindCapital at riskCapital at risk
Go to site
More Info
More Info

Nutmeg offers pretty good value across its portfolios with the fees ranging from around 0.25% to 0.75% for the basic platform fee.

However, even at its cheapest, Nutmeg is still more expensive than Vanguard.

So, when we compared Nutmeg fees vs Vanguard’s, it’s Vanguard that comes out as the winner.

Winner: Vanguard

Round 5: Ease of use

NutmegVanguard
Ease of use score★★★★★★★★★★
Apple iOS rating4.8/54.4/5
Google Play rating 4.4/53.7/5
Ways to contact customer servicePhone, in-app chat, secure messaging, email, post and in-personSecure message, email, phone, chatbot
UI/UXGoodGood
Desktop or web access
Mobile app
Keep in mindCapital at riskCapital at risk
Go to site
More Info
More Info

Neither Nutmeg nor Vanguard offers a particularly fancy investing experience that will blow your socks off.

However, both these platforms offer a robust mobile app and desktop platform for investing. If you want a slicker and simpler mobile experience, you might want to check out some other trading apps that have more bells and whistles.

Nutmeg and Vanguard both try to offer solid but basic customer service and this is how they can try and keep fees low while providing a decent experience.

Winner: Tie

Round 6: Tools, resources and features

NutmegVanguard
Tools, resources and features★★★★★★★★★★
Analysis features
Tools for investing/trading
Social features
Learning resources
Additional features
Keep in mindCapital at riskCapital at risk
Go to site
More Info
More Info

Both Vanguard and Nutmeg have pretty similar offerings when it comes to the investing tools and resources available.

These platforms aim to keep things simple, so you’re not going to find loads of detailed research and analysis here and it’s hard to separate them.

Winner: Tie

Overall winner: Is Vanguard better than Nutmeg?

Vanguard and Nutmeg both offer a fairly limited investing experience with plenty of similarities.

However, the greater investment choice and lower fees offered by Vanguard makes it our winner (which is also reflected in the overall Finder scores).

Winner: Vanguard

All investing should be regarded as longer term. The value of your investments can go up and down, and you may get back less than you invest. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. If you’re not sure which investments are right for you, please seek out a financial adviser. Capital at risk.


George Sweeney, DipFA's headshot
Deputy editor

George is a deputy editor at Finder. He has previously written for The Motley Fool UK, Nasdaq, Freetrade, Investing in the Web, MoneyMagpie, Online Mortgage Advisor, Wealth, and Compare Forex Brokers. He's focused on making personal finance and investing engaging for everyone. To do this he draws from previous work and his Level 4 Diploma for Financial Advisers (DipFA), sharing what he’s learnt. When he’s not geeking out about money, you’ll find him playing sports and staying active. See full bio

George's expertise
George has written 187 Finder guides across topics including:
  • Investing
  • Personal finance
  • Tax
  • Pensions
  • Mortgages

More guides on Finder

  • Moneybox vs Hargreaves Lansdown (HL)

    Hargreaves Lansdown and Moneybox are both investment platforms with a lot to offer. We compare their features, fees, account types and more – side by side in Moneybox vs Hargreaves Lansdown (HL).

  • Moneyfarm vs Hargreaves Lansdown (HL)

    Hargreaves Lansdown and Moneyfarm are both investment platforms with a lot to offer. We compare their features, fees, account types and more – side by side in Moneyfarm vs Hargreaves Lansdown (HL).

  • Vanguard vs Freetrade

    Freetrade and Vanguard are both investment platforms with a lot to offer. We compare their features, fees, account types and more – side by side in Vanguard vs Freetrade.

  • XTB vs Trading 212

    Trading 212 and XTB are both investment platforms with a lot to offer. We compare their features, fees, account types and more – side by side XTB vs Trading 212.

  • Moneybox vs Trading 212

    Trading 212 and Moneybox are both investment platforms with a lot to offer. We compare their features, fees, account types and more – side by side in Moneybox vs Trading 212.

  • InvestEngine vs Trading 212

    Trading 212 and InvestEngine are both investment platforms with a lot to offer. We compare their features, fees, account types and more – side by side in InvestEngine vs Trading 212.

  • InvestEngine vs Vanguard

    Vanguard and InvestEngine are both investment platforms with a lot to offer. We compare their features, fees, account types and more – side by side in InvestEngine vs Vanguard.

  • Robinhood UK review

    Commission-free share-trading app Robinhood has launched in the UK. Our investing expert tried it out – find out the pros and cons.

  • XTB Review 2024

    Find out about the features, fees, and much more in our expert review of the commission-free XTB trading platform.

  • Trading 212 review

    We review the features and costs of Trading 212, an investment platform designed to teach you about investing and lets you buy shares with zero fees.

Go to site