Disclaimer: The partners on Finder's mortgage comparison tables are sorted in alphabetical order.
Key takeaways
- New American Funding wins on lower advertised rates, broader loan selection, and customer service, earning 4.91/5 on Zillow from 8,600+ reviewers.
- Its Non-QM loan accepts alternative documentation, making it a strong choice for self-employed borrowers who can’t qualify through standard channels.
- Rocket Mortgage is available nationwide and offers home equity loans, but doesn’t provide USDA loans or HELOCs and has no physical branches.
- Both require a 620 minimum credit score and carry A+ BBB ratings — get quotes from both, as advertised rates won’t reflect your actual offer.
Our verdict: We pick New American Funding
New American Funding gets our vote on three important criteria: interest rates, loan selection and customer service.
For starters, New American Funding’s advertised interest rates are lower than Rocket Mortgage’s. While a fraction of a percent doesn’t seem like much, it could save you thousands in interest over the long term.
New American Funding also edges out Rocket Mortgage for its bigger loan selection. In particular, we like its Nonqualifying (Non-QM) loan, which accepts alternative documentation — an option that could work well for self-employed people.
Overview: New American Funding vs. Rocket Mortgage
New American Funding |
Rocket Mortgage |
|
| Get rates | See rates | |
| At a quick glance |
|
|
| Loan products offered | Conventional, Jumbo, FHA, VA, Refinance | Conventional, Jumbo, FHA, VA, Refinance, Home equity loan |
| State availability | Not available in: HI, NY | Available in all states |
| Min. credit score | 620 | 620 |
| BBB Rating | A+ | A+ |
| Trustpilot Rating | Great | Great |
| Pros |
|
|
| Cons |
|
|
| More info | Read Review | Read Review |
New American Funding customer reviews
New American Funding gets high praise from customers, earning a 4.91- out of 5-star rating on Zillow from over 8,600 customers as of January 2022. Reviewers report attentive service from their loan officers, who kept them up to date during the entire process. Other reviewers mention being happy with fast closing times and lower-than-expected rates.
While complaints are less common, a few customers mentioned paperwork mix-ups and delays in hearing back from loan officers at the initial stages of the loan application process. To its credit, New American Funding appears to respond to these complaints quickly. Compared to other lenders, its service levels appear to be higher than average.
Rocket Mortgage customer reviews
Rocket Mortgage, previously known as Quicken Loans, gets a 4.48- out of a 5-star rating on Zillow from over 7880 reviewers as of January 2022. Most reviewers mention attentive, personalized service they received from their loan officers, along with fast closing and no paperwork delays. Borrowers also appreciated Rocket Mortgage’s MyQL to track their loan’s progress.
However, some customers report being unhappy about unauthorized credit inquiries during the application process. Some also say that loan advisors were pushy when trying to close a loan. Overall, Rocket Mortgage appears to offer higher-than-average service levels but has a fairly large number of complaints.
Compare your mortgage options
New American Funding and Rocket Mortgage are both highly rated lenders that are popular with thousands of Americans. However, if you’d prefer a fully digital mortgage that doesn’t require you to work with a loan officer and has no origination fees, consider Better or Beeline.
Or, if you’re looking for a specialized loan that neither New American Funding or Rocket Mortgage offers, we suggest Draper & Kramer Mortgage or North American Savings Bank. Both these lenders offer a wide range of loan products and also have excellent customer reviews.
Find your perfect mortgage by comparing these lenders and lender marketplaces. Select See rates to get a personalized quote.
Ask a question
More guides on Finder
-
I Make $70,000 a Year. How Much House Can I Afford? (2026)
A $70K salary can typically support a $190K–$345K home, depending on debt, down payment and how a lender scores you.
-
50-Year Mortgages: Probably Not a Great Idea
Extending a loan that large can mean paying over double the interest, so it’s probably not in your best interest.
-
How to Get Help With Your Mortgage: For Homeowners & Buyers (2026)
Step-by-step guide to mortgage relief, refinance programs and down payment help for homeowners and buyers.
-
Stockman Bank mortgage review
A top agricultural real estate lender, but state availability is limited.
-
Investors Bank mortgage review
An East-Coast-based traditional lender with plenty of mortgage options but an inefficient application process.
-
First Home Mortgage review
Numerous mortgage options, but only for homebuyers in select states.
-
Vanderbilt Mortgage and Finance review
This lender specializes in financing mobile homes, but customer support can be difficult to contact.
-
U.S. Bank mortgage review
This lender offers a wide range of mortgage products, but branch locations are limited.
-
Homepoint Financial mortgage review
This lender offers a wide variety of mortgage products, but your experience may vary.
-
Freedom Mortgage review
A top lender of FHA and VA loans, but customer reviews are very mixed.
