Finder makes money from featured partners, but editorial opinions are our own.

What Happens to Your Money If Your AI Trading Agent Makes a Mistake

An autonomous AI agent gave away a quarter of a million dollars in February after misreading the request. As brokerages roll out agentic trading to everyday investors, the fine print on who eats a costly error is already written, and it isn't the platform.

Finder bot next to trading platform

On February 22, an AI trading bot named Lobstar Wilde meant to send a small crypto tip to a stranger on X. It sent its entire holdings instead: about a quarter of a million dollars, by its own account. The bot, built by an OpenAI employee days earlier with $50,000 and instructed to “make no mistakes,” made the error within three days of going live.

Lobstar Wilde wasn’t connected to a brokerage account, and nobody’s retirement savings were on the line. But the mistake reveals a mechanic that regulators, and now Congress, have been asking about since Robinhood, Public, SoFi, Coinbase and Webull all rolled out AI trading agents to retail customers this year: an autonomous system misreading a plain-language instruction and executing before anyone could stop it. Finder reviewed the publicly available disclosures behind all five platforms to see, in each company’s own words, who’s actually on the hook if an agent gets it wrong.

What SIPC does and doesn’t cover

The first place most investors look is the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC), the nonprofit that insures brokerage accounts. SIPC steps in when a brokerage firm fails and customer assets go missing, covering up to $500,000 per customer, including a $250,000 limit on cash. It does not cover losses caused by a decline in an investment’s value, and it does not cover claims arising from bad or inappropriate investment advice.

If Robinhood or Public went bankrupt tomorrow, the SIPC would work to make a customer whole for missing assets. If an AI agent inside a fully solvent account buys a stock that crashes, or executes a trade the customer didn’t intend, that’s not a missing-assets problem. It’s an investment-decision problem, and SIPC was never built to touch it.

Our picks for the best AI trading platforms

Important information
The probability of a member receiving $1,000 is 0.028%. If you don’t make a selection in 45 days, you’ll no longer qualify for the promo. Members must fund their account with a minimum of $50.00 to qualify. The probability percentage is subject to decrease. Members are only eligible for the Stock Award promotion upon opening their first brokerage account; subsequent cash brokerage accounts are ineligible for the promo, including for members with multiple accounts.

Terms and conditions apply*. For 401k rollovers, existing SoFi IRA members must complete 401k rollovers via this link For SoFi members without a SoFi IRA, a SoFi IRA must first be opened, and 401k rollover must be completed utilizing Capitalize via this link. SoFi and Capitalize will charge no additional fees to process a 401(k) rollover to a SoFi IRA. SoFi is not liable for any costs incurred from the existing 401k provider for rollover. Please check with your 401k provider for any fees or costs associated with the rollover. For IRA contributions, only deposits made via ACH and cash transfer from SoFi Bank accounts are eligible for the match. Click here for the 1% Match terms and conditions.

Must be a SoFi Plus member at the time a recurring deposit is received into your SoFi Active or Automated investing account to qualify. Bonus calculated on net monthly recurring deposits made via ACH and paid out as Rewards Points. See Rewards Terms of Service. SoFi reserves the right to change or terminate this promotion at any time without notice. See terms and limitations. https://www.sofi.com/sofiplus/invest/ #disclaimers

Best for control over automation

Public logo

T&Cs apply

1% match on IRA contributions
  • $0 stock, ETF & option trades
  • Connect Claude, Cursor, Codex & other AI agents
  • Marketplace of ready-made Agents across five investing categories
  • Transparency and control over the automation

Best for plain-language AI trade execution

Webull logo
12 free shares & 1-month complimentary Webull premium
  • $0 stock & options trades
  • Connect ChatGPT, Claude, or any MCP-compatible agent
  • Drafts trade instructions in plain language
  • Preview every order before it goes live

What the fine print actually says: a side-by-side

Reading each platform’s disclosures directly, rather than its marketing pages, reveals a clear pattern: every platform places investment-decision risk on the customer.

PlatformWho bears the risk if the agent errsBuilt-in guardrails
Public (Agents)Customer is solely responsible for determining the suitability of any strategy and for verifying instructions before activationEvery action stays inside a single authenticated brokerage environment; customer approves each Agent before it goes live
SoFi (Composer)
Retail investor makes the ultimate decision on every trade; Composer doesn’t offer recommendations or monitor individual investments unless stated otherwise in writing; any deviation from the AI-generated strategy’s logic is “done at the client’s own risk,” and results are not guarantees of future performanceCustomer sets the trading rules in advance; rules can be backtested against historical data before being turned on
Webull (MCP Server)
Customer solely responsible for verifying order details and monitoring positions; Webull assumes no liability for losses from automated or AI-directed decisionsConnects directly to the primary brokerage account; no separate sandboxed sub-account described in Webull’s own disclosures
Robinhood (Agentic Trading)Customer assumes all risk for agent-executed trades; Robinhood doesn’t control, supervise or audit connected agentsDedicated, separately funded account; push notification per trade; support can compare the instruction given against what the agent actually did; disconnect anytime
Coinbase (Coinbase for Agents)Outputs “may be inaccurate or incomplete” and are “not investment advice”; customer assumes full responsibility for their own trading activityIsolated sub-account; user sets capital limits, asset permissions and trade-size caps
Coinbase (Coinbase Advisor, separate product)Registered as a fiduciary, but still can’t “replace your judgment for your trades”; customer assumes full responsibility for their own trading activityRegistered with the SEC as an investment adviser and with the National Futures Association (NFA) as a commodity trading adviser (CTA); requires user approval before any action is taken

Regulators are already flagging the gap

This isn’t just a concern from outside the industry. The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), the self-regulator that oversees brokerage firms, flagged autonomous AI agents as a top concern in its 2026 regulatory report, warning that poorly designed reward functions could lead an agent to optimize toward decisions that end up hurting the investor.

FINRA’s own framing puts the burden on firms to establish what the report calls a “supervision, governance or model risk management framework” around these tools, not on the technology to police itself. FINRA’s rules are designed to be technology-neutral, meaning they apply to AI tools the same way they’d apply to any other technology a firm uses — but that also means they weren’t written with autonomous, third-party trading agents specifically in mind.

It’s the same gap the House Financial Services Committee asked the SEC to address directly in its own June letter, including who’s accountable when the agent, not the human, is the one making the call, and whether a broker-dealer’s obligations survive once a third-party AI is the one placing the trade. As of this writing, no public SEC response to the letter has been reported.

What this means in practice

The existing protection, SIPC, was designed for a different kind of failure than the one an AI agent can cause. For everyday investors, that puts the real safeguards in the account setup itself: fund a dedicated account with money you can afford to lose entirely, use spending and symbol limits wherever the platform offers them, keep manual trade approval turned on if that option exists, and check the activity feed often rather than setting it and forgetting it.

None of that would have stopped Lobstar Wilde. That bot wasn’t a customer of any of these platforms, and its mistake happened in the seconds before anyone could react. That’s the risk agentic trading is actually asking investors to accept, whether the agent is a hobbyist’s weekend project or the one connected to their brokerage account.

Richard Laycock's headshot
To make sure you get accurate and helpful information, this guide has been edited by Richard Laycock as part of our fact-checking process.
Matt Miczulski's headshot
Written by

Investments editor and market analyst

Matt Miczulski is an investments editor and market analyst at Finder. With over 450 bylines, Matt dissects and reviews brokers and investing platforms to expose perks and pain points, explores investment products and concepts and covers market news, making investing more accessible and helping readers to make informed financial decisions. Before joining Finder in 2021, Matt covered everything from finance news and banking to debt and travel for FinanceBuzz. His expertise and analysis on investing and other financial topics has been featured on Yahoo Finance, CBS, MSN, Best Company and Consolidated Credit, among others. Matt holds a BA in history from William Paterson University. See full bio

Matt's expertise
Matt has written 297 Finder guides across topics including:
  • Trading and investing
  • Broker and trading platform reviews
  • Money management

Ask a question

Finder.com provides guides and information on a range of products and services. Because our content is not financial advice, we suggest talking with a professional before you make any decision.

By submitting your comment or question, you agree to our Privacy and Cookies Policy and finder.com Terms of Use.

Questions and responses on finder.com are not provided, paid for or otherwise endorsed by any bank or brand. These banks and brands are not responsible for ensuring that comments are answered or accurate.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Go to site