Bitcoin vs. Bitcoin Cash: Which will come out on top? | finder.com
bitcoin-vs-bitcoincash-200x200

Bitcoin vs. Bitcoin Cash

Both coins are very similar, but it’s the differences that count.

We know that everyone's situation is unique and we aim to help you find the right product for you. We may receive compensation when you visit our partners' sites or are approved for their products. You can read more about how we maintain editorial independence and how we make money here.

Bitcoin Cash (BCH) is the result of a bitcoin fork. It is extremely similar in many ways to bitcoin (BTC), but Bitcoin Cash has a few technical differences that make a big impact.

One difference, which has many significant follow-on effects, isY the difference in block size. Bitcoin has a 1MB block size, while Bitcoin Cash has an 8MB block size.

This information should not be interpreted as an endorsement of cryptocurrency or any specific provider, service or offering. It is not a recommendation to trade. Cryptocurrencies are speculative, complex and involve significant risks – they are highly volatile and sensitive to secondary activity. Performance is unpredictable and past performance is no guarantee of future performance. Consider your own circumstances, and obtain your own advice, before relying on this information. You should also verify the nature of any product or service (including its legal status and relevant regulatory requirements) and consult the relevant Regulators' websites before making any decision. Finder, or the author, may have holdings in the cryptocurrencies discussed.

Learn more Where to buy

What does block size mean?

Blockchain transactions, such as those done with bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash, are conducted on the blockchain.

You can think of each block as a vehicle that carries transactions to their destination. A transaction is concluded once a block arrives and parks itself in the chain.

If each transaction is a passenger, then bitcoin’s 1MB block size is more like a car, while BCH’s 8MB block size is more like a bus.

Larger blocks can hold more transactions, which helps process them faster.

The pros and cons of a larger block size

A larger block size is good news in that it helps process transactions a lot faster, but it also means a full node takes up a lot more data storage space.

A full node is required to mine on the blockchain. It includes a copy of the entire transaction history for the whole blockchain. So as you can imagine, a larger block size comes with higher hardware and data storage costs.

One of the main arguments against a larger block size is that it leads to increased centralization of a coin, and that the higher hardware costs mean only large mining groups will be able to profitably work on the blockchain.

What a larger block size looks like

It can help to visualize what a larger block size looks like. Here are two snapshots of a few hours in the mempools of bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash. The mempool is where pending transactions are stored while they wait for a miner to hook them up to a block and make the transaction happen.

Specifically, these are what the two mempools were doing between about 4-8 p.m. Eastern time on December 20, 2017.

The bitcoin mempool

btc mempool snip 8am-12pm


The Bitcoin Cash mempool

bch mempool 8am-12pm snip

Source: Johoe’s Mempool Size Statistics


What am I looking at?

Each dip and spike on the top of the mempool shows a block being processed. In bitcoin, the 1MB block size just takes small bites out of the waiting transaction, starting with the ones with the highest fees. But the 8MB block size of Bitcoin Cash takes big chunks out of the mempool.

This is particularly important when there are “larger” transactions going through.

In this case, larger refers to the actual size of each transaction in bytes rather than the value of it. Certain additions like extra encryption will increase the size of transactions, while others like SegWit will decrease the size of each transaction.


Bitcoin vs. Bitcoin Cash

Other differences are in the mining algorithms. At its inception, Bitcoin Cash had an easier mining algorithm.

What's mining difficulty?

Mining difficulty refers to how quickly a block can be discovered and attached to the blockchain. To solve a block, the miner needs to spend processing power on solving a complex math problem.

By making the problem easier, blocks can be mined faster. By making it harder, blocks are mined slower.

On the bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash blockchains, fast and easy blocks are good for transaction times, but not necessarily good for the currency in the long run.

This is because miners are rewarded with newly minted coins for solving these problems and finding new blocks. If it’s too easy, the currency faces escalating inflation rates and gets devalued.

Both BTC and BCH will get considerably more difficult to mine as they get closer to their 21 million coin limit.

For more on bitcoin mining, read our guide.

An easier mining algorithm was deemed to be necessary for BCH to keep a competitive edge against the more-valuable bitcoin and to attract the miners needed to run the network.

Soon this had the unintended side effect of miners dipping in and out of BCH based on whether it was profitable at the time, leading to extremely unpredictable block times. Sometimes blocks would be hours apart (for very slow transactions), and sometimes they would come along within a few seconds of each other (for very fast transactions, but rapid inflation).

In response, BCH introduced a dynamic mining algorithm that would get easier or more difficult as needed. This helped introduce some more consistency to the BCH blockchain and keep more miners working on it.

Which is best?

Each is good at a different thing.

What are the advantages of bitcoin?

The high fees and slow transaction times of the original bitcoin are a deliberate but somewhat unfortunate design choice.

It’s intended to keep the coin rare, challenging and valuable. The bitcoin community and developers are banking on bitcoin being a “store of value” for cryptocurrency as a whole, just like gold underpins the US dollar and other fiat currencies. No one actually uses gold as a currency, but it still offers liquidity and value.

The idea is that bitcoin could be digital gold.

Read our simple guide to bitcoin to find out more.

What are the advantages of Bitcoin Cash?

Bitcoin Cash was deliberately split away from bitcoin by a team that thought high fees and slow transactions would eventually destroy bitcoin. It was deliberately designed to essentially be bitcoin, except easy to send, receive and transact with.

Hence the “cash” part of its name. It was designed to be the spending money next to bitcoin’s gold.

Get to know Bitcoin Cash better with this easy-to-understand overview.


Where can I buy bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash?

Name Product Payment Methods Available Fiat Currencies Available Cryptocurrencies
Cryptocurrency
BTC, XRP, USDT, ETH, NEB, XVG, TRX, NEBL, ETH, NEO, FUN, ETC, BCC, POE, DASH, ELF, ICX, BNB, ZRX, APPC & 80+ more
Trade 60+ cryptocurrency pairs on this up-and-coming exchange based in China. Multi-language support.
Credit card, Debit card, SWIFT, SEPA, Cryptocurrency
USD, EUR, RUB, GBP
BTC, DASH, ETH, XRP, ZEC
Use your USD, EUR or RUB to buy and sell cryptocurrency at competitive exchange rates and with high maximums for verified accounts.
Cryptocurrency
-
BTC, BCH, KCS, DRGN, DBC, XRB, ETH, PRL, LTC, SNOV, DENT, RPX, QLC, NEO, UTK, BNTY, ACT, POE, UKG, LA, LEND, VEN & 50+ more
Browse a variety of coin offerings in one of the largest multi-cryptocurrency exchanges and pay in cryptocurrency.
Cash, BPAY, POLi, Cryptocurrency
AUD
BTC, BCH, ETH, XRP, ADA, XEM, LTC, XLM, MIOTA, TRX, DASH, NEO, XMR, EOS, QTUM, BTG, LSK, ETC, XVG & over 60+ more
CoinSpot is an Australian-based marketplace that allows you to easily buy, sell or trade more than 100 cryptocurrencies.
Credit card, Debit card
AUD, USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, CNY & 50+ more
BTC, BCH, ETH, LTC
Buy and sell bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin and Bitcoin Cash on one of the world's most renowned cryptocurrency exchanges.
Cryptocurrency, Payeer, AdvCash, Perfect Money, Capitalist, QIWI* Only available for RUB deposits
USD, RUB
BTC, BTG, DASH, ETH, LTC, DOGE, WAVES, LSK, BCC, TRX, NANOX, PAC, ZEC, XVG, EOS, ETC, RDD, TOKC, B2X, TTC & 400+ more
Pay in USD, RUB or trade crypto to crypto at this Russian-based cryptocurrency exchange with hundreds of coins listed.
Credit card, Debit card, Cryptocurrency, Perfect Money, SEPA, Wire Transfer, Payza, CryptoCapital, Money Polo, Payeer, Giropay, Yandex Money & more
USD, EUR, RUB, PLN, UAH
BTC, BCH, ETH, ETC, XRP, KICK, DASH, WAVES, ZEC, XMR, LTC, DOGE, USDT
A UK-based cryptocurrency platform that provides buyers with a wide variety of payment options.
Cryptocurrency, Credit card, Bank transfer, Wire transfer
USD, EUR, JPY
BTC
With options to buy bitcoin and popular altcoins through credit card, wire transfer and more, Bitflyer offers users the choice of paying with cryptocurrency or USD, EUR and JPY.
Credit card, Debit card, Neosurf, Cashlib, Trustpay, ePay
EUR, USD, GBP, CNY, SEK, NOK, DKK
BTC, ETH
Buy bitcoin with cash or credit card and get express delivery in as little as 10 minutes.
MoneyGram, Perfect Money, Western Union, Cryptocurrency, OKPAY
USD, EUR, RUB
BTC, ETH, LTC
Buy and sell crypto and other digital currencies on this global fixed-rate exchange.
Credit card, Debit card
USD, EUR, RUB
BTC, BTG, BURST, BYC, CANN, CFI, CLAM, CLOAK, CLUB, COVAL, CPC, CRB, CRW, CURE, CVC, DASH, DCR, DCT, DGB, DMD, DNT, DOGE, DOPE & 140+ more
Use your credit or debit card to buy bitcoin and other cryptocurrency without having to verify your identity.
PayPal, Moneygram, OKPAY, Perfect Money, SEPA, WebMoney, Western Union, Wire Transfer, Paxum, QIWI, Payeer
EUR, USD
BTC, ETH, ETC, ZEC
Cryptonit is a secure platform for trading fiat currency for bitcoin, Litecoin, Peercoin and other cryptocurrencies — delivered to the digital wallet of choice.
Cash, PayPal, Western Union, SWIFT, Flexepin, Gift Cards & more
CAD, USD
BTC, ETH
Buy and sell bitcoin with privacy on this multi-signature, peer-to-peer exchange that supports a wide range of payment options.
Cryptocurrency
-
XLM, BTC, BCH, USDT, OMG, ZRX, KIN, MOBI & more
Stellarport taps into the Stellar Decentralised Exchange to provide buyers and sellers with access to XLM and various other cryptocurrencies.
Bank Transfer, Western Union, MoneyGram
USD
BTC
Buy and sell bitcoin fast through a cash deposit at your local bank branch or credit union, or via a money transfer service.
Cryptocurrency
-
BTC, BTG, ETH, ETC, DASH, XRP, DOGE, XEM, LTC, XLM, NEO, ADA, EOS, QTUM, XMR, TRX, BCC, XVG, LSK, GEO & 250+ more
CoinSwitch allows you to compare and convert over 250 cryptocurrencies across all exchanges.
Cash, Credit card, Debit card
USD, EUR
BTC, ETH
Use USD/EUR to buy bitcoin and Ether with credit card or cash on the Coinmama cryptocurrency exchange.
Cash, Credit card, Cryptocurrency, Debit card, BPAY, Flexepin, Neosurf, Neteller, M-PESA, PayPal, Perfect Money, WebMoney, Western Union, iDEAL, SEPA, Skrill, SWIFT
AUD, USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, CNY & 50+ more
BTC
Trade fiat currency for bitcoin in person or online with this peer-to-peer exchange offering competitive fees and wide delivery options.
Credit card, Debit card
USD, EUR
BTC, BCH, ETH, XMR, ZEC, DASH, XRP, ETC, LTC, DOGE, XLM,1ST, ADX, AMP, ANT, BAT, BCN, BNT, BTG, CFI, CVC & 70+ more
Access competitive crypto-to-crypto exchange rates for more than 35 cryptocurrencies on this global exchange.
Bank account, Credit card, Debit card, eCheck, PayPal
USD
BTC
Buy bitcoin instantly with credit card, PayPal or bank account on this peer-to-peer lending platform.
OKPay, PerfectMoney, Yandex Money, Payeer, QIWI, Cryptocurrency
USD, EUR, RUB
BTC, XRB, ETH, DCN, BCH, NIO, TRX, DASH, COB, DOGE, PRIX, DSR, XCPO, LTC, VERI, LOC, NUA, PKT, PPT, ICO & 80+ more
Supporting over 100 coins, you can exchange a variety of cryptocurrency pairs on this peer-to-peer platform.
Cash, Credit card, Cryptocurrency, Debit card, Flexepin, Neosurf, Neteller, M-PESA, PayPal, Perfect Money, WebMoney, Western Union, iDEAL, SEPA, Skrill, SWIFT
AUD, USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, CNY & 50+ more
BTC
Connect with bitcoin buyers and sellers through this peer-to-peer marketplace that accepts cash, credit and more than 300 other payment methods.
Credit card, Debit card, OKPAY, PayPal, Skrill, SOFORT
EUR, USD, CHF, GBP
BTC
Buy bitcoin through PayPal on one of the oldest virtual currency exchanges in the business.
Cryptocurrency
-
BTC, BTG, DASH, ZET, XVP, XPM, WDC, VTC, VRC, UNO, TROLL, START, SLR, SLG, RDD, QTUM, PPC, POT, OK, NVC, NMC, NLG, NEOS & 25+ more
Trade an array of cryptocurrencies through this globally accessible exchange based in Brazil.
ACH Bank Transfer, Wire Transfer, SEPA * payment methods vary depending on fiat currency
USD, EUR, GBP
BTC, BCH, ETH, LTC
Buy and sell cryptocurrency at this US-based exchange which offers fiat currency payment options, including wire transfer, ACH bank transfer and SEPA.
Cryptocurrency
-
BTC, ETH, XVG, SC, XRP, DOGE, STRAT, XMR, ADA, OMG, ETC, BCC, XLM, DGB, UKG, QTUM, ZCL, RDD, LTC, NEO & 120+ more
Buy from one of the largest crypto to crypto exchanges with a selection of over 190+ cryptocurrencies.
Cryptocurrency
-
BTC, ETH, XRP, DOGE, XLM, ETC, STRAT, LTC, SC, DGB, BCH, LSK, XMR & 50 more
Trade various coins through a global crypto to crypto exchange based in the US.
Electronic Funds Transfer, Wire Transfer, Cryptocurrency
USD
BTC, ETH
Trade bitcoin and Ethereum at a US-based exchange where payments can be made in USD.

Compare up to 4 providers

Name Product Payment Methods Available Fiat Currencies Available Cryptocurrencies
Cryptocurrency
BTC, XRP, USDT, ETH, NEB, XVG, TRX, NEBL, ETH, NEO, FUN, ETC, BCC, POE, DASH, ELF, ICX, BNB, ZRX, APPC & 80+ more
Trade 60+ cryptocurrency pairs on this up-and-coming exchange based in China. Multi-language support.
Credit card, Debit card
AUD, USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, CNY & 50+ more
BTC, BCH, ETH, LTC
Buy and sell bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin and Bitcoin Cash on one of the world's most renowned cryptocurrency exchanges.
Credit card, Debit card, SWIFT, SEPA, Cryptocurrency
USD, EUR, RUB, GBP
BTC, DASH, ETH, XRP, ZEC
Use your USD, EUR or RUB to buy and sell cryptocurrency at competitive exchange rates and with high maximums for verified accounts.
Cryptocurrency, Credit card, Bank transfer, Wire transfer
USD, EUR, JPY
BTC
With options to buy bitcoin and popular altcoins through credit card, wire transfer and more, Bitflyer offers users the choice of paying with cryptocurrency or USD, EUR and JPY.
Credit card, Debit card
USD, EUR
BTC, BCH, ETH, XMR, ZEC, DASH, XRP, ETC, LTC, DOGE, XLM,1ST, ADX, AMP, ANT, BAT, BCN, BNT, BTG, CFI, CVC & 70+ more
Access competitive crypto-to-crypto exchange rates for more than 35 cryptocurrencies on this global exchange.
Cryptocurrency
-
BTC, BCH, ETH, LTC, DOGE, NEO, XMR, POWR, DASH, PIVX, XEM, OMG, GNT & 500+ more
Buy and sell hundreds of cryptocurrencies with minimal verification on this all-in-one, New Zealand-based exchange.
OKPay, PerfectMoney, Yandex Money, Payeer, QIWI, Cryptocurrency
USD, EUR, RUB
BTC, XRB, ETH, DCN, BCH, NIO, TRX, DASH, COB, DOGE, PRIX, DSR, XCPO, LTC, VERI, LOC, NUA, PKT, PPT, ICO & 80+ more
Supporting over 100 coins, you can exchange a variety of cryptocurrency pairs on this peer-to-peer platform.
Electronic Funds Transfer, SEPA, Wire Transfer *payment methods vary per country
USD, EUR, GBP, JPY, CAD
BTC, BCH, ETH, ETC, XMR, DASH, LTC, XRP, XLM, REP, ICN, MLN, ZEC, USDT, GNO, EOS
Exchange multiple cryptocurrencies through a range of payment methods, including Electronic Funds Transfer, SEPA or Wire Transfer.
Cryptocurrency
-
BTC, ETH, XRP, DOGE, XLM, ETC, STRAT, LTC, SC, DGB, BCH, LSK, XMR & 50 more
Trade various coins through a global crypto to crypto exchange based in the US.
Cryptocurrency
-
BTC, BCH, KCS, DRGN, DBC, XRB, ETH, PRL, LTC, SNOV, DENT, RPX, QLC, NEO, UTK, BNTY, ACT, POE, UKG, LA, LEND, VEN & 50+ more
Browse a variety of coin offerings in one of the largest multi-cryptocurrency exchanges and pay in cryptocurrency.

Compare up to 4 providers


Will Bitcoin Cash overtake bitcoin?

No one can say for sure, but you’ll find a lot of strong opinions in both directions. However, bitcoin’s transaction functionality seems to be the main issue.

For example, the first major Bitcoin Cash growth spurt came at the start of November 2017, following the news that the bitcoin B2X hard fork was cancelled. This hard fork was intended to solve some of bitcoin’s transaction problems. When it was called off, people argued that the growth came from users trading their BTC for BCH.

The second major growth spurt came around the end of December 2017 when the bitcoin mempool had been clogged up (as above) for the better part of a month and there was growing dissatisfaction with bitcoin’s yet-to-be-released Lightning Network.

You will need to decide whether bitcoin’s transaction functionality will continue to affect Bitcoin Cash’s growth as well as consider what will happen if bitcoin ever solves these problems.


Frequently Asked Questions

Was this content helpful to you? No  Yes

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder only provides general advice and factual information, so consider your own circumstances, or seek advice before you decide to act on our content. By submitting a question, you're accepting our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.
Go to site