American Express vs Mastercard: Which is best for me?
The positives and negatives depend on how you'll use your Mastercard or Amex card. Make a decision based on what features you need.
While Amex is mostly great for rewards, Mastercard has a much wider choice of cards.
Depending on how much you’re planning on using your card, where you usually shop and what you want to get out of it, you’ll be better off with one or the other. Let’s dig deeper.
What’s the difference between Amex and Mastercard?
Although it may look like they serve the same purpose, Mastercard and Amex are indeed two different things, which is why it’s a bit complicated to compare them.
Mastercard is a card network. It doesn’t issue cards, but it allows them to function by providing the infrastructure they need and it makes money by taking a small fee for every transaction that’s made on the Mastercard network. As you probably already know, your card may be branded Mastercard, but your bank is the one you’ll be dealing with for most credit-card-related queries, from monthly repayments to blocking the card if it gets stolen.
Amex, on the other hand, is both a network and an issuer. If you get an Amex credit card, you’ll only have to deal with Amex: you’ll use the American Express network when making a payment, but Amex will also handle the financial side of things.
How do Mastercard and Amex compare?
Here are some of the things you should be thinking about when choosing between Mastercard and Amex:
- Card acceptance. American Express charges merchants a higher fee, so many don’t take it, especially outside the big cities. A lot of people who have Amex also have a Mastercard or a Visa they can use as an alternative.
- The type of card you need. American Express is great for purchases and rewards, but if you need a balance transfer or a credit builder credit card, you can forget about it. Generally speaking, Mastercard has many more card options, mostly because there are dozens of card issuers (banks) to choose from.
- Eligibility criteria. American Express is known to have somewhat stricter income and credit score criteria, so it may be easier to get a Mastercard if your credit score isn’t ideal. In any case, always use an eligibility checker before applying as it will tell you how likely you are to be accepted without impacting your credit score.
- Rewards. Although it always depends on the card you pick and how much you use it, American Express is known to have the upper hand when it comes to rewards, including great introductory bonuses when you join.
If you’re considering Amex because of rewards but are unsure if it’s really as good a deal as they say, you may want to compare cards using our table. Don’t forget to take a look at annual fees because top rewards cards, be they Amex or Mastercard, usually charge a pretty pricey one.
So, which should I choose if I’m a frequent traveller?
That’s a tricky question. Amex has a nice set of travel partners and you can easily turn your rewards into air miles or hotel stays. If you’re big on British Airways, you may want to take a look at its Amex card, which lets you earn Avios points.
On the other hand, while you may want to use Amex to get travel rewards, it doesn’t necessarily mean it’s the best option to make purchases while you’re travelling. All Amex cards charge a foreign currency transaction fee, normally a 2.99% of the transaction. Fee-free spending abroad is more of a Mastercard thing.
Mastercard also grants you access to its Priceless Cities benefits, which is a series of exclusive experiences and events you can only access with Mastercard.
And again, don’t forget about card acceptance. Depending on where you’re travelling to and how much you like local shops, you may find it difficult to actually use your Amex in some areas.
What protection do Mastercard and Amex offer?
It really depends on the card you’re looking at. Amex usually offers 90-day purchase and refund protection, meaning that if an item you bought has been stolen in the first 90 days, or if you’re having troubles returning it to a shop, you can submit a claim and Amex will refund you.
It also has Fraud Protection Guarantee, which means that if you’re victim of a fraud, you’re not responsible for the payments that are made with your card provided you kept your account safe. Other features, such as travel insurance or concierge services depend on the card you choose.
Mastercard has a whole lot of protection features and benefits, including purchase protection and fraud protection as well, but which ones apply is entirely up to the card’s issuer.
Mastercard pros and cons
- Wider acceptance
- More credit card options and features
- If your credit card issuer has branches, you’ll be able to deal with your credit card in person
- Fee-free foreign currency transaction cards available
- Benefits vary significantly among cards and card issuers so you may need to dig into each card’s terms or contact the provider to learn which benefits you’ll receive
- Rewards programme depends on the card issuer and it’s hard to find one that’s as good as American Express
Amex pros and cons
- Great rewards and perks
- Juicy introductory bonuses
- Has one of the lowest APRs on the market
Cons
- Not all merchants take it
- No physical presence
- Fewer card options, especially for people with less-than-ideal credit scores
The bottom line
There’s a reason Amex equals rewards in people’s minds: its cards are probably the best possible way to get really good quality treats out of your daily spending. However, you should consider the drawbacks carefully before going for it, especially when it comes to card acceptance and especially if the card you’re looking at charges an annual fee. Will you be able to use it enough to make it worth it?
On the other hand, Mastercard is somewhat a safer choice. It’s accepted pretty much everywhere and you can choose among a huge list of cards with different features, including fee-free spending out of the country.
Compare Mastercard and Amex cards by type
More guides on Finder
-
How to buy Sui (SUI) in the UK
This guide provides step-by-step instructions on how to buy Sui, lists some exchanges where you can get it and provides daily price data on (SUI).
-
How to buy Pepe (PEPE) in the UK
This guide provides step-by-step instructions on how to buy Pepe, lists some exchanges where you can get it and provides daily price data on (PEPE).
-
How to buy Arbitrum (ARB) in the UK
This guide provides step-by-step instructions on how to buy Arbitrum, lists some exchanges where you can get it and provides daily price data on (ARB).
-
How to buy SSV Network in the UK
This guide provides step-by-step instructions on how to buy SSV Network, lists some exchanges where you can get it and provides daily price data on (SSV).
-
How to buy USDD in the UK
This guide provides step-by-step instructions on how to buy USDD, lists some exchanges where you can get it and provides daily price data on (USDD).
-
How to buy Blur in the UK
This guide provides step-by-step instructions on how to buy Blur, lists some exchanges where you can get it and provides daily price data on (BLUR).
-
How to buy FLOKI in the UK
This guide provides step-by-step instructions on how to buy FLOKI Inu, lists some exchanges where you can get it and provides daily price data on (FLOKI).
-
How to buy Aptos in the UK
This guide provides step-by-step instructions on how to buy Aptos, lists some exchanges where you can get it and provides daily price data on (APT).
-
How to buy EthereumPoW in the UK
This guide provides step-by-step instructions on how to buy EthereumPoW, lists some exchanges where you can get it and provides daily price data on (ETHW).
-
How to buy Coinbase Wrapped Staked ETH in the UK
This guide provides step-by-step instructions on how to buy Coinbase Wrapped Staked ETH, lists some exchanges where you can get it and provides daily price data on (CBETH).
Ask an Expert