Sign up & start saving!
Get our weekly newsletter for the latest in money news, credit card offers + more ways to save
Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our content.
Prudential vs. Protective Life
When these insurers go head to head, the key differences lie in their policy lineups.
Guides
Coverage
Policy Length
Age
Both insurers are industry giants with the financial ratings and reputations to back it up. But they offer slightly different policies and riders.
What's in this guide?
Life insurance products with Prudential and Protective Life
 Prudential |  Protective Life | |
|---|---|---|
| Term |  | |
| Whole | | |
| Universal | | |
| Variable | | |
| Variable universal | | |
| Indexed universal | | |
| Final expense | ||
| Final expense | | |
Get free life insurance quotes today
Compare affordable quotes from 12+ A-rated life insurance companies side-by-side.
X
Costs
Your premium is a product of your age, gender, occupation and lifestyle. These insurers have similar price points, though you may be charged a higher premium with Prudential.
If you’re a healthy nonsmoker, here’s what you might pay monthly for a $250,000, 20-year term life policy.
| Gender | Age | Prudential | Protective Life |
|---|---|---|---|
| Male | 20 | ||
| Male | 30 | ||
| Male | 40 | ||
| Male | 50 | ||
| Male | 60 |
| Gender | Age | Prudential | Protective Life |
|---|---|---|---|
| Female | 20 | ||
| Female | 30 | ||
| Female | 40 | ||
| Female | 50 | ||
| Female | 60 |
*Based on sample rates from Policygenius, August 2019.
Policy riders
With both insurers, you can add riders to your policy to bridge gaps in your coverage. While they each offer a comprehensive set of riders, Prudential focuses more on living benefits.
Prudential Riders
- Waiver of premium rider
- Accelerated death benefit rider
- Accidental death benefit rider
- Serious illness rider
- Estate planning rider
- Cash value rider
- Disability income rider
- Additional death benefit rider
Protective Life Riders
- Waiver of premium rider
- Accelerated death benefit rider
- Accidental death benefit rider
- Child rider
- Disability income rider
- Term insurance rider
- Guaranteed insurability rider
Financial strength
An insurer’s financial strength rating reveals its claims paying ability. Prudential and Protective Life score top ratings with the major agencies, which means they have the funds to pay out claims for the foreseeable future.
In J.D. Power’s latest life insurance study on customer satisfaction, Protective Life ranked seventh of 23 insurers surveyed, and Prudential followed in eighth place.
| Prudential | Protective Life | |
|---|---|---|
| A.M. Best | A+ (Superior) | A+ (Superior) |
| Moody’s | Aa3 (High quality) | A1 (Good) |
| Standard & Poor’s | AA- (Very strong) | AA- (Very strong) |
| Fitch | AA- (High quality) | A+ (Very high quality) |
| J.D. Power | 3 out of 5 circles or “about average” | 4 out of 5 circles or “better than most” |
Customer reviews and reputation
Protective Life has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau (BBB) for the way it engages with customers. The BBB records 51 complaints in the past three years though, with many people complaining about communication issues. Customers award the company 2 out of 5 stars.
Prudential has an D- rating with the Better Business Bureau while it’s in the process of resolving complaints, and it’s earned 1 out of 5 stars with customers. The BBB files 69 complaints in the past three years, most of which related to billing issues and the claims process.
Bottom line
These insurers have similar rates, riders and reputations. The main difference comes down to the policy options. They offer a range of term and permanent policies, but Prudential sells survivorship over whole life insurance.
To find the insurer that best meets your needs, compare life insurance providers.
Compare life insurance providers
More guides on Finder
-
Compare decreasing term life insurance
Save money by targeting your coverage to your largest debts.
-
How to use life insurance to pay for retirement
A permanent life insurance policy’s cash value can be used as a retirement income supplement, though using it reduces your policy’s death benefit.
-
Whole life insurance vs. variable life insurance
Two permanent life insurance policies that provide lifelong coverage, though variable life is a riskier investment option than whole life.
-
Workers’ compensation vs. life insurance
These coverage options serve different functions but have one benefit in common.
-
Mortgage life insurance vs. term life insurance
Mortgage life insurance may be a good fit for people with serious health conditions, otherwise term life insurance offers more value and flexibility.
-
How to get life insurance as a freelancer
As a freelancer you may have unpredictable cashflow, but you can still find income protection with term life insurance.
-
Survivor benefit plans vs. life insurance
Survivor benefit plans pay out a monthly benefit to your surviving spouse or dependents — you won’t be able to designate any other beneficiary.
-
Life insurance portability vs. conversion
Leaving your job doesn’t have to mean leaving your group life insurance behind.
-
Short-term vs. long-term disability insurance
Short- and long-term disability insurance offers coverage for different amounts of time and replaces a different percentage of your income, but you can buy both if you can afford it.
-
How to combine life and disability insurance
Ensure your loved ones’ financial future is protected with both life and disability insurance.
Ask an Expert