Before there were price comparison sites, the best (and arguably only) way to compare multiple insurers in one fell swoop was to use an insurance broker. These days, price comparison sites have become most people’s first point of call. But if your car insurance needs are complex or you’re insuring a classic, high-powered or unusual car, it could still be worth calling on the specialist expertise of a car insurance broker.
A car insurance broker is an insurance specialist that acts as a middle man between you and insurance companies. Sometimes they’ll be part of a larger firm of insurance brokers. As regulated financial experts, brokers can help you decided what kind of insurance and what level of cover you need. A broker can then search on your behalf for the best car insurance deal, across a range of insurers.
Car insurance brokers work independently of the insurers whose products they recommend. Unlike insurance agents, they’re not tied to a particular insurer.
Some insurance brokers cover the whole of the available car insurance market, whereas others may work with a smaller, select panel of providers. It’s worth checking this before you use a broker.
Insurance brokers must be regulated and authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). They earn their living through the commission they’re paid by insurers when you take out a product on the broker’s recommendation. However, their recommendations should always be based on your individual needs, and not how much money they might make.
Many insurance brokers are members of the British Insurance Brokers’ Association (BIBA), which has a voluntary code of conduct for its members. This states that BIBA members should:
The British Insurance Brokers’ Association (BIBA) is a professional body representing the interests of insurance brokers, intermediaries and their customers.
As well as supporting its members (insurance brokers), it has published a code of conduct that outlines the ways in which it expects its members to behave.
It also has a searchable directory of its members, to help you identify the right broker for your needs.
Maybe. Brokers can certainly take some of the leg work out of comparing insurance deals, because they check what’s on offer from multiple insurers. But, provided your requirements are pretty straightforward, you may be able to get just as good a price (or potentially better) using a price comparison site.
That said, because brokers offer a more personalised service, they can offer a level of reassurance that you are receiving the right type and level of cover at a good price. Especially if you have atypical requirements. And some brokers get special discounts on car insurance from insurers they work with regularly. This may need to be offset against the commission they charge, and which is built into your premium, though.
In many cases, your best bet to secure the right cover at the best possible price will be to compare all of your options. This includes brokers, price comparison sites, and direct-only insurers.
There are a number of risk factors that might mean you find it difficult to get reasonably priced cover via a price comparison site. Risk factors that could make it worth trying a specialist broker include:
You can find a car insurance broker to suit your needs in a few ways. One way is simply to use a search engine to find a suitable broker for your needs. For example, a search for “car insurance broker young driver” show results for, unsurprisingly, brokers that specialise in cover for young drivers.
The downside of this approach is that the results you see may be ranked by the insurers that are best at search engine optimisation, rather than those that are necessarily best for your needs. Plus, while the vast majority of brokers are legitimate, there’s a chance that a rogue, unregulated company may sneak into the search results. You can double check if a broker is regulated on the FCA’s Financial Services Register.
A good alternative is to use BIBA’s search service. You have two options:
At first glance, brokers and insurance comparison sites might seem like they are doing the same thing. After all, both claim to compare insurance policies to help you find the best deal.
But how they approach this is a bit different.
Price comparison sites are a quick and easy way of comparing deals from hundreds of insurers online. And they tend to cover most insurers on the market (with the exception of those that choose not to appear on comparison sites). If your car insurance needs are pretty straightforward, they’re a good way to quickly scan the market.
However, the policies on offer via price comparison sites tend to be standardised policies. Remember being asked to tick a box to confirm the range of assumptions a comparison site has made about you? That’s because, in order to offer a simple service, price comparison sites rely on you meeting certain, generic criteria. If your circumstances aren’t quite “standard” (for example, you’re still putting in the miles aged 100+, or you need to use your car for business purposes), you might find it difficult to get a suitable, reasonably price policy on a price comparison site.
Brokers tend to offer a more bespoke service. Often, you’ll need to speak with them on the phone or in person, rather than filling in a generic form online. Brokers may work with fewer insurers than a price comparison site, so it’s worth checking the details of their insurer panel before using them. But they can cater to more specialist needs, and the insurers they do work with may offer lower prices via the broker than you can get elsewhere. So, if your car insurance needs are a bit unusual, a broker could be a better bet than a price comparison site.
There are a few key advantages to using a car insurance broker.
Brokers have the knowledge and experience to offer guidance on the right products and level of cover for your needs. If you have any questions, they’ll be in a good position to answer them.
A broker will ask you about your personal circumstances to find you the right policy. They’ll know the right insurers to go to for your specific risk profile. They may also have access to policies that aren’t available via a price comparison site. Brokers can sometimes also be more flexible on policy features and price than comparison sites.
If you need to make a claim, your broker might be able to speak to loss adjusters and claims departments on your behalf. They’ll know the steps to follow to minimise the risk of your claim being rejected, and can take some of the hassle away at a stressful time.
While using a broker can have a number of advantages, there are a few potential downsides. They include:
A more limited range of insurers
Many brokers use a panel of insurers, rather than covering the whole of the market. So there’s a chance you may never be told about some good options. Plus, some insurers opt never to make their products available through brokers (or indeed comparison sites). So to get a complete picture of your insurance options you may need to check several brokers and still go to some insurers directly.
Commission charges can (sometimes) bump up the premium
A broker’s commission will be included in the premium you’re quoted, which in some cases may increase the quote compared with going direct. However, this may be offset by the broker getting a preferential deal from the insurer. To be sure, you could also get a quote directly from the insurer recommended by the broker. Just make sure you are comparing like with like.
You might not need to use a broker
If your needs are straightforward, you can probably get a decent deal online via a price comparison site.
You may find a very small smattering of car insurance brokers that choose to feature on price comparison sites. But it’s not always easy to tell brokers from actual insurance companies. And the products shown on price comparison sites are unlikely to include more bespoke policies.
Plus, because they tend to focus on less standardised insurance, the majority of car insurance brokers won’t be on price comparison sites. Instead, you typically have to call or email them directly.
So, in short, there’s no quick and easy way of comparing all of the car insurance brokers on the market at once. Your best bet might be to select around 3 brokers that look like they cater to your circumstances, and get quotes from each of them.
If your car insurance requirements are straightforward and you know the type of cover you need, a price comparison site is a great way to scan the market and secure the right cover at the best price. But the standardised policies available via price comparison sites sometimes don’t cater as well to unusual risk factors. If you drive a classic, high-end or particularly powerful car, or your personal circumstances make you a higher-risk driver, the expertise of a car insurance broker could help you get a better deal.
Find out the cost and car insurance group of a Mini Cooper S and see how much you could pay based on age, location and model.
Find out the cost and car insurance group of a Smart car, and see how much you could pay based on age, location and model.
Find out the cost and car insurance group of a Mini One, and see how much you could pay based on age, location and model.
Find out the cost and car insurance group of Jaguar I Pace, and see how much you could pay based on age, location and model.
Find out the cost and car insurance group of a Jaguar E Pace, and see how much you could pay based on age, location and model.
Find out the cost and car insurance group of Cupra born, and see how much you could pay based on age, location and model.
Find out the cost and car insurance group of Mini clubman and see how much you could pay based on age, location and model.
Find out the cost and car insurance group of a Cupra Formentor, and see how much you could pay based on age, location and model.
Find out the cost and car insurance group of Porsche Macan, and see how much you could pay based on age, location and model.
Find out how agreed value car insurance works and if it’s the right option for you.