Bitcoin mining - can it still be profitable? | finder.com
finder.com
US
AU
NZ
UK
CA
SG
More

Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our content.

Bitcoin mining: Can I make money doing it?

Mining helps keep the bitcoin blockchain secure — but it's rarely profitable.

Kevin Joey Chen
Kevin Joey Chen

Updated

Fact checked
Disclaimer: This information should not be interpreted as an endorsement of cryptocurrency or any specific provider, service or offering. It is not a recommendation to trade.
Unlike regular fiat currencies (such as US dollars or euros) bitcoin assets are not controlled by a central government or bank, and new bitcoin (BTC) cannot be printed and issued like paper money. Instead, bitcoin tokens are introduced into the market via a process known as “mining”. BTC are awarded to the miners who have solved the math problems necessary to verify bitcoin transactions.

In this guide we’ll look at how mining works, why it’s a necessary component of bitcoin infrastructure, and whether it’s a good way of making a buck.

Must read: Cloud mining warning

Cloud mining will almost never be profitable. This is because the breakeven point, where you make as much money from cloud mining as you put into it, will keep moving backwards and you’ll typically never be able to reach it.

The reason it moves back is because Bitcoin mining difficulty tends to rise over time, especially as Bitcoin prices do. This means the amount of Bitcoin you get from cloud mining will usually decrease over time, which pushes back the breakeven point. Bitcoin mining difficulty will usually only drop if Bitcoin prices do, but if that happens then your Bitcoin is worth less, which also pushes back the breakeven point.

As such, even if a cloud mining contract looks like it will be profitable, you’re still more likely to lose more than you earn.

In the rare cases where a cloud mining contract turns out to be profitable, it will have been more profitable to simply buy cryptocurrency instead of mine it.

What's in this guide?

Compare bitcoin cloud mining providers

Name Product Payment Methods Payment Currencies Mineable Coins
Hashflare Cloud Mining
Hashflare Cloud Mining
Credit card (VISA/Mastercard), Wire transfer
USD, EUR
BTC, DASH, ETH, LTC, XMR, ZEC
Genesis Mining
Genesis Mining
Credit card (VISA/Mastercard), Cryptocurrency
USD, BTC, LTC, DOGE, DASH
BTC, DASH, ETH, LTC, XMR, ZEC
loading

Compare up to 4 providers

What is mining?

Whenever a transaction is made in bitcoin, a record of it is made on a block containing other recent transactions, like a page in a ledger. Once the block is full, bitcoin miners compete against each other to verify and validate the block and all its transactions by solving a complex cryptographic problem.

The first miner to accomplish this is awarded a set amount of bitcoin, based on the mining difficulty at the time. The verified block is then added to the blockchain, a history of all blocks verified since the beginning of bitcoin, and transmitted to all users of bitcoin so that they can have the latest blockchain.

For a more detailed explanation of the blockchain, check out our guide here.

Proof of work

At the heart of bitcoin mining lies a hard, mathematical problem. The goal is to ensure that the process of adding a new block to the blockchain requires a lot of work. That helps to ensure that any hacker tampering with the transactions needs not only to mess with the transactions but also win the “race” of bitcoin mining.

So how does it work?

Basics of cryptography

SHA-256 – the mining algorithm used by bitcoin – is a one-way cryptographic algorithm. When you pass a word through SHA-256 you will be given back an unrecognizable string of letters and numbers called a “HASH”.

For example, the SHA-256 of the word “BUTTERFLY” (source) is “8c62ace4f9ef8ccd08ca6fb992a8524bb7dbdc0530654bd254c9da07a660949a” (HASH). This seemingly random string of letters and numbers has three important properties:

  1. Only the word “BUTTERFLY” will ever give that specific HASH.
  2. The word “BUTTERFLY” will always give back that exact HASH.
  3. There is no way of figuring out the word “BUTTERFLY” if you only know the HASH.

With this information, we can now start piecing together the mining process.

The mining process

Bitcoin mining involves three variables: the block, the mining difficulty and a random number. Here’s how it all comes together:

Imagine our block consists of the word “BUTTERFLY” discussed earlier. In reality, the block would contain a list of recent, unverified transactions, but let’s keep it simple. In order for the block to be solved, bitcoin uses a deceptively simple test: If the HASH result of the block starts with a certain number of zeros, the block is considered verified. This number of zeros is the “mining difficulty” and is increased as more miners join the bitcoin network. For our example, let’s say that we have a mining difficulty of just two, ie, our HASH must start with two zeros.

The problem: “BUTTERFLY” will always return the same HASH, and it doesn’t start with two zeros. So what we need is the third variable, a random number (called a NONCE). We take this number, combine it with “BUTTERFLY”, and HASH again. If it doesn’t start with two zeros, we change the number and try again, and because changing one small number changes the whole HASH result, there is no way to predict the number we’ll need to solve this!

We repeat this process over and over until we find a number that, when combined with “BUTTERFLY”, gives us a HASH that starts with two zeros. That number is the solution to the block. Here are some tries:

SourceHash
BUTTERFLY0d5323edd7edbefa4ea
f479576dbec336329c9b3ee
2733a961c36827013a93fd6
BUTTERFLY1f9c569a7f73712fcba
cf2eb3c9a52104af523b8e
bcbf3a08480be1213016f5e3
BUTTERFLY2880207ac39840e8575
515f31d9a748dc2130d67
8dbc51d43059f70421099e4e1
BUTTERFLY3d99f664274ca90f08a
b9ce9e44db06822b8acc49
f652dd46213a2bb0deef8b58
BUTTERFLY442a166008dd1f2c431
2eff11b707bae61d87738d
1d568e66a95fa2fcd53d45c0
BUTTERFLY5f212c60594fe43cb9
cdae6f7e4b44bb870ce17
84ecd77d76d6074c07cd895f84
BUTTERFLY6a4aef6d35da553583f
f4a6ce6e772eb4683d8fbd
c6e7eda75cf1a26b44f63135

This arduous process of randomly trying to find a number that gives the solution is what makes bitcoin mining such a computationally expensive process and as more miners join the network the harder it gets. As of November 2017, a regular home computer working alone, ie, not an application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC) and not part of a cloud mining network, would take 2.7 millionyears to mine one block.

This has led to the rise of ASIC computers built specifically for mining, and to an increase in cloud mining.

Evolution of the mining computer

  • CPU mining. In the early days of bitcoin, mining difficulty was low and not a lot of miners were competing for blocks and rewards. This made it worthwhile to use your computer’s own central processing unit (CPU) to mine bitcoin. However, that approach was soon replaced by GPU mining.
  • GPU mining. A graphics processing unit (GPU) is a powerful processor whose sole purpose is to assist your computer’s graphics card in rendering 3D graphics. GPUs are not built for executive decisions (like CPUs) but to be very good laborers, hence GPUs are able to execute over 800 times more instructions in the same amount of time as a CPU. Mining is a repetitive process that does not require any intelligent decisions, leading to GPUs replacing CPUs in the mining world.
  • FPGA mining. Next came mining with field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs). These greatly outperformed GPUs and CPUs in the mining process as FPGAs are processors that can be programmed to execute specific instructions, and only those instructions (instead of being repurposed for mining, like GPUs were).
  • ASIC mining. Similar to FPGAs, application-specific integrated circuits are chips designed for a specific purpose, in our case mining bitcoin, and nothing else. ASICs for bitcoin were introduced in 2013 and, as of November 2017, they are the best processors available for mining bitcoin and they outperform FPGAs in power consumption.
  • Mining pools. To offset the difficulty of mining a block, miners started organizing in pools or cloud mining networks. Whenever a miner in one of these pools solves a block, the reward is shared with everyone in the pool in a ratio representative of how much work you put into the pool (even though you personally never solved the puzzle).
  • Cloud mining. Clouds offer prospective miners the ability to purchase mining rigs in a remote data centre location. There are many obvious advantages, the most obvious being: no electricity costs, no excess heat, and nothing to sell when you decide to hang up your virtual pickaxe.

Bitcoin computer mining

Where do I store my mined bitcoin?

Once miners receive bitcoin, they are given a digital key to the bitcoin addresses. You can use this digital key to access and validate or approve transactions.

You can keep these digital keys safe with a number of wallet options:

  • Desktop wallets. Software like Bitcoin Core allows you to send and store bitcoin addresses and also connects to the network to track transactions.
  • Online wallets. Bitcoin keys are stored online by exchange platforms like Coinbase or Circle and can be accessed from anywhere.
  • Mobile wallets. Apps like Blockchain store and encrypt your bitcoin keys so that you can make payments using your mobile device.
  • Paper wallets. Some websites offer paper wallet services, generating a piece of paper with two QR codes on it. One code is the public address at which you receive bitcoin and the other is your private address you can use for spending.
  • Hardware wallets. You can use a USB device created specifically to store bitcoin electronically and your private address keys.

Are people still making money mining bitcoin?

Making money mining bitcoin is much more difficult today. Some of the issues contributing to this difficulty include:

  • Hardware prices. The days of mining using a standard CPU or graphic card are gone. As more people have begun mining, the difficulty of solving the puzzles has too increased. ASIC microchips were developed to process the computations faster and have become necessary to succeed at mining today. These chips can cost $3,000 or more and are guaranteed to further increase in cost with each improvement and update.
  • Rise in corporate miners. Hobby miners must now compete with for-profits — and their bigger, better machines — when mining to make a buck.
  • Puzzle difficulty. Bitcoin’s protocol adjusts the computational difficulty of the puzzles to finish a block every 2,016 blocks. The more computational power put toward mining, the more difficult the puzzle.
  • Power costs. Power in the United States is more expensive than it is in other parts of the world, making it further difficult to compete with big-miner money.

When discussing the feasibility of bitcoin mining, an unexpected variable rears its head: power consumption. This catches a lot of prospective miners off-guard. After all, we rarely consider how much power our electric appliances are consuming. But computing hashes is a very intensive process, pushing whatever processor you’re using to the limit, and to its maximum power consumption. So the question we have to answer is this: will the small reward you earn from bitcoin mining be enough to offset the cost of power consumed?

If you’re using CPU/GPU/FPGA to mine, the answer is a definite no. As of November 2017, the BTC reward is so small that it doesn’t pay for the energy your computer will consume to verify a block.

This leaves us with Pools, ASICs and Cloud Mining. If you’re not willing to put a lot of money into setting up a mining operation, your best bet could be to get a cloud mining rig. These are relatively low cost, and require no hardware knowledge to get started, no extra electricity bills, and you won’t end up with a machine you can’t sell when bitcoin mining is no longer profitable.

Compare bitcoin marketplaces

Name Product Deposit methods Fiat Currencies Cryptocurrencies
eToro USA Cryptocurrency Trading
eToro USA Cryptocurrency Trading
Wire transfer, Online banking
USD

14
cryptocurrencies

Disclaimer: eToro USA LLC does not offer CFDs and makes no representation and assumes no liability as to the accuracy or completeness of the content of this publication, which has been prepared by our partner utilizing publicly available non-entity specific information about eToro. Your capital is at risk.

Copy the trades of leading cryptocurrency investors on this unique social investment platform. Non-US residents can read our review of eToro's global site here.
Go to site
View details
Gemini Cryptocurrency Exchange
Gemini Cryptocurrency Exchange
Bank transfer (ACH)
USD, AUD, CAD, EUR, GBP, SGD, HKD

26
cryptocurrencies

Trade bitcoin, Ethereum and more at a US-based exchange where payments can be made in USD.
Go to site
View details
Coinbase Digital Currency Exchange
Coinbase Digital Currency Exchange
Bank transfer (ACH), Credit card, Debit card, Bank transfer (SEPA), Wire transfer
USD, EUR, GBP, CAD, MXN, HRK, CZK, DKK, CLP, BGN & 10+ more

43
cryptocurrencies

Buy and sell major cryptocurrencies on one of the world's most renowned cryptocurrency exchanges.
Go to site
View details
Crypto.com App
Crypto.com App
Credit card, Cryptocurrency, PayPal, TransferWise, SEPA
USD, AUD, CAD, CHF, EUR, GBP, NZD, SGD, JPY, ZAR & 9+ more

68
cryptocurrencies

Finder Exclusive: Get 0% fees on credit/debit card purchases for 30 days after signup.
Buy 80+ cryptocurrencies, earn up to 8% p.a. on holdings, pay with your crypto for cashback at stores, get loans and more with this complete crypto-finance platform.
Go to site
View details
KuCoin Cryptocurrency Exchange
KuCoin Cryptocurrency Exchange
Cryptocurrency, Interac e-Transfer, PayPal, Wire transfer, Credit or Debit Card
USD, EUR, GBP, RUB, CNY, AUD, KRW, JPY, TRY, VND & 40+ more

211
cryptocurrencies

Finder Exclusive: Get up to 10 USDT in trading fee rebates for signing up and making a deposit, and up to 30 USDT in trading fee rebates after buying with fiat. T&Cs apply.
Browse a variety of coin offerings in one of the largest multi-cryptocurrency exchanges and pay in cryptocurrency.
Go to site
View details
CEX.IO Cryptocurrency Exchange
CEX.IO Cryptocurrency Exchange
Bank transfer, Credit card, Cryptocurrency, SWIFT, SEPA, Faster Payments (FPS)
USD, EUR, GBP, RUB

22
cryptocurrencies

Disclaimer: Highly volatile investment product. Your capital is at risk.
Use your USD, EUR or RUB to buy and sell cryptocurrency at competitive exchange rates and with high maximums for verified accounts.
Go to site
View details
Coinmama Cryptocurrency Marketplace
Coinmama Cryptocurrency Marketplace
Bank transfer, Credit card, Debit card, SWIFT, SEPA
USD, EUR, AUD, CAD, GBP, JPY

10
cryptocurrencies

Founded in 2013, CoinMama lets you buy and sell popular cryptos with a range of payment options and quick delivery.
Go to site
View details
Kraken Cryptocurrency Exchange
Kraken Cryptocurrency Exchange
Bank transfer, Cryptocurrency, SWIFT, Wire transfer, Osko, SEPA
USD, EUR, GBP, JPY, CAD, CHF, AUD

53
cryptocurrencies

Buy, sell and trade a range of digital currencies on this high-liquidity exchange – suitable for beginners right through to advanced traders.
Go to site
View details
Paxful P2P Cryptocurrency Marketplace
Paxful P2P Cryptocurrency Marketplace
Bank transfer, Cash, Cryptocurrency, PayPal, Credit or Debit Card, Payoneer
DZD, XCD, ARS, AMD, AWG, AUD, AZN, BSD, BHD, BDT & 140+ more

2
cryptocurrencies

Connect with bitcoin buyers and sellers through this peer-to-peer marketplace that accepts cash, credit and more than 300 other payment methods.
Go to site
View details
CoinSwitch Cryptocurrency Exchange
CoinSwitch Cryptocurrency Exchange
Credit card
USD, JPY, RUB, EUR

387
cryptocurrencies

CoinSwitch allows you to compare and convert over 250 cryptocurrencies across all exchanges.
Go to site
View details
loading

Compare up to 4 providers

Bottom line

The rising costs of mining effectively and competing against large mining pools have made it harder for the hobbyist to profit on mining bitcoin.

It’s virtually impossible to mine enough bitcoin to recoup your initial cost of equipment and electricity. But if you’re not so concerned about making a buck, you could have fun panning for this cool currency.

FAQs

Disclaimer: Cryptocurrencies are speculative, complex and involve significant risks – they are highly volatile and sensitive to secondary activity. Performance is unpredictable and past performance is no guarantee of future performance. Consider your own circumstances, and obtain your own advice, before relying on this information. You should also verify the nature of any product or service (including its legal status and relevant regulatory requirements) and consult the relevant Regulators' websites before making any decision. Finder, or the author, may have holdings in the cryptocurrencies discussed.

More guides on Finder

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder.com provides guides and information on a range of products and services. Because our content is not financial advice, we suggest talking with a professional before you make any decision.

By submitting your comment or question, you agree to our Privacy and Cookies Policy and finder.com Terms of Use.

Questions and responses on finder.com are not provided, paid for or otherwise endorsed by any bank or brand. These banks and brands are not responsible for ensuring that comments are answered or accurate.

2 Responses

    Default Gravatar
    SauhardJanuary 23, 2019

    if I buy a processor of mining, what’s next? How to proceed further? What else hardware needed and other things?

    Reply
      Avatarfinder Customer Care
      JoshuaJanuary 27, 2019Staff

      Hi Sauhard,

      Thanks for getting in touch with finder. I hope all is well with you. :)

      After buying the necessary processor, you would need a computer. However, as what our guide mentioned, it is not worth it anymore to mine bitcoin by yourself. The cost outweighs the gain. However, you are still interested in going it alone, you would need to seek bitcoin mining hardware manufacturers. You can easily find them by doing a quick search on the Internet.

      Alternatively, you may consider buying Bitcoin cloud mining contracts. This can simplify the process, but of course, it comes with some levels of risk since you do not control the actual physical hardware.

      Please make sure you weigh the pros and cons of your decision before making an investment to ensure that you understand the risk involved.

      I hope this helps. Should you have further questions, please don’t hesitate to reach us out again.

      Have a wonderful day!

      Cheers,
      Joshua

      Reply
Go to site