If you’re thinking of opening a stocks and shares ISA, you might be wondering whether it’s best to go it alone with a DIY ISA, or to get someone to manage it for you. There are pros and cons to both options. If you’re considering the managed stocks and shares ISA route, read this guide first so you understand your options.
If you’ve read our introductory guide, you’ll already know that a stocks and shares ISA is a type of ISA that lets you hold investments, such as funds or stocks and shares, and pay no tax on your investment returns.
A managed stocks and shares ISA is a version of this whereby a portfolio manager selects and manages your stocks and shares portfolio on your behalf. The alternative to a managed stocks and shares ISA is a DIY stocks and shares ISA. As the name suggests, with a DIY ISA you pick the specific assets you want to invest in yourself, and decide when (and how much) to buy and sell.
Typically, the extra work involved for them in a managed stocks and shares ISA means that providers will charge higher fees than for a DIY version.
While you won’t be responsible for choosing specific assets or balancing your portfolio over time, the manager won’t make their initial investment selection without any input from you. Depending on how the managed ISA works, you’ll either pick a type of portfolio (cautious, or moderate risk, for example) or answer some questions that help the manager make their selections based on your circumstances and appetite for risk.
While the detail may be different, typically you’ll go through the following basic steps:
We say “sit back”, but don’t detach yourself entirely from proceedings. You’ll need to keep an eye on your investments on an ongoing basis, to monitor performance and where your money’s been invested. If you have concerns about either, it’s better to flag this to the stocks and shares ISA provider sooner than later.
You can choose between different types of managed stocks and shares ISA, depending on your preferences. And, unfortunately, your budget, as some options are pricier than others. In each case, as time goes on the make-up of your stocks and shares ISA will be periodically balanced by the manager to ensure it continues to meet the criteria you’ve selected (low-risk, for example).
This is the most affordable, but least nuanced, form of managed stocks and shares ISA. Ready-made portfolios are bundles of investments that are put together by experts. They’re diversified, in that they hold lots of different assets that are pre-selected to suit different customer profiles. Often, you’ll need to choose the portfolio that sounds best for you by reading the blurb about it. Your chosen platform may offer quick questionnaires or other tools to help guide your decision.
Some platforms will let you tweak the details of your portfolio – by asking to invest more in one asset and less in another, for example. Others are less flexible – everyone who picks the same portfolio will get the same balance of assets.
A step up from simply choosing your own ready-made portfolio, and typically pricier as a result, are robo-advisors.
There are 2 key differences between robo-advisors and the ready-made portfolios offered by regular investment platforms. Firstly, robo-advisors may have a larger range of portfolios, including additional options such as ethical portfolios or portfolios that focus on tech firms. That’s because they usually don’t offer a DIY option, so portfolios are their bread and butter.
Secondly, rather than choosing a portfolio based on the blurb about it, a robo-advisor will typically guide you towards a suitable option by asking you to fill in an online questionnaire about your risk appetite, how comfortable you are with different styles of investing and levels of loss, and potentially your investment goals. You don’t have to go with the recommendation, if you don’t think it’s quite right. Ultimately the choice is yours.
While the initial recommendations will be made by a “robot” (essentially a clever algorithm that analyses your answers), a human committee behind the robo-advisor will decide on how money is allocated to funds in the different portfolios and rebalance customer portfolios periodically.
All investing should be regarded as longer term. The value of your investments can go up and down, and you may get back less than you invest. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. If you’re not sure which investments are right for you, please seek out a financial adviser. Capital at risk.
As with any type of investment, you can employ a human financial adviser to gather a detailed picture of your risk appetite, goals and personal circumstances, recommend a bespoke stocks and shares ISA portfolio and – if you wish – invest and manage your money on your behalf.
This approach is likely to be much more tailored and flexible, as the adviser will be able to take a holistic approach to the questions they ask and your wider personal circumstances and preferences. But you’re likely to pay a pretty penny for this, and may need to have a fairly high minimum amount to invest (across your stocks and shares ISA and any other accounts) for the adviser to take you on.
Without wishing to sound like a broken record (we know we answer a lot of questions this way): it depends! Neither is better or worse, it’s all about what’s best for you.
A managed stocks and shares ISA might be better suited to those new to investing and/or short on time, as it takes the effort and hassle out of choosing and balancing the assets in a portfolio. But you may need to accept higher fees.
If you are experienced with managing your own investments, or have the time, inclination and confidence to give it a try, opting for a DIY stocks and shares ISA will give you more control and could save you money.
Any investment portfolio, managed or not, carries some risk. That’s just the nature of investing. While there’s the potential for higher returns than with cash savings, the trade-off is that that value of your investments can go down as well as up and the money you pay in (your capital) is at risk.
So then you might ask: are managed stocks and shares ISAs riskier than DIY stocks and shares ISAs? The answer to this is a bit more nuanced. Firstly, it depends on the risk level of the portfolio you choose. Some certainly pose more risk than others, but may also net you higher rewards if things go well.
Secondly, there’s the question of whether it’s riskier to choose and manage your own investments than to leave it to a professional. If you’re fairly new to investing, the idea of choosing your own investments can be daunting. Plus, there’s arguably a greater chance you’ll make poor choices (initially, at least), or fail to create a diverse enough portfolio. In theory, at least, an experienced account manager should have the knowledge and expertise to make better choices, in line with your risk appetite. They’ll ensure your portfolio is diversified, and balance it as time goes on.
But this doesn’t completely eliminate the risk that they’ll make decisions that don’t work out, even if they seemed sound at the time. And nobody, amateur or professional, has a crystal ball to predict how markets will behave in the future.
If you’re not confident about managing your own investments, or simply don’t have enough time to do the legwork required to choose individual investments and buy and sell them to keep your portfolio balanced, a managed stocks and shares ISA could be suitable.
If, on the other hand, you enjoy getting into the nitty gritty of investments and appreciate nuanced control, you might be better off with the DIY approach.
If you decided to go for a managed account, you’ll need to spend a bit of timing picking the right provider for you. Things to consider include:
Managed stocks and shares ISAs can be simpler and less time-consuming than DIY alternatives, but they do mean you’ll be surrendering control of your investments to a third party. They can be more expensive too. These factors mean they won’t be right for everyone, so consider your options carefully before making a final decision.
Have a look at our table of providers that will invest on your behalf – you’ll be able to choose between portfolios that have been made by professionals and will be fully managed going forward.
How compound interest can make your stocks and shares investments grow faster than they would do otherwise.
Discover how tax on stocks and shares ISA dividends works if you’re holding this type of investment.
Should you hold your investments in an ISA, a general account, or both? Here’s the lowdown on your options.
Find out the best performing stocks and shares ISA funds year-to-date, annually and over the last 5 years.
If you want or need to take money out of a stocks and shares ISA, make sure you’re aware of the rules and implications.
Stocks and shares ISAs can help you maximise investment returns – but they come with strings attached. We explain one of the key restrictions.
Use it or lose it: We explain why the stocks and shares ISA deadline matters if you want to maximise your tax-free investment allowances.
Looking to invest in an ISA and not sure of the difference? Read our guide as we look at the pros and cons of each and how to invest.
We look at how many people are paying tax, where the UK’s tax revenue comes from and what the money is spent on.