Finder makes money from featured partners, but editorial opinions are our own. Advertiser Disclosure
A type of retirement account that lets you invest in real estate, private companies and more.
Self-directed IRAs (SDIRAs) are similar to regular IRAs. The main difference is which assets you invest your money in. This can be an advantage or a huge risk if you’re not sure whether the alternative investment options are right for you.
Understanding self-directed IRAs
With regular IRAs, you can invest in stocks, funds, bonds and similar instruments. A self-directed IRA opens up new investment opportunities, including real estate, livestock or private companies. The only investment options that aren’t allowed are life insurance, most collectibles and S corporation shares.
Even though you can invest in alternative assets, some transactions will charge fees and your account will lose its retirement status if you fail to follow the rules.
Also, you can’t open an SDIRA with any broker. You need to find a custodian, which is a company that will handle your transactions and hold your assets until you retire. On top of that, there are many fees that you’ll likely pay.
As for tax implications, a self-directed IRA can be Roth or traditional, meaning you can use the same potential tax benefits as regular IRAs.
Self-directed IRAs vs. regular IRAs
Although incredibly similar, self-directed IRAs differ from regular IRAs in four main aspects:
|Self-directed IRA||Regular IRA|
|Investments available||Real estate, livestock, precious metals, commodities and private companies||Stocks, mutual funds, ETFs and bonds|
|Where to open||A custodian and some brokers||A brokerage firm|
|Return and risk||Returns can be attractive if you’re knowledgeable about a certain asset class –– but the risk is higher than a regular IRA||Risk tends to be low, but returns are more modest. Choose your own investments or let a robo-advisor choose for you|
|Fees||Hefty fees include annual maintenance fees, one-time account opening fees, asset processing fees and more||Fees are generally low and some can be waived|
Benefits of self-directed IRAs
SDIRAs offer two benefits over standard retirement accounts:
- Diversification. Invest in assets well beyond the stock market.
- Potentially higher returns. Take advantage of your expertise in a particular field — say real estate — and enjoy higher returns than what you could earn with a standard IRA.
Risks of self-directed IRAs
Despite having the benefit of higher diversification than regular IRAs and the opportunity to earn a higher return on investment, SDIRAs aren’t without drawbacks.
- You must do your own due diligence. SDIRAs are often high-risk investment options and your custodian isn’t a financial advisor. This means it’s up to you to find the right investment.
- Lack of liquidity. Sell your stocks and ETFs with a tap of a button. But other assets you own through SDIRAs may be hard to liquidate.
- Limited fraud protection. When investing in stocks, you know what you’re buying, and you’re protected by your broker and relevant agencies. But investing in alternative assets offers a higher risk of fraud, mainly because the custodian’s only job is to hold and administer your assets –– not evaluate the legitimacy of your investments.
Self-directed IRAs can be expensive
SDIRA fees are one of the biggest downsides of this type of investment. Expect to pay:
- $200 to $500 annual maintenance fee (sometimes per asset). Standard IRAs may cost up to $50 annually, but a lot of brokerage firms offer $0 fees.
- $50 one-time new account establishment fee. Standard IRAs typically don’t have this fee, but SDIRAs can cost around $50 just to set up your account.
- $30 to $250 asset processing fee. Another fee that’s nonexistent with standard IRAs but costs between $30 and $250 depending on the asset for purchase, liquidation, registration or any kind of transfer.
- $30 to $250 other fees. There are many other fees you could be charged, including expedited transaction fees, re-registration of assets, account termination fees and more.
Note: Practice your own due diligence when comparing SDIRA custodians to ensure you’re paying fewer fees.
Not all transactions are allowed
Some transactions are prohibited by the IRS. You may end up paying up to 100% tax and lose your retirement account status if you proceed with these transactions. Here’s what you’re not allowed to do with your self-directed IRA:
- Buy collectibles, such as art, antiques, gems, coins, alcoholic beverages and specific precious metals.
- Invest in S-corporations.
- Buy life insurance.
- Sell, exchange or lease property between your SDIRA and a disqualified person.*
- Extend credit or provide a cash loan between your SDIRA and a disqualified person.
- Furnish goods, provide services or facilities between your SDIRA and a disqualified person. For example, you can’t improve, maintain or repair a property you own with your SDIRA.
- Transfer your SDIRA income or assets to — or use them by or for the benefit of a — disqualified person. For example, you can’t rent your SDIRA property to your child.
Disqualified persons include:
- The account owner.
- Your IRA beneficiary.
- Your spouse.
- Your immediate blood relatives and their spouses.
- Plan service providers and fiduciaries including advisors, custodians and administrators.
- An entity in which you own at least 50% of the voting stock.
- An officer, director or a shareholder or partner with 10% or more invested.
2 ways to open a self-directed IRA
To open a self-directed IRA, you have to go through a:
- Brokerage. Typical brokerage firms rarely offer SDIRAs. There are a few exceptions to this rule, including Charles Schwab and TD Ameritrade.
- Custodian. These are typically banks and trust companies. But before you apply, check whether they offer SDIRAs and compare the fees because these vary between companies.
Compare retirement accounts
Self-directed IRAs can be useful for those who want to diversify their retirement portfolio and who can take advantage of the new assets. Keep in mind, SDIRAs are more expensive than standard IRAs.
More guides on Finder
Backdoor Roth IRAs
This loophole lets high earners contribute to a Roth IRA even if they make too much.
What’s an average 401(k) return?
Discover what an average 401(k) return is and how asset allocation can affect how your retirement savings perform.
How to save for retirement
Strategies to help you make the most of your retirement savings.
A guide to your inherited 401(k)
How to handle and make the most of your inherited 401(k) assets.
401(k) vs. IRA: Which is best for you?
Knowing the difference between a 401(k) and an IRA will help you maximize your retirement savings.
A beginner’s guide to retirement investing
What you need to know to start building your retirement nest egg.
Best Roth IRA accounts for 2022
These Roth IRAs stand out for their competitive fees, intuitive platforms and practical research tools.
How to roll over a 401(k)
Opt for a direct 401(k) rollover to avoid penalties and fees.
Best IRA accounts for 2022
Check out the best IRAs with the lowest fees and the most useful features.
Ask an Expert