Secured cards vs. unsecured cards: What’s the difference?

Whether you decide on an unsecured or a secured credit card depends on your personal financial needs. Those with relatively healthy credit might want an unsecured card for perks such as a cash back or travel credits. Those with poor or no credit, however, might consider a secured card. Secured cards are meant to help you build your credit so that you can eventually graduate to an unsecured credit card, making them great for students, new immigrants and those who have a history of poor credit.

Here’s a breakdown of how these two cards differ and which one you might want to consider.

What is a secured credit card?

When you open a secured credit card, you must provide your lender with a security deposit — typically $200 to $500, though lower deposits are available. This deposit acts as collateral in case you fall behind on your payments. The amount of your security deposit is also your credit limit.

A secured credit card offers the opportunity to build your credit score. If you consistently make your card payments on time, you’ll see a gradual increase in your score and, eventually, you can graduate to an unsecured credit card. Just make sure your card provider reports your payments to all three major credit bureaus.

Why do card providers require collateral?

You may be new to credit or have a damaged credit score. In these cases, lenders tend to view you as a riskier borrower. Collateral guarantees the provider will be repaid, making them more willing to lend.

Pros and cons of secured credit cards

Who are secured cards good for?

Secured credit cards are best for those without a credit score or those who have a poor credit history and want to build credit. For example, if you have fair to poor credit, you’re far less likely to get approval for an unsecured credit card. Other individuals who can benefit from secured credit cards include new immigrants, college students and those with no history of credit.

What is an unsecured credit card?

When you open an unsecured credit card, you won’t have to put down a security deposit. Instead, you’re borrowing money from your bank. In that sense, each time you use the card, you’re taking out a loan you’re expected to pay back in order to maintain a trustworthy credit history.

Typically, if your provider accepts you as a customer, it means they’ve accessed your credit history and are quite confident you’ll repay your debts. To determine your credit limit, your card provider will gauge your ability to repay. They’ll look at factors such as your income and payment history. Ultimately, the credit limit they offer you is the amount they feel you can borrow responsibly.

The importance of your credit score

Your credit score will determine many aspects of your financial future such as applying for credit cards, personal loans and your ability to take out a mortgage for a home.

If you have a good to an excellent credit score of 680 or higher, you’re typically better off applying for an unsecured card so you can go without putting down a security deposit — you’ll likely get better interest rates too.

If you have fair credit — generally 620 to 679 — you may still qualify for an unsecured card. But the ones you qualify for will likely come with higher fees, shadier terms and less favorable interest rates. Compare credit cards for fair credit, or you might be better off getting a low APR secured card, building or rebuilding your credit score and then moving on to a reputable unsecured card.

Pros and cons of unsecured credit cards

Who are unsecured cards good for?

Unsecured cards are the “standard” pick for most consumers and offer the standard array of credit card benefits, including balance transfer opportunities, reward programs and the ability to carry a balance. Of course, you’ll still want to use your unsecured card responsibly, just the same as an unsecured credit card.

Secured or unsecured cards: Which is best?

There really is no “best” pick between a secured and unsecured card. These cards serve different purposes and you’ll generally pick one based on your financial needs. In short:

• If you need help creating or building your credit score, you’ll apply for a secured credit card.
• If you want a credit card for earning rewards, cash back, or for other standard financial reasons, you’ll apply for an unsecured credit card.

How to graduate to an unsecured card

Graduating to an unsecured card is as simple as raising your credit score. To do that though, you’ll need to practice some credit card best practices. A few examples include:

• Make on time payments. Late credit card payments reflect poorly on your credit score.
• Pay off debts entirely if possible. Paying off a debt in full not only reduces the amount of debt you have to worry about, but is a positive mark on your credit report.
• Don’t max your credit cards. Creditors will note if you repeatedly max out your credit card. To them, this is risky behavior and your credit score may suffer as a result.
• Maintain a healthy credit utilization ratio. Generally, you want to use 30% of your available credit or less. Having a number higher than this over a period of time may hurt your credit score.

Compare secured credit cards

Sort by:

Name	Product	Filter values	Minimum deposit required	Purchase APR	Annual fee	Recommended minimum credit score
OpenSky® Secured Visa® Credit Card			Starting at $200	17.39% variable	$35	300	Apply for this card with no credit check if you're new to credit or have bad credit.	Apply now View details	Compare	loading Fetching your data...
Applied Bank® Secured Visa® Gold Preferred® Credit Card			Starting at $200	9.99% fixed	$48	300	No credit check is required for this secured card. Make a deposit of at least $200 to open this card and get a low 9.99% fixed APR on purchases.	Apply now View details	Compare	loading Fetching your data...
Assent Platinum 0% Intro Rate Mastercard® Secured Credit Card			Starting at $200	0% intro for the first 6 months (then 12.99% variable)	$49	300	A rare secured card with a 0% intro APR on purchases for 6 months, followed by 12.99% variable.	Apply now View details	Compare	loading Fetching your data...
Self Visa® Credit Card			Starting at $100	21.74% variable	$25	300	Build your credit with a low minimum security deposit of $100 and no credit score required.	Apply now View details	Compare	loading Fetching your data...
First Progress Platinum Select MasterCard® Secured Credit Card			Starting at $200	13.99% variable	$39	300	No minimum credit score and no credit history required.	Apply now View details	Compare	loading Fetching your data...
First Progress Platinum Prestige Mastercard® Secured Credit Card			Starting at $200	9.99% variable	$49	300	Build or rebuild your credit with this secured card.	Apply now View details	Compare	loading Fetching your data...
First Progress Platinum Elite MasterCard® Secured Credit Card			Starting at $200	19.99% variable	$29	300	Build your credit with all three major credit bureaus.	Apply now View details	Compare	loading Fetching your data...
PCB Secured Visa®			Starting at $200	18.9% fixed	$39	300	Choose your initial deposit amount and credit limit from $200 to $1000	View details	Compare	loading Fetching your data...

loading

Load More

Compare up to 4 providers

Clear selection

Compare

Bottom line

If you have the means to obtain an unsecured credit card, that should be your first pick when it comes time to apply. However, if you don’t have credit or have a poor credit history, compare secured credit card options to find a card that can help you build credit for the future. Spend responsibly and pay off your balance on time and you’ll soon be able to graduate to an unsecured credit card.

Common questions about secured and unsecured cards

• When I make a security deposit on a secured credit card, will the deposit earn interest?

  Most of the time, your provider won’t pay interest on your security deposit.

• Is a secured credit card a “normal” credit card?

  Yes. You can use your secured card like any other credit card, as long as you stay within your credit limit.

• Will card providers check my credit?

  Most card providers will check your credit for both secured and unsecured cards. For that reason, you may be declined if your credit score is too low. If you’re declined for a secured card, consider applying with a provider that doesn’t check your credit history.

• What is an APR?

  Short for annual percentage rate, it’s a card’s interest rate expressed yearly. Basically, it’s the fee you’re charged for the privilege of borrowing money through your credit card company.

Pictures: Getty Images