Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our content.

New car replacement insurance

You could be due a brand-new vehicle after a theft or write-off.

A shiny new car straight from the showroom floor can be an attractive target for thieves. Fortunately, if you have comprehensive car insurance, you could be entitled to a brand-new replacement if your car is written off or stolen within months of becoming yours.

How does new car replacement work?

New car replacement is a type of coverage that’s included with some comprehensive coverage policies. If yours doesn’t include it, it’s also available as a policy add-on. You can learn about the different levels of car insurance coverage here.

Under most policies for new car replacement, if your brand-new vehicle is stolen or declared a total loss, it’s replaced with another new vehicle of the same make and model. Unlike standard comprehensive coverage that pays to repair or replace your vehicle, new car replacement also covers the cost of car depreciation.

Compare insurers that offer this perk on your policy or comprehensive coverage for free or an extra fee.

Am I eligible for new car replacement?

Eligibility will vary slightly by insurer, but expect to meet basic requirements:

  • You must be the first registered owner of the car.
  • You may be eligible if the vehicle was a registered dealer demo.
  • If you purchased your vehicle with a car loan, your lender may need to give permission replacement.
  • Your car must meet your insurer’s age and kilometre restrictions.
  • Your car must be damaged enough to need a replacement, rather than repairs.
  • If stolen, your car must be declared a total loss or non-recovery within your insurer’s required timing — for example, within 14 days of the date it was stolen.

Compare free comprehensive car insurance quotes online

1 - 3 of 3
Name Product Accident Forgiveness Min. Liability Coverage Discounts Available Online Claims Available Provinces
Surex Auto Insurance
Up to 25%
Alberta, New Brunswick, Northwest Territories, Nova Scotia, Nunavut, Ontario, PEI, Yukon
Submit one application and receive quotes from 10+ insurers. Save up to 25% on your car insurance, plus get access to an insurance advisor.

Who it might be good for: Drivers looking to use an insurance broker to compare multiple pricing and coverage options.
Aviva Car Insurance
Up to 25%
Alberta, Northwest Territories, Nova Scotia, Nunavut, Ontario, Yukon
Aviva car insurance offers customizable policies, discounts and optional insurance coverage add-ons. Get a free quote through Surex.

Who it might be good for: Drivers looking to customize their auto policy.
Travelers Car Insurance
Up to 25%
Alberta, Northwest Territories, Nova Scotia, Nunavut, Ontario, Yukon
Travelers auto insurance offers a selection of coverage options for just about any type of vehicle. Get a free quote through Surex.

Who it might be good for: Drivers looking to get car, motorcycle, classic car, motorhome or recreational vehicle coverage.

Compare up to 4 providers

What happens after my car is replaced?

The process varies by insurer. In some cases, your insurance company transfers your policy to the new vehicle. With others, your coverage ends and you must obtain a new policy for your replacement car. Carefully read your policy’s terms and conditions to avoid any surprises down the road.

In most cases, your vehicle is replaced with one that’s as close to your current model as possible:

  • Same make, model and series. The replacement car will be like the current version of the car you insured.
  • Accessories and modifications included. If you loaded your new car with expensive optional extras, most insurers agree to provide you with a replacement vehicle that has the same modifications.

    What are the limitations of new car replacement insurance?

    Here too, limitations vary by insurer. But you’ll likely need to meet further requirements that relate to your car, your policy and how it was damaged beyond repair:

    • As soon as your car passes your insurer’s kilometre or age threshold, your insured value plummets, and the replacement car you receive won’t be worth as much as when you bought your new car.
    • Your insurer might say its unable to find a similar replacement car. In that case, you can search for a replacement vehicle yourself — and your insurer must honour it.
    • You might not be covered for extended warranties you purchased for the original vehicle.
    • A basic deductible often applies, but some insurers waive it if your car is written off in an accident you aren’t at fault for.
    • Some insurers stipulate a maximum weight limit for the vehicle to be eligible for new car replacement.
    • Fires, floods, theft and larceny may not be covered.

    What are the alternatives to new car replacement?

    If you’ve grown attached to your car and want to be sure you can drive it — or one like it — for as long as you can, you’ve got options when it comes to protecting it:

    • Agreed-value car insurance. Even if your car isn’t yet 2 years old, you might not be eligible for new car replacement if you aren’t the first registered owner. However, you can estimate how much a new replacement vehicle will cost and negotiate an agreed value to cover it with your insurer.
    • Better car replacement. Some providers offer better car replacement, which replaces your current vehicle with a newer model that has less kilometre.
    • Gap insurance. After an accident or theft, your insurance policy might not cover the full value of your vehicle — a problem when you’re still paying off a loan and you’re left repaying on a vehicle you can’t drive. Gap insurance is designed to cover the gap between your payout and payments if your car is stolen or damaged beyond repair.

    Need financing to cover the cost of a new car? Compare car loans

    1 - 8 of 8
    Name Product Loan Amount Interest Rate Loan Term Min. Credit Score Requirements
    CarsFast Car Loans
    $500 - $75,000
    4.90% - 29.90%
    12 - 96 months
    Min. income of $2,000 /month, 3+ months employed
    Get a new or used vehicle delivered to your door.
    Browse thousands of vehicles from dealers across Canada and get matched with financing that meets your needs.
    Loans Canada Car Loans
    $500 - $35,000
    0% - 31.99%
    24 - 120 months
    Min. income of $1,800 /month, 3+ months employed
    Compare rates from 60+ lenders.
    Complete a single application to get quotes from different lenders. Bad credit, CERB and EI borrowers considered. 0% APR for new cars only, used car rates start at 7.99%.
    Coast Capital Car Loan
    $10,000 - No Max.
    18 - 84 months
    Able to service debt payment of $300/month
    Competitive rates and flexible terms.
    Finance new and used vehicles from one of Canada's largest credit unions. No credit union membership required. Available across Canada except SK, QC, NT, NU, YT.
    Clutch Car Loans
    $7,500 - No Max.
    From 3.90%
    12-96 months
    3+ months employed, Max.1 bankruptcy
    Pre-qualify for a loan in under 2 minutes with no impact to your credit score.
    Get approved for financing in under 24 hours for the used car you want. No hidden fees. Get the vehicle delivered to your door.
    Canada Drives Car Loans
    $7,500 - $99,999
    4.75% - 29.99%
    12-84 months
    Min. income of $1,800 /month
    Buy a used car online and get it delivered to your door in under 24 hours.
    Get pre-approved for financing in 3 minutes with no impact to your credit score. No fees or penalties for early loan repayment.
    Carloans411 Car Loans
    $500 - $50,000
    1.90% - 19.99%
    Up to 72 months
    Min. income of $1,600 /month, 3+ months employed
    High application approval rate.
    Get connected with suitable lenders to finance your next car, van or truck. Check eligibility for this loan through LoanConnect.
    Canada Auto Finance
    $500 - $45,000
    4.90% - 29.95%
    3 - 96 months
    Min. income of $1,500 /month, 3+ months employed
    Get financing from partnered local lenders.
    Financing for a new or used car is available for borrowers with bad credit, no credit, CERB, EI or bankruptcy.
    Splash Auto Finance
    $10,000 - $50,000
    9.90% - 29.90%
    24 - 84 months
    Min. income of $2,200 /month, 3+ months employed
    Apply with any credit score.
    Get financing for a new or used car. Auto loans for borrowers with fair credit, bad credit, no credit or bankruptcy.

    Compare up to 4 providers

    Bottom line

    Combining your third-party liability protection policy with collision and comprehensive insurance can help improve your coverage, but may not fully cover the cost to replace your vehicle. New car replacement insurance is a type of coverage that pays to replace your vehicle after a total loss, including the cost of depreciation. So instead of getting a vaguely similar vehicle, you’ll get the same make and model. Get quotes from multiple providers to find a policy that can cover your new vehicle, then compare your options to get the best value.

    More guides on Finder

    • How to lower car insurance costs

      You don’t need to pay more for car insurance than necessary. Find out the 9 easiest ways to pay less and save on your monthly car insurance bill.

    • Hyundai Elantra insurance rates

      The average Hyundai Elantra car insurance cost is $290 a month, or $3,474 a year. Compare different insurance providers to find the best price.

    • aha car insurance review

      aha car insurance is an optimal solution for individuals in Ontario that want quick, stable coverage.

    • Onlia car insurance review

      Onlia auto insurance is a favourable solution for individuals that want quick, easy-to-understand coverage.

    • Honda Accord insurance rates

      The average Honda Accord car insurance cost is $249 a month, or $2,988 a year. Compare different insurance providers to find the best price.

    • How much does Audi R8 insurance cost?

      Car insurance rates for the Audi R8 average at $406 a month, or $4,872 a year. Learn what features affect its car insurance rates.

    • How your driving record affects car insurance rates

      Find out what shows up on your driving record, how insurers use your record and tips to improve it.

    • How much does Honda CR-V insurance cost?

      The average Honda CR-V car insurance cost is $190 a month, or $2,280 per year. Learn how to compare different insurance providers to find the best price.

    • Audi A4 insurance cost

      Audi A4 car insurance can cost an average of $354 a month or $4,224 a year. Learn what factors affect your rate and compare providers.

    • Cheapest cars to insure

      Use our our helpful guide to compare the cheapest and most expensive cars to insure.

    Ask an Expert

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Go to site