Who’s at fault in a car accident?

A guide to who’s liable for damages in common collision scenarios.

Everybody knows what to do when there’s a car accident: Get out of the vehicle, check for injuries, exchange insurance information with the other driver and wait for the police to arrive. Then days later your insurance claims kick in, and someone (or multiple people) are held responsible for the collision. The question is, who?

We created a guide to understand who’s at fault in common collision scenarios. At fault means someone is responsible for an accident and may be held liable for damages. Let’s investigate the most popular types of car accidents to occur.

When a car hits a pedestrian

You might think pedestrians always have the right of way, but that’s not actually true. When determining who’s at fault in a vehicle-pedestrian accident, look at who broke the law or acted carelessly. This is known as the law of negligence.

Here are a few examples of negligence:

• For a driver: running a red light, rolling past a stop sign, driving while talking on a cell phone, etc.
• For a pedestrian: jaywalking, loitering in the crosswalk after the light turns red, etc.

It’s easy to blame the driver in a pedestrian-driver accident. Oftentimes, they’re certainly at fault. But pedestrians don’t have automatic immunity. If they’re walking in the street when they shouldn’t be, they may be at fault.

And then the driver and the pedestrian can both be negligent, at which point contributory or comparative negligence laws will apply.

When a driver rear-ends another driver’s car

As with a vehicle-pedestrian accident, it may seem obvious who’s at fault in a rear-end collision. But the driver who rear-ends another isn’t always the one liable. To determine fault in a rear-end collision, return to the concept of negligence.

If you rear-end another vehicle, you’ll likely bear most of the responsibility for the collision. The law considers you negligent because you failed to keep sufficient space between your vehicle and the leading vehicle — the car in front of you.

The driver of the leading vehicle may also bear some responsibility for the collision. That driver could be negligent as well, like if they reverse without warning or fail to maintain their brake lights.

In the awarding of damages — the compensation a party receives — your state will follow the concepts of contributory or comparative negligence.

In parking lot accidents

The parking lot is one of the most common places for accidents to happen. Drivers are vulnerable when backing out, pedestrians appear out of nowhere and countless cars squeeze into compact spaces. To determine who’s at fault in a parking lot, keep two concepts in mind: who’s moving and who has the right of way.

Here’s the skinny on who’s at fault in common parking lot accidents.

• A driver backs out of a space and collides with an oncoming car

  Both cars are moving, so both drivers may be deemed partially at fault.
  However, in most cases the driver in the through-lane has the right of way. This means the driver backing out is more likely to hold responsibility for the accident. In some cases, the driver backing out has backed out enough that they have control of the lane. If this is the case, that driver would have the right of way.

• Two drivers pull out of spaces and back into each other

  Both cars are moving and neither driver has the right of way. Because of this, both drivers will likely be deemed at fault in the accident.

• Two cars collide while going for the same space

  Both cars are moving. However, the driver turning rightward into the parking space has the right of way. Because the other driver is turning into oncoming traffic, they must yield.

There are many variables that might ultimately decide who’s at fault, but the driver turning left will probably be held mostly responsible for the collision.

In a three-way collision

When gauging fault in a three-way collision, think about the extent to which a driver contributed to the accident. As you might expect, the leading vehicle usually bears less responsibility than the end vehicle. But that might not always be the case.

• Leading car.

  Oftentimes, the front car won’t be at fault in a three-way pileup. However, the driver could be found partially negligent for reckless driving.
  For example, they may have slammed on their brakes, making it difficult for the driver behind them to brake in time.

• Middle car.

  To determine fault for the middle car, consider the accident through the lens of a rear-end collision. The driver is still expected to keep sufficient space between them and the leading car. That said, they may be held partially responsible for damage to the leading car. Often, the driver of the leading car can make a claim against the drivers of the middle and end cars.

  The driver of the middle car may still be held responsible for the pileup if they’re found negligent — for example, by slamming on their brakes.

• End car.

  Typically, the driver of the end car will be held mostly responsible for the collision. The driver of the middle car will probably make a claim against the end car as well.

  The driver of the end car may be able to pursue a claim against the other drivers in certain cases of negligence.

Frequently asked questions

• What do I do if I get into a car accident?

  After a car accident, move your car to the side of the road, where it’s less likely to get hit by other cars. Check for injuries to yourself, passengers and to the other driver. Then call the police and notify them of the collision.

  While you’re waiting for the police to arrive, collect information about the accident. Take as many photos of the collision as possible, including your surroundings.

  Note the drivers and passengers at the scene, the location of the collision, license plates, and makes and models of the vehicles. Collect the insurance information from the other driver and contact information of nearby witnesses. It’s useful to keep a few tools in your car like a pen and paper in case of accidents or emergencies.

• Will my insurance cover my collision?

  Unless you live in New Hampshire or Virginia, your state requires you to have a minimum amount of liability coverage. Thus, your insurance will at least partially cover damages to the other driver if you’re at fault. Your own vehicle will be covered if you have collision coverage.

• Where can I find cheap car insurance?

  Compare car insurers, where you can also research rates based on your car make and model.

  Compare car insurance

  Enter your ZIP code below and click Compare Now to find the best rates near you.

  Compare now

  Your information is secure.