Comparing top weight loss shakes March 2021 | finder.com
finder.com
US
AU
NZ
UK
CA
SG
More

Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our content.

Compare 8 well-known weight-loss shake brands

A short-term dieting solution with no long-term guarantees.

Clare Cribbin
Clare Cribbin

&

Kelly Waggoner
Kelly Waggoner

Updated

Fact checked

With the rise of the wellness economy, it’s become hard to avoid the no-prep, pick-up-and-go advertising for shake diets and meal replacements. Targeted to busy adults looking to kick-start weight loss by cutting out calories, shake diets are sold at grocery stores, through consultants and at online retailers. And they come in varieties to fit your dietary needs — including vegetarian and gluten-free — even if they don’t always live up to the hype.

A note about weight-loss shakes

Before adding weight-loss shakes or pills to your diet, talk to your doctor or another medical professional about the risks of use related to your health, goals and lifestyle.

Compare weight-loss shakes

See how the big names in weight-loss drinks shake out when it comes to cost, ease of purchase and variety.

DietPrice per shakeHow to buy?Dietary optionsNumber of flavors
Atkins~$2.40In stores and onlineVegetarian and gluten-free9
Boost~$1.60In stores and onlineVegetarian and gluten-free3
Ensure~$1.40In stores and onlineVegetarian and gluten-free3
Glucerna~$3.20In stores and onlineVegetarian and gluten-free4
Isowhey~$3.00In stores and onlineVegetarian and gluten-free10
Optifast~$4.00In stores and onlineVegetarian and gluten-free3
Special~$2.90In stores and onlineVegetarian and gluten-free6
Slimfast~$1.80In stores and onlineVegetarian5
weight_loss_shutter2

Do weight-loss shakes work?

Possibly in the short term. But weight-loss shakes aren’t intended to be a permanent dieting solution.

Many nutritionists warn against relying solely on diet shakes for weight loss. Manufacturers focus advertising on the idea that you’ll get all the vitamins, protein and fiber of a lunch or dinner. Still, if you aren’t burning more calories than you’re taking in, you might lose weight initally but soon plateau — or even gain weight.

As with any weight-loss product, talk with your doctor about the safety of adding weight-loss shakes to your diet.

Are weight-loss shakes safe?

It depends on who you ask. Manufacturers can tout the health claims of weight-loss shakes without strong oversight of the FDA. That’s because dietary supplements — including meal replacements — don’t require FDA approval before they land on the shelves of your local supermarket.

As recently as 2018, the FDA has advised against contaminated weight-loss products, conceding that it “cannot test and identify all weight-loss products on the market.” Industry-focused FDA guidance warns that even fortified meal replacements don’t always “provide the appropriate amounts of necessary vitamins and minerals that a traditional, higher calorie meal normally provides.”

It’s worth repeating: If you plan to introduce weight-loss products like meal replacement shakes into your diet, consult your doctor first to talk over the risks.

How to suss out retailer red flags online

When shopping for supplements or weight-loss products online, pause for circumstances like:

  • Sketchy sites. Before ordering shakes online, make sure you’re shopping from a reputable site. Check its security certificate to be sure your information is secure.
  • Questionable policies. When in doubt about an online store, read the terms and conditions. If something sounds off, avoid handing over your payment information.
  • Illicit ingredients. Be wary of sites selling products that haven’t been approved in the US. Because an ingredient is approved elsewhere doesn’t necessarily mean it’s safe to use.
  • MLM schemes. Products sold through multilevel marketing companies — also called direct sales — aren’t often known for their quality. These companies rely on business models built on tiered recruits and generating revenue over health.
weight_loss_shiutter1

Latest deals & coupons

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

20% off Vibrant health favorites

Terms and exclusions apply, see site for details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

Buy 1, get 1 50% off BodyTech Brands

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

Buy 1, get 1 50% off RedCon1

Terms and exclusions apply, see site for details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

20% off Rainbow Light favorites

Terms and exclusions apply, see site for details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

Buy 1, get 1 50% off outright protein bar cases

Terms and exclusions apply, see site for details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

Buy 1, get 1 50% off Vega

Terms and Exclusions Apply, See Site for Details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

Buy 1, get 1 50% off RXBAR

Terms and exclusions apply, see site for details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

20% off Garden of Life favorites

Terms and exclusions apply, see site for details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

The VS brand digestive health sale: 15% off 2 or 20% off 3+ items

Terms and Exclusions Apply, See Site for Details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

Buy 1, get 1 50% off Bang energy drinks

Terms and Exclusions Apply, See Site for Details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

Buy 1, Get 1 50% off womens best

Terms and exclusions apply, see site for details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

Buy 1, Get 1 50% off Alani Nu Snack and drink cases

Terms and Exclusions Apply, See Site for Details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

20% off select plnt

Terms and Exclusions Apply, See Site for Details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

25% off Vital Proteins

Terms and Exclusions Apply, See Site for Details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

20% off New Chapter

Terms and Exclusions Apply, See Site for Details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

20% off Dymatize

Terms and Exclusions Apply, See Site for Details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Vitamin ShoppeVitamin Shoppe

15% off Letter Vitamins from the VS brand

Terms and Exclusions Apply, See Site for Details

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Find Your TrainerFind Your Trainer

Additional bonus gift card with your gift card order

Limited Time Offer

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

MyproteinMyprotein

40% off and free shipping

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Show code

Coupon code ends

WalgreensWalgreens

Join myWalgreens for FREE to unlock sale prices & earn unlimited Cash rewards

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Find Your TrainerFind Your Trainer

Order $100 Gift Card and Receive $10 Gift Card Free

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Find Your TrainerFind Your Trainer

20% Bonus Gift Card for Any Gift Card Amount $500+

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Find Your TrainerFind Your Trainer

$100 off and Save Extra 5% off 12 Session Subscription

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Show code

Coupon code ends

Find Your TrainerFind Your Trainer

$150 off and Save An Extra 10% off 24 Session Subscription

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Show code

Coupon code ends

Find Your TrainerFind Your Trainer

Order any Gift Card Amount Over $500, Receive a 20% Bonus Gift Card

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Find Your TrainerFind Your Trainer

20% Bonus: Order $500 Gift Card + Get $100 Free Gift Card

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Find Your TrainerFind Your Trainer

15% Gift Card Bonus: Gift Card Orders $200 + Get $30 Free Gift Card

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

CVS PharmacyCVS Pharmacy

Check out the great deals at CVS

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Find Your TrainerFind Your Trainer

Hurry to Find Your Trainer to see all their special deals

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

More guides on Finder

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder.com provides guides and information on a range of products and services. Because our content is not financial advice, we suggest talking with a professional before you make any decision.

By submitting your comment or question, you agree to our Privacy and Cookies Policy and finder.com Terms of Use.

Questions and responses on finder.com are not provided, paid for or otherwise endorsed by any bank or brand. These banks and brands are not responsible for ensuring that comments are answered or accurate.
Go to site