The best mascaras 2018: Reviewed by real women | finder.com
Mascara-FeaturedImage

The best mascaras 2018: Reviews by real women

We value our editorial independence, basing our comparison results, content and reviews on objective analysis without bias. But we may receive compensation when you click links on our site. Learn more about how we make money from our partners.

We asked women from all walks of life – from women in their 50s to teenagers. Here are their top-rated mascaras.

What is the best mascara? It’s almost impossible to know. Mascara ads always seem to promise the world. Lashes that are 10 times thicker. False-lash effect. Sky-high curls. Lash-multiplying formula. But most of them never truly seem to deliver on these claims.

Nobody has the time or money to test mascara after mascara. So how do we really know what works and what doesn’t?

By asking, of course.

Here at finder, we decided to compare and compile reviews. We asked a bunch of real women who use mascara every day what is the best mascara they’ve ever used. We spoke to women from all walks of life, from women in their 50s to teenagers, from university students to lawyers.

What did we find? Well, there was one clear favorite and lots of other great products that we never even thought to try!

1. Maybelline – The Falsies

  • Best supermarket mascara ever. Affordable and definitely comparable to more expensive brands I’ve tried.Natalie
  • I’m a sucker for a bargain, and luckily for me Maybelline is a reliable one. Great for everyday use and not as thick or clumpy as some of the more expensive brands.Liz
  • The Falsies is really good for a defining the individual lashes. It’s a good price too.Clare
  • No clumps – just long, thick lashes.Rae
  • It makes my lashes huge without being clumpy. Also, they say that you’re meant to replace your mascara every 3 or so months due to bacteria. I love that this product is relatively inexpensive and that I can buy it whilst doing my usual weekly grocery shop.Alana
  • Using the lower lash brush because I make a mess with the normal sized one.Jackie

2. Tarte – Lights Camera Lashes

  • I really liked it because it’s a mascara you can layer without it becoming clumpy. Even if I do five coats, my lashes never turned into stuck-together blobs as they do with other mascaras.
    Mia
  • Tarte makes a great mascara. Depending on how thick your lashes are you can get away with one coat which is quite economical. Great for darker lashes.Alex M
  • It’s thickening yet it doesn’t clump or smudge.Emily M

3. Lancôme – Hypnose

  • Lancôme Hypnose, because it stays put!Marie
  • Lancôme Hypnose Star. It’s the best mascara for a night out or if you want a bit of the wow factor for the day. People will actually compliment you and notice the hints of glitter in your eyelashes. Guess the price doesn’t warrant wearing it everyday though!Shirley
  • Lancôme Hypnose Doll. As a short lashed Asian female, I am partial to Lancôme hypnose baby doll. I’m prone to smudging because of my lack of eyelids and tiny eyes. But it gives you epic length, especially if you layer it.Sally

4. Rimmel – Volume Flash Mascara

volume flash rimmel - edited
Available at Amazon

  • An amazing mascara – builds great volume without clumping! It can be layered and doesn’t stick together, so you can go from day to night lashes easily. Good value for money as well and available and most supermarkets and chemists.Gemma

5. Benefit – Badgal Lash Mascara

Benefit – Badgal Lash Mascara
Available at Amazon

  • I love Benefit’s Bad Gal mascara because it makes my lashes look longer, and my eyes look bigger.Rachel

6. Dior – Diorshow Waterproof Mascara

dior show - edited
Available at Sephora

  • Never using anything else! No running – it lasts all day and night and gives good volume.Katrine

7. Benefit – They’re Real!

Benefit They're Real
Available at Amazon

  • This mascara gives you length and volume at the same time, and it never looks clumpy or like you’re wearing too much.Amanda

8. Max Factor – Masterpiece Max

max factor masterpiece - edited
Available at Amazon

  • I like it because the brush spreads out my lashes, thus avoiding clumping, and it also adds volume and length which is great because I don’t need to use two! It also doesn’t crumble off so it stays on forever!Jessica P

9. Bobbi Brown – Black Smokey Eye Mascara

Bobbie Brown Smokey Eye - edited
Available at Sephora

  • It lasts forever and doesn’t clump.Bianca M

10. Yves Saint Laurent – Mascara Volume Effect Faux Cils Shocking

YSL Shocking - edited
Available at Sephora

  • Perfect balance of length and volume, beautiful non-clogging formula.Steph A

11. Estee Lauder – Sumptuous Extreme Lash Multiplying Volume Mascara

Sumptuous - edited
Available at Ulta

  • It has a long name so you KNOW it’s fancy. Also because it’s perfect for everyday wear (not too heavy) but can also be layered for some intense eyelash magic.Jessica C

12. Maybelline – Volum’ Express The Colossal Cat Eyes Mascara

maybelline cat eyes - edited
Available at Amazon

  • For a ‘I’m not wearing mascara, I’m naturally pretty’ look.Amy

13. Lengthening & Define Dead Sexy Lashes Mascara

Dead Sex Lashes
Available at Amazon

  • This mascara basically doubles my eyelashes and makes them look much fuller. It’s a great second application mascara if you’re someone who likes to layer.Aliyyah

14. Too Faced – Better than Sex

too faced - edited
Available at Ulta

  • It really is better than sex!Bianca C

15. Stila – Huge Extreme Lash Mascara

mega lash australis - edited
Available at Sephora

  • One coat and BAM. Hellooo eyes.Mary

16. Make Up For Ever – Aqua Smokey Lash Mascara

make up for ever - edited
Available at Amazon

  • It gives long lasting curl. It’s so dramatic and it gives amazing length.Emily G

17. Rimmel – Scandaleyes Flex

rimmel flex - edited
Available at Amazon

  • I like it because it’s the only good brand that makes my lashes look amazing that I’m not allergic to. It’s hypoallergenic but not an unknown hippy brand.Cassilda

18. Inika – Mineral Mascara

inika - edited
Available at Amazon

  • Because it’s not stuck in the eyes of animals nor uses ingredients from exploited animals, and it looks amazing.Jennifer

19. L’Oreal Paris – Telescopic Mascara

L'Oreal Telescopic - edited
Available at Amazon

  • It’s super dark and creates unbelievable length that gets noticed every time.Lauren

20. Glossier Lash Slick

Glossier Lash Slick
Available at Glossier

  • For an everyday casual lash you can wear without any other makeup, Lash Slick is my mascara of choice.Amanda

Current deals and specials

Macy's Macy's

Free MAC keychain with $35 or more MAC purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free Tarte 4 piece Glitz and Glamour Brush set ($51 value) with select order

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free Tarte 2 piece Turn Up The Glam set ($54 value) with select order

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free benefit 2 piece Superstar Steal Set ($36 value) with select order

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

MAC 2 piece Turquatic Gift Set ($79 value) now: $57

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Yves Rocher Yves Rocher

Free shipping with $35 or more order

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

ESPA Skincare ESPA Skincare

5 free samples with $75 or more order

Exclusions may apply. Choose samples at checkout.

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

WinkyLux WinkyLux
Exclusive

Free full size lipstick with orders $20 and over

Last verified

Macy's Macy's

Free gift with $65 or more origins purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free mask with any Borghese purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free gift with any Sk-II purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free gift with any Shiseido purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free gift with any Philosophy purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free gift with $70 or more on Borghese purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free gift with $50 or more on Borghese purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free gift with $50 or more on beauty purchases

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free Clinique gift with $50 or more on beauty purchases

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free Bobbi Brown gift with any makeup purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free 5 piece gift with $450 or more on Sk-II purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free 3 day supply of new Clinique Dramatically Different Hydrating Jelly with $50 or more on beauty purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Free gift with any $35 Origins purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Double Wear SIP PWP now: $10 with Double Wear SIP purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Macy's Macy's

Beauty Blender 2pc gift now: $20 with any foundation purchase

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Ulta Ulta

40% off select Cargo Skus

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Elizabeth Arden Elizabeth Arden

26% off Ceramide eye makeup set was: $34 now: $25

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Elizabeth Arden Elizabeth Arden

61% off Ceramide ultra lipstick set was: $96 now: $36.50

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Elizabeth Arden Elizabeth Arden

Visible difference multi-targeted BB cream broad spectrum sunscreen SPF 30 now: $32.50

Plus free shipping

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Elizabeth Arden Elizabeth Arden

25pc Limited edition makeup collection was: $270 now: $39.50

Plus free shipping

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Elizabeth Arden Elizabeth Arden

New visible difference multi-targeted BB cream SPF 30 now: $32.50

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

Ulta Ulta

Unzipped desert sunset palette was: $42 now: $29

T&Cs apply

Last verified

Get deal

Deal ends

eBay eBay

Get makeup brushes on sale today

Last verified

Amazon Amazon

Shop the editor's beauty picks on Amazon

Get the best beauty products on Amazon thanks to the editor's picks.

Last verified

Tarte Tarte

Free sample and shipping on orders $40 and over

Last verified

eBay eBay

Shop Kylie Jenner's lipsticks

Last verified

Kiko Milano Kiko Milano

Sign up to the newsletter and enjoy $5 off your first online order

Last verified

RealHer RealHer

Get 10% off your entire order

When you sign up for the newsletter today

Last verified

Bliss Bliss

20% off your first order

When you sign up to the Bliss List newsletter

Last verified

Sephora Sephora

Shop the sale at Sephora

New savings added every week

Last verified

Ulta Ulta

Free standard shipping on any $50 purchase

Last verified

eBay eBay

Check eBay for their latest beauty deals

Last verified

Last checked Code description Code

Mia Steiber

Mia Steiber is a journalist at finder.com.au with a serious shopping habit and an addiction to gold jewellery. Her talents include tracking down one-off or almost sold out pieces and knowing the sizing charts for just about every brand.

Was this content helpful to you? No  Yes

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder only provides general advice and factual information, so consider your own circumstances, or seek advice before you decide to act on our content. By submitting a question, you're accepting our Privacy and Cookies Policy and Terms of Use.
Go to site