Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our content.
The best mascaras in 2021
Read reviews from real customers to find the best mascara for any budget or preference.
Which is the best mascara? That depends on what you’re looking for! We’ve searched far and wide to find the top five mascaras for every need and budget based on reviews from real people. Scan through our list below to find the best mascara fit for your beauty bag.
Best drugstore mascara: L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise
There’s a reason why L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise is a fan favorite at Walgreens. The mascara’s 200+ soft bristles will help give you that movie star volume, from root to tip. Don’t worry about flaking or clumping with this one — the formula goes on silky smooth.
- Review from a Walgreen’s customer: “My eyelashes are very short, very fine, and sparse. I have used dozens, if not more, kinds and brands of mascara over the years — this is the best I have ever used … they look full and the length gained is remarkable.”
- Price: $10.99 at Walgreens
Best waterproof mascara: Maybelline Sky High Waterproof Mascara
What’s the deal with Maybelline Sky High Waterproof Mascara, which has racked up almost 30,000 5-star reviews (!) on Amazon? Its waterproof formula works overtime to protect you from pesky mascara runs, all while delivering liquid-black volume for the ultimate night out on the town.
- Review from an Amazon customer: “Wow! I’ve always loved Maybelline mascara and this is no different. I love the length and the wear of the formula. Great mascara. Easy to remove as well.”
- Price: $8.98 at Amazon
Best mascara for sensitive eyes: Clinique High Impact Mascara
Clinique High Impact Mascara has been ophthalmologist-tested and allergy-tested, making it a safe pick for those with sensitive eyes (and contact lens wearers!) Bonus points: the formula is 100% fragrance free and offers plenty of volume.
- Review from an Ulta customer: “I got a sample of this mascara awhile ago and although it wasn’t in the color I would have chosen, I tried it. Loved it immediately! This is my second purchase and it has become my favorite mascara. I’ve been asked if I’m wearing false lashes!!”
- Price: $20 at Ulta
Best luxury mascara: Eccentrico Mascara from Armani Beauty
Go name-brand with the Eccentrico Mascara from Armani Beauty, a luxurious formula with a smudge-free blend. You’ll get plenty of intense black volume and zero clumping. We’re also pretty obsessed with the jet-black and cherry-red packaging.
- Review from a Sephora customer: “This Mascara is everything! It makes my lashes super long and gives lots of volume. Worth every penny.”
- Price: $32 at Sephora
Best clean mascara: Ilia Limitless Lash Lengthening Mascara
ILIA Limitless Lash Lengthening Mascara doesn’t just give your lashes a major boost. It’s also made without ingredients like sulfates, parabens, coal tar and formaldehydes. The yummy ingredients it does include? Ultra-conditioning shea butter and nourishing beeswax.
- Review from a Sephora customer: “I’m very picky with mascara. I have a good amount of lashes but they’re blonde, so I’m really looking for length and not too much volume. This does it: no clumping, no flakes. Beautiful formula and the wand is perfect. I’ve been switching around mascaras for a year but the search is over.”
- Price: $28 at Sephora
Latest beauty deals and coupons
More guides on Finder
13 of the best shoes for nurses
Shop some of the best nursing shoes to help you stay on your feet in comfort and style. We share our picks and tips and advice from nurses.
10 amazing vacation ideas for 2021
10 US destinations we wanna visit this year.
Top 11 women’s winter coats in 2021
Wrap up in comfort and warmth when you shop these trendy women’s winter coats, with options for tight budgets and that special splurge.
Covergirl’s Lash Blast mascara now has a clean and vegan formula
The fan-favorite mascara in the iconic orange tube goes green with a new formula. Find out where you can get it.
Best 3D printers in 2020
Whether you’re a student or an industry professional, we broke down the best 3D printers to suit your needs — from budget options to accessible features.
Top high-waisted joggers in 2021
See top picks for this fall/winter trend, starting at under $20. If these don’t suit your style, learn where you can shop for more — no matter your budget.
Best Iceland tours and tour companies for 2021
Make the most of your visit to the land of fire and ice by traveling with an expert guide.
The best eyeshadow palettes in 2021
Looking for your next go-to palette? These are our top12 eyeshadow palette picks for every style and occasion.
20 top European summer festivals in August 2021
The music and culture festivals that are set to sizzle in Europe this summer.
Is Gucci L’Obscur mascara worth it? Recap of first impressions + reviews
We’ve compiled early reviews and first impressions so you can decide for yourself if it’s worth shelling out $35.
Ask an Expert