Policygenius disability insurance review 2021

This marketplace helps you to find the best disability insurance match for your needs.

  • Consider Policygenius if… You want to be guided through the process of getting disability insurance.
  • Look elsewhere if… You already have a solid idea of what you need in a disability policy.
No reviews yet. Write a review


Short term disability


Long term disability


Benefit period 2, 5, or 10 years or until age 65 or 67
Waiting period 60 - 365 days
Coverage amount $100 to $20,000
Individual credit
Available states All 50 states
Policy riders No info available
Simplified issue No


  • Guides you through the process
  • Access to multiple quotes
  • Online help available


  • Medical exam might be required
  • You may have to request reconsideration

Review by

Rhys Subitch is the loans editor at Finder, guiding Americans toward smart borrowing decisions. With over half a decade of experience researching, editing and writing for a Fortune 500 company, university and several independent publications, Rhys brings readers the most up-to-date and curated info in the lending sphere. They make frequent appearances on Finder's YouTube channel to talk through loan topics that range from the very basics to the latest government assistance programs. Before specializing in lending, Rhys was a personal finance writer for Finder’s credit cards, insurance, banking and mortgage verticals. They hold a BA in sociology and a certificate in editing from the University of Washington, Seattle.

Expert review

Policygenius streamlines the process of buying disability insurance by offering assistance from licensed advisors. It also helps you to work out how much coverage you need, and then complete the application for the best possible outcome. If you’re considering buying a policy from a national carrier, Policygenius can save you time.

But if you’re looking for a niche provider or hoping to get a policy without a medical exam, you may want to compare disability insurance companies on your own.

How does Policygenius work?

As a broker, Policygenius doesn’t directly provide disability insurance. Instead, it matches you with insurance companies, pulls quotes and helps you to complete your application.

It supports online applications, and offers live support during business hours for each stage.

How do I know I’m getting the best rates?

Policygenius stands out for assisting its customers through the application process. If the insurance company comes back with a higher premium than they originally quoted, Policygenius will take your application to other insurers to try to get you a better rate.

Policygenius disability insurance reviews and complaints

Policygenius has a near-perfect rating on Trustpilot. Of the over 1,730 customer reviews, 93% are 5 out of 5 stars. Many customers praise the Policygenius staff’s helpfulness when it comes to figuring out how much insurance they need and completing the application itself.

The marketplace is accredited with the Better Business Bureau (BBB), and has an A- rating for its customer rating. Customers award the company 4.57 out of 5 stars, and the BBB has only recorded five complaints over the past three years, as of October 2020.

Which disability insurance companies does Policygenius work with?

Policygenius currently works with over 15 insurers to provide short- and long-term disability policies. The potential insurers you could be matched with include:

  • Ameritas
  • Assurity
  • Fidelity Security
  • Guardian
  • Illinois Mutual
  • MassMutual
  • MetLife
  • Mutual of Omaha
  • Northwestern Mutual
  • Ohio National
  • Petersen International
  • Principal Financial Group
  • RiverSource
  • State Farm
  • The Standard
  • Thrivent
  • Unum

Company ratings

There are two huge measures of a company’s trustworthiness. Its financial strength points to its ability to pay out its policies, while its customer satisfaction ratings reflect how the company treats its customers.

Generally, Policygenius works with companies that are highly rated with both AM Best and the Better Business Bureau.

CompanyA.M. BestBetter Business Bureau
AssurityA-Not rated
Fidelity SecurityA-A+
Illinois MutualA-A+
MetLifeANot rated
Mutual of OmahaA+A+
Mutual of OmahaA+A+
Northwestern MutualB++A+
Ohio NationalAA+
Petersen InternationalAA+
Principal Financial GroupA+A+
State FarmA++A+
The StandardAA+

Pros and cons of Policygenius disability insurance


  • Guides you through the process. You’ll start by figuring out how much insurance you need, and Policygenius will make recommendations as you choose your benefit amount, waiting period, features and go through the actual application.
  • Access to multiple quotes. Depending on your application, you may be able to get quotes from more than one of over 15 companies Policygenius works with.
  • Online help available. While you get automated assistance through the process, you can also chat online or call a representative during business hours for any questions that come up.


  • Medical exam might be required. You may need to undergo a medical exam depending on your application and the company you’re matched with.
  • You may have to request reconsideration. While you can have Policygenius shop your application around to other insurers if your premiums are higher than quoted, you may also have to ask the company you applied with to reconsider if you missed something on the application.

How do I sign up for Policygenius disability insurance?

To use Policygenius to get disability insurance, you’ll need to hop online. You can get support during the process via phone or online chat.

  1. Go to the Policygenius website and click Disability.
  2. Fill out your gender, date of birth and choose your state then click Next.
  3. Provide information about your job and income then select Next.
  4. Choose your benefit amount and click Next.
  5. Select your waiting period then Next.
  6. Choose your benefit period and click Next.
  7. Select any additional features then Next.
  8. Fill out your health information and click Next.
  9. Check over your information and press Get your rates.
Get quotes from Policygenius Disability Insurance

Compare alternatives to Policygenius

Name Product Coverage Amount Benefit period Waiting period Own Occupation Medical exam required
Policygenius Disability Insurance
$100 to $20,000
2, 5, or 10 years or until age 65 or 67
60 - 365 days
Depends on provider
Get matched with one of 15 top life insurance companies to find the best coverage and rates for you.
JRC Life Insurance
$500 to $20,000
2 year to lifetime
30 - 365 days
Compare policies up to $10 million from 45+ top insurance companies with the click of a button.
$500 to $20,000
1, 2, 5, or 10 years or until age 65 or 67
30 - 365 days
Secure long-term disability insurance online by filling out an easy 10-minute application, even if you're a high income earner.

Compare up to 4 providers

Frequently asked questions

Ask an expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder only provides general advice and factual information, so consider your own circumstances, or seek advice before you decide to act on our content. By submitting a question, you're accepting our finder.com Terms of Use and Privacy and Cookies Policy.
Go to site