Overtone hair treatment review

I gave up harsh dyes for a healthy hair color alternative.

Last updated:

Overtone Vibrant Red Coloring Conditioner

We value our editorial independence, basing our comparison results, content and reviews on objective analysis without bias. But we may receive compensation when you click links on our site. Learn more about how we make money from our partners.

Even brunettes can go bright without bleach.

Anyone who’s dyed their hair an intense shade like red or purple will tell you: It fades fast. After just a few shampoos or dips in the pool, your color — and hard-earned cash — washes down the drain, and you’re left with the dreaded trifecta: dullness, dryness and damage.

I purchased this product myself. All opinions are my own.

Read my review

Cheryl Wagemann

I’d stopped coloring my naturally dark brown hair a rich auburn years ago because the upkeep became too much. So I was intrigued by Overtone’s new line of semipermanent coloring conditioners made for brunettes, no prelightening required. The product is packed with hair-healthy ingredients like coconut oil and shea butter — and, most important, no ammonia.

I put Overtone’s Coloring Conditioner in Vibrant Red to the test to see if it could give me the mermaid hair of my dreams and hold up through one hot summer.

Shop Overtone now

Overtone coloring conditioner review

First impression

My first thought when I opened the jar was: Wow, that’s red! I’m talking straight-up fire engine. Other color-depositing products I’ve tried look subtle and develop after applied to your hair. So I was a little nervous about how this would turn out.

Also, I wasn’t wild about the strong rosemary and mint scent that reminded me of calamine lotion.

Overtone Vibrant Red Coloring Conditioner
Matt Wagemann/Finder Image credit

I’m glad I read the packaging before hopping in the shower, because I assumed I’d apply it after shampooing. While you can use it in the shower, Overtone says you’ll get brighter results if you apply it dry.

I used almost half of the jar to coat my thick, waist-length mane. The product consistency is thick, so dripping was minimal. Still, I wore an old T-shirt and stood in my shower so it wouldn’t stain my bathroom floor.

After working the conditioner into my hair piece by piece, I let it sit for 15 minutes and then rinsed with cool water.

My hair before using Overtone
My hair before using Overtone Coloring Conditioner
Image: Matt Wagemann/Finder Image credit

The verdict

Not going to lie: As I glopped the product on my hair and checked my reflection, I feared I’d end up looking more like Bozo than Ariel. But as soon as I rinsed, my cherry-stained strands looked promising — even soaking wet.

After blow-drying, I was even more impressed: My faded brown mop had transformed to flowing ruby-red locks. It was the rich true red I’d hoped for!

After using Overtone
My hair after using Overtone Vibrant Red Coloring Conditioner
Matt Wagemann/Finder Image credit

My hair felt silkier and so much more manageable. I blow-dried it in half the time, and my waves looked smoother and more defined than usual.

Because I applied this to the top layer of my hair only, it resulted in a subtle balayage effect that I love. However, it didn’t blend the errant grays I have at my crown, and it could’ve applied more evenly. But that may be my fault: I applied it fairly haphazardly and didn’t saturate the underside of my hair.

Overall, it looks almost like I used a permanent dye! It kicked up my color with a punch of red that’s striking, but not cartoonish.

The tone is on the cooler side, but it’s not purple. And it’s definitely more pigmented than other color-depositing and gloss treatments I’ve tried.

One week later

After three shampoos and a dip in the pool, my color was still vibrant! Even after a day of chlorine and too much time in the sun. While its initial luster faded slightly, my hair still had a warm red tinge.

Tips for using Overtone conditioner

If you try Overtone’s Coloring Conditioner, follow these tips for best results:

  • Do a strand test to make sure you like the color before committing to it.
  • Saturate your roots and the underside of your hair for even, all-over color.
  • Wear gloves, because this product does stain.
  • Dab your hairline and part with barrier cream, like plain conditioner or petroleum jelly, to prevent staining your skin.

To find the right hue for you, shop by shade and then choose a level based on your current hair color.

Pastel

Intense color for prelightened shades of platinum blonde

Vibrant

Intense color for platinum to dark brown hair

Extreme

Richest color available for all hair color levels

For Brown Hair

Pigments specifically made for dark hair

Shop Overtone now

Bottom line

Overtone Coloring Conditioner is an easy solution to go bright without frying your hair. Plus, the brand makes a line of daily conditioners to maintain your shade, so you won’t have to keep recoloring it.

While no semi- or demipermanent can match the lasting power of a permanent dye, it’s still a solid alternative to rock a fun burst of color and preserve your hair’s integrity.

Hair color inspo

Need some inspiration? Take a cue from these bold looks created with Overtone Coloring Conditioner.

  • Overtone Rose Gold Coloring Conditioner on woman with platinum hair

    Image: Overtone Instagram

  • Woman with dark blue hair from Overtone Coloring Conditioner

    Image: Overtone Instagram

  • Woman with faded lilac hair from Overtone Coloring Conditioner

    Image: Overtone Instagram

Top Overtone deals for December 2019

Overtone Overtone

Full kits now starting from $47

Get semi-permanent vegan and cruelty-free color conditioners now!

Last verified

Frequently asked questions

Was this content helpful to you? No  Yes

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder.com provides guides and information on a range of products and services. Because our content is not financial advice, we suggest talking with a professional before you make any decision.

By submitting your comment or question, you agree to our Privacy and Cookies Policy and Terms of Use.

Questions and responses on finder.com are not provided, paid for or otherwise endorsed by any bank or brand. These banks and brands are not responsible for ensuring that comments are answered or accurate.

2 Responses

  1. Default Gravatar
    Purple4meSeptember 9, 2019

    Hello!

    I just got the purple for brown hair. But I’m afraid to use it as I saw you say it’s possible it will never come out. Does that mean I may have purple stuck in my brown hair until I bleach it out? If so, what kind of hair usually has this “forever” result? Side note: I’m not wanting it to last forever.

    • Avatarfinder Customer Care
      CherylSeptember 10, 2019Staff

      Hello!

      Overtone Coloring Conditioner is semipermanent, so it typically washes out within six weeks. However, the company says you could experience permanent results depending on factors like your hair’s porosity and starting shade.
      I recommend performing a strand test to see how long it lasts in your hair.

      Hope this helps!

Go to site