Penalties up 174% as VAR helps break World Cup record in Russia

Brodie Fogg 9 July 2018 NEWS

FIFA World Cup VAR Penalties L

The impact of VAR technology on the FIFA World Cup has been unearthed by finder.com/nz, with statistics showing that we’ve never seen so many games decided by penalties.

There is no denying that this world cup has been one filled of nail-biting moments. Plenty of exciting, tight games. A stack of upsets. And 160 strikes rippling the back of the net. But, of course, there will always be controversy: and we’re not just talking about what’s gone down in Maradona’s booth. The biggest talking point has been about VAR.

VAR, or Video Assisted Referee, is an off-field official who looks at the video footage of goals or goal-scoring opportunities to see if there has been any foul play that may alter the decision made by the referee on the field in real time. If there is a debatable incident, the referee on-field is notified, they stop the game, head off the field to watch a replay on a screen, and then alter or confirm their decision based on that footage.

For football purists, it’s seen as an invasive process that breaks up the flow of the game. Many argue that there is still so much subjective grey area in decisions that, even after using VAR, fans and commentators are still split on whether the correct decision has been made anyway. But ultimately, good or bad, VAR is impacting the result of games.

By analysing the FIFA World Cup statistics out of Russia, we can already see that a VAR-enabled tournament delivers more penalty goals. Despite the fact that – at the time of this writing – we’ve only completed the quarter-finals and four games remain, the Russia World Cup has already seen more goals scored from penalties than any of the previous 20 World Cups.

These are in-game penalties, ignoring successful spot kicks during penalty shoot-outs. Plus, it doesn’t take into account missed penalties – you know, like the one from Lionel Messi…

Is VAR resulting in more penalties?

So far this World Cup, in the 60 games played thus far there have been 20 penalties. It works out to one penalty every three games. In comparison, in the 2014 World Cup hosted in Brazil, over the entire 64 game tournament there were only 12 penalties. When we look at the ratio of penalties scored per game that is a 174% increase. By the time we’re done, it will be almost double!

If you go back to the 2010 South Africa World Cup as your comparison point, then this year is up 253%. In fact, you have to go back to 1994 to find anything comparable, where in the USA we saw 15 penalties in a shorter 52 game tournament. But even still, that is a penalty strike-rate 12% less than what we’ve seen in 2018.

Below you will see all the penalty data from each of the 21 World Cups. It seems clear that if VAR is here to stay – which certainly seems likely – that we can expect more games to be decided by penalties in the future. Is that a good or bad thing? I guess that depends on whether your team is still in the World Cup or not…

History of Penalties at FIFA World Cup

Year Venue Penalties Scored Games Played Penalties Per Game % Change
2018 Russia 20 60 0.33 174%
2014 Brazil 12 64 0.19 133%
2010 South Africa 9 64 0.14 69%
2006 Germany 13 64 0.20 100%
2002 Korea-Japan 13 64 0.20 76%
1998 France 17 64 0.27 92%
1994 USA 15 52 0.29 115%
1990 Italy 13 52 0.25 108%
1986 Mexico 12 52 0.23 150%
1982 Spain 8 52 0.15 97%
1978 Argentina 6 38 0.16 100%
1974 Germany 6 38 0.16 101%
1970 Mexico 5 32 0.16 63%
1966 England 8 32 0.25 100%
1962 Chile 8 32 0.25 125%
1958 Sweden 7 35 0.20 74%
1954 Switzerland 7 26 0.27 197%
1950 Brazil 3 22 0.14 82%
1946 France 3 18 0.17 94%
1942 Italy 3 17 0.18 318%
1938 Uruguay 1 18 0.06 N/A

Latest streaming headlines

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder only provides general advice and factual information, so consider your own circumstances, or seek advice before you decide to act on our content. By submitting a question, you're accepting our Privacy and Cookies Policy and Terms of Use, Disclaimer & Privacy Policy.
Go to site