Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our content.
Sharesies Vs InvestNow Vs Smartshares, and beyond
We compare these popular online investing platforms side-by-side to find out which is the right choice for you.
Sharesies, InvestNow and Smartshares are three well-known online platforms that aim to help Kiwis grow their wealth. They’re designed to make it easy to invest in shares, exchange traded funds (ETFs) and managed funds — but how do you know which of these investing platforms is the best choice?
This guide features a Sharesies vs InvestNow vs Smartshares comparison. We’ll look at the fees, features and available markets each provider offers to help you find the right investment service for your needs.
What's in this guide?
Sharesies vs InvestNow vs Smartshares: How much does it cost to invest?
There’s a key question you’ll need to consider when choosing an investing platform: What fees does the provider charge?
Fee amounts and pricing structures vary depending on the platform you choose. Sharesies offers a choice between a monthly or an annual subscription, but the cost of a monthly subscription depends on the size of your portfolio.
Share brokerage fees also apply, as do management fees when you invest in an ETF or managed fund.
On InvestNow, the platform doesn’t charge any fees to customers — but you will need to pay fees charged by the fund provider, including management fees and entry and exit costs.
When you invest with Smartshares, you’ll need to pay a one-off establishment fee. Annual management fees are charged as a percentage of your total investment, but the percentage amount varies depending on the ETF.
Check out the table below to find how much it costs to invest with Sharesies vs InvestNow vs Smartshares.
|Platform||Set up fee||Subscription/platform fee||Transaction fee||Exchange fees||Management fee|
|Sharesies||N/A||From $0 to $3, depending on the value of your portfolio||0.5% for orders up to $3,000 and 0.1% for order over||0.4% exchange fee when you change NZ dollars into US dollars||Management fees are built into the price of ETFs and managed funds and are charged by the fund manager Sharesies partners with.|
|Smartshares||$30||N/A||Dependent on fund||Dependent on fund||Dependent on fund|
|InvestNow||N/A (although there is a $250 minimum investment)||N/A||N/A||Up to 2.45%, depending on managed fund|
Sharesies vs InvestNow vs Smartshares: Available markets
Each of these providers offers access to a different range of financial products. For example, while you can use Sharesies to invest in shares, ETFs and managed funds, InvestNow provides access to managed funds and term deposits.
We’ll take an in-depth look at which provider offers what a little further down the page. For a quick breakdown, check out the table below.
Best for trading US shares
If you’re looking to trade US stocks from NZ, the most direct way of these to do so is via Sharesies. However, there are other easy-to-use share-trading platforms, such as Stake, that let you buy US shares from New Zealand.
Through Sharesies you can buy and sell shares in over 2,300 US companies listed on the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), Nasdaq, and the Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE).
To buy US shares, you’ll need to convert your NZ dollars into US dollars. Sharesies charges a 0.4% currency conversion fee, while the following transaction fees apply in USD:
- 0.5% transaction fee for orders up to $3,000
- An additional 0.1% fee for amounts above $3,000
InvestNow and Smartshares don’t allow you to buy shares in US companies directly, but they do offer exposure to US stocks through managed funds and ETFs, respectively.
Best for trading NZ shares
If you’d like to buy and sell NZ shares directly, Sharesies is once again the only one of these three platforms that allows you to do so.
You can trade shares in more than 165 companies and ETFs listed on the New Zealand Stock Exchange (NZX), including well-known names like Spark and The A2 Milk Company.
To buy and sell shares on the NZX, you’ll need to pay a 0.5% transaction fee on orders up to $3,000, while an additional 0.1% fee applies to amounts above $3,000.
To gain exposure to NZ shares on InvestNow or Smartshares, you’ll need to consider a managed fund or ETF.
Best for investing in ETFs
Sharesies and Smartshares both allow you to invest in ETFs.
Sharesies provides access to over 30 ETFs on the NZX, as well as ETFs from the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), Nasdaq, and the Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE).
There are no brokerage fees when you buy an NZ ETF, but they do apply when you buy an ETF on a US exchange (0.5% on orders up to $3,000 and an additional 0.1% on amounts above $3,000, charged in USD).
You should also be aware of the 0.4% exchange fee when you convert NZD to USD.
Meanwhile, Smartshares also offers access to a wide range of 35 ETFs. These include:
- ETFs that invest in NZ, Australian, US or international shares
- ETFs that track the performance of a specific index, such as the NZX 50 or the ASX 200
- Bonds and cash ETFs
- Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) shares
- ETFs that invest in global trends, such as technological innovation.
Smartshares charges a $30 setup fee when you first apply, while annual management fees vary depending on the fund you choose and range from 0.20% to 0.75%.
Best for investing in managed funds
If you’re doing a Sharesies vs InvestNow comparison, you’ll be interested to learn that both providers provide access to managed funds.
InvestNow offers access to more than 140 funds from over 20 NZ and global fund managers, including:
- AMP Capital
- ANZ Investments
- Devon Funds
- Fisher Funds
- Russell Investments
You can choose from a regular investment plan or a one-off investment, and access funds that target international shares, listed property, fixed interest and more.
InvestNow doesn’t charge any transaction fees, but you’ll need to pay a fee to the fund manager. This varies depending on the fund you choose — as a general guide, expect to pay anywhere between 0.2% and over 3%.
The choice is more limited with Sharesies, where you can invest in a total of eight funds from the following fund managers:
- AMP Capital
- PIE Funds
Sharesies doesn’t charge fees on managed funds, so you’ll need to check with the fund provider for details of all costs involved.
About the contenders
Sharesies, InvestNow and Smartshares all have their strengths and weaknesses. If you want to invest directly in NZ or US shares, Sharesies is the clear choice. And because it also offers access to ETFs and managed funds, Sharesies wins points for offering potential diversification.
But InvestNow and Smartshares both offer a wide range of choice of managed funds and ETFs respectively, so they’re well worth considering if you want to invest in those options.
Ultimately, your investment goals and appetite for risk will help determine the platform you choose. Compare Sharesies, InvestNow and Smartshares with other online investing services to find the best platform for your needs.
More guides on Finder
Electric vehicle (EV) stocks to watch and how to invest
We take a closer look at six popular EV stocks and what they have to offer to Kiwi investors.
Review: Interactive Brokers online share trading broker
Interactive Brokers offers some of the lowest brokerage fees on the market, but there are caveats you need to be wary of.
How to invest in the ASX 200
Your simple guide to the S&P/ASX 200, how it works, and how to invest in this benchmark index from NZ.
Booster KiwiSaver review
Booster offers 15 different KiwiSaver funds for you to choose from.
kōura Wealth KiwiSaver
kōura Wealth offers personalised KiwiSaver plans to help you meet your long-term savings goals.
The best performing US ETFs of 2020
The best performing US ETFs over the past year, three years or five years can help inform your decision on what to invest in for the future.
Nikko AM KiwiSaver
Nikko AM offers a range of KiwiSaver funds, even customisable ones.
Is Sharesight the right performance tracker for your share portfolio? Find out in this review.
Investing – your options explored
Your simple guide to the different types of investments, how they work, and how to choose the right investments for your needs.
What is the S&P 500 and how can I invest in it from New Zealand?
Find out the different ways you can invest in the S&P 500 index from New Zealand.