Car insurance excess

What is a car insurance excess and how does it affect you?

Last updated:

A car insurance excess is the amount you pay when you want to make a claim. Excesses mainly exist to deter people from claiming really small damages, or claiming things too often.

It’s a toughie when you’re already stressed out from needing to make a claim, but unfortunately, all insurers have excesses in place. They can differ by thousands though, so if you haven’t already, review what excess you’re currently sitting on and consider lowering it if it’s out of your price range.

Keep in mind that your premiums will change depending on what your excess is. So if you have a high excess you’ll pay less on your premiums, but if you have a low excess you’ll have higher premiums.

What is car insurance excess?

The car insurance excess is the amount you will be required to pay when you make a claim on your policy. In other words, it’s the amount you agree to contribute towards the cost of a claim, with the insurer covering the remaining amount.

For example, if your policy has a $500 excess and you make a claim for $3,000 damage to your vehicle, you’ll cover the first $500 of the repair costs and the insurer will foot the bill for the remaining $2,500.

However, the amount of excess payable varies depending on a number of factors. Not only does the excess differ according to the policy you select, but you can also adjust your excess higher or lower to vary your premium amount. In addition, specific drivers such as those under 25 years of age, may be required to pay a higher excess amount.

Want to save more in the long run? Look for policies with low excesses

An excess is the amount you pay when you want to make a claim. Premiums are one thing, but if you have to fork out an extra $1,000 after you’ve had an accident, that can easily eat away at your bank account. Before you sign on the dotted line, have a careful look at what excesses you’d be paying if you want to claim.

Compare car insurance options in New Zealand

Name Product Accidental Damage Roadside Assistance New Car Replacement Fire and Theft
Cove Comprehensive (Full Cover) Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
New car cover for accidental cover of cars less than 12 months old
Yes
Join now and get one month free on your new policy worth up to $100. Monthly contracts you can cancel any time.
The Warehouse Everyday Plus  (Full Cover) Car Insurance
Covered up to the amount on your schedule
Optional
Up to $150,000
Yes
Protecta Comprehensive (Full Cover) Car Insurance
Yes
Yes
New for old replacement for vehicles less than a year old
Yes
Club Auto Comprehensive (Full Cover) Car Insurance
Yes
Yes
N/A
Yes
ANZ Comprehensive (Full Cover) Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
Should be less than 1 year old and has less than 15,000 kilometres on the odometer
Yes
Trade Me Comprehensive (Full Cover) Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
Market value
Yes
AMP Comprehensive (Full Cover) Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
Less than 1 year old
Yes
Vero Comprehensive (Full Cover) Car Insurance
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
ASB Comprehensive (Full Cover) Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
Yes
Yes
Tower Comprehensive (Full Cover) Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
Yes
Yes

Compare up to 4 providers

Name Product Accidental Damage Roadside Assistance New Car Replacement Fire and Theft
The Warehouse Third Party Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
No
No
Protecta Third Party Car Insurance
Yes
No
No
No
ANZ Third Party Car Insurance
Yes
No
No
No
Trade Me Third Party Accident Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
No
No
AMP Third Party Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
No
No
Vero Third Party Car Insurance
Up to $3,000
No
No
No
ASB Third Party Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
No
No
Tower Third Party Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
No
No
State Third Party Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
No
No
NZI Echelon Third Party Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
No
No

Compare up to 4 providers

Name Product Accidental Damage Roadside Assistance New Car Replacement Fire and Theft
The Warehouse Third Party, Fire and Theft Car Insurance
Covered up to the amount on your schedule
Optional
Up to $75,000
Yes
Protecta Third Party, Fire and Theft Car Insurance
Yes
No
No
Yes
Club Auto Third Party, Fire and Theft Car Insurance
Yes
Yes
N/A
Yes
ANZ Third Party, Fire and Theft Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
No
Yes
AMP Third Party, Fire and Theft Car Insurance
Up to $5,000
Optional
No
Yes
Vero Third Party, Fire and Theft Car Insurance
Up to $3,000
No
Yes
Yes
ASB Third Party, Fire and Theft Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
Yes
Yes
Tower Third Party, Fire and Theft Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
Yes
Yes
State Third Party, Fire and Theft Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
No
Yes
NZI Echelon Third Party, Fire and Theft Car Insurance
Yes
Optional
No
Yes

Compare up to 4 providers

Person-Driving

Why do insurers include an excess on their policies?

The purpose of car insurance excesses is to reduce the number of small claims insurers are required to pay out. If the excess didn’t exist, we’d all be able to lodge claims for every minor little bump, scratch and dent that our cars suffer.

While this may seem like a wonderful idea on the surface, in reality it would cause the cost of car insurance policies to skyrocket, and the premiums could leave a much bigger dent in your bank balance.

But by getting policyholders to agree to pay the first part of each claim themselves, insurers are able to prevent myriad of claims for minor repairs and therefore keep car insurance premiums down. This in turn means that you can fall back on car insurance in those situations where you really need the financial protection it provides.

What types of car insurance excess are there?

It wasn’t all that long ago that there was only one type of car insurance excess. These days there are several excesses that may apply, and it’s worth remembering that you may need to pay more than one excess when you make a claim. Common excesses include:

  • Basic or standard excess. This is the standard amount you will need to pay when you make a car insurance claim. When you fill out a quote, your excess will usually default at about the $400 mark, but you can make this higher or lower. If the claim is for an incident where you weren’t at fault, some insurers will waive the excess altogether while others will require you to pay it upfront and then refund the excess amount once the claim has been processed and your car repaired. However, keep in mind that there are some policies that will require you to pay an excess even if you were not at fault.
  • Voluntary excess. Most insurers allow you to pay an additional voluntary excess in return for a cheaper car insurance premium. Take a look at the ‘Can I reduce my excess?’ section further down the page for more information about how this works.
  • Age related excess. This excess applies to drivers under the age of 25 and reflects the fact that young drivers are statistically more likely to be involved in an accident or drive recklessly. The amount of a young driver excess varies substantially depending on your age. It must be paid on top of the basic excess when you claim for an incident that occurred with a young driver behind the wheel.
  • Licence related excess. In addition, the licence type may have an impact on your excess. A learner, restricted or overseas licence may have an additional excess.
  • Non-nominated driver excess. This excess may apply if you make a claim for an incident that occurred when your car was being driven by someone not listed on the policy. However, this excess isn’t charged by all insurers.
  • Specific driver excess. Some insurers will impose an additional excess for claims that arise when your car is being driven by a specific person listed on your policy. This excess is applied if the insurer determines there to be a higher level of risk associated with providing cover for that particular person.
  • Glass/windscreen excess. Some insurers will impose a specific excess for windscreen and window glass claims. However, many also offer the option to reduce or even waive this excess – if you’re willing to pay an additional premium, of course.

All of the excesses listed above may not apply to your car insurance policy. Check the fine print in the PDS for full details of what you’ll be required to pay when you make a claim.

Can I avoid paying a car insurance excess?

While you will most likely have to contribute some amount towards the cost of a claim, it’s possible in some cases to avoid paying a car insurance excess. Instances where you can avoid paying an excess include:

  • If the insurer allows you to waive the policy excess altogether by paying substantially higher premiums than would normally apply
  • If you were not at fault and you can meet any conditions outlined in your policy, for example providing the name, address and registration number of the person who was at fault
  • If you’re experiencing genuine financial hardship and are unable to pay your excess.

Whether or not you can avoid paying an excess will once again depend on the terms and conditions of your policy. Check the fine print closely to find out if you’ll have to dip into your own pocket every time you claim.

How do I pay an excess?

How you pay your excess depends on the insurer and the nature of your claim. When you lodge a claim, your insurance company will advise you whether the excess:

  • Will be deducted from any amount paid to you;
  • Must be paid to the insurer; or
  • Must be paid to the vehicle repairer when you collect your car.

When do I not have to pay an excess?

The circumstances when you do not have to pay a car insurance excess generally depend on the insurer and your individual policy. If your insurer agrees to waive all excesses when you pay an additional premium, for example, then you won’t have to worry about contributing towards the cost of the claim. Just keep in mind that the additional premium you’ll be required to pay will probably be fairly substantial.

If you’ve fallen on hard times, you may also not be required to pay an excess. Talk to the Financial Services Complaints Ltd (FSCL) if you’re experiencing financial difficulty and unable to pay the policy excess. You need to be able to demonstrate that you are experiencing financial hardship, and you may still be required to pay the insurance excess over time.

Do I need to pay a car insurance excess if I’m not at fault?

The other main situation where you may be able to avoid forking out to pay a car insurance excess is when you are not at fault for the incident being claimed. This is not always the case, as some policies require you to pay an excess regardless of who was at fault.

In other situations, you can avoid paying the excess if you were not at fault and you can meet the conditions outlined by the insurer. For example:

  • If the insurer agrees that you were not at fault in any way. It can be quite difficult to definitively prove that you did not contribute to an accident in some way, so establishing your innocence may not be as easy as you might think.
  • If you can provide the name, address and rego number of the at-fault driver. If this condition applies, problems may arise if the at-fault driver flees the scene of the accident, refuses to supply their details, or if you forget to gather their information in the stressful aftermath of an accident.
  • If the insurer recovers its costs from the at-fault driver. It could take months or years for this condition to be met, or it may never be met if the other driver is uninsured, can’t be found or refuses to pay the necessary amount.

So what can you do if you think you’re being unfairly asked to pay an excess? You could refuse to pay the excess and dispute it, but this means the insurer may not repair your car or may simply deduct the amount from any benefit you receive.

Another option is to pay the excess now, ensuring that your claim is processed quickly and you can get back on the road, and dispute the matter at a later date. However, it’s essential to seek independent legal advice before deciding on the best approach.

How much should I be paying?

The cost of your car insurance excess is determined when you take out cover. There’s a standard excess that applies to cover, but you can choose to adjust this to a higher level and receive lower premiums as a result. On the other hand, you may wish to lower the excess payable at claims time, which will of course lead to a higher premium.

The simplest way to find out the excess that applies to your policy is to check the certificate of insurance. You can also find a guide to the excesses imposed by your insurer in the PDS.

As a general guide, standard excesses tend to range from around $200 up to $700, but could be higher or lower depending on your circumstances.

Can I reduce my excess?

Yes, you can. When you apply for car insurance cover, many insurers will give you the option to choose your excess. You can:

  • Choose the standard excess amount quoted.
  • Increase your excess – doing so will lower your premium.
  • Reduce your excess – this will result in a higher premium.

Should I reduce my excess?

You’re the only person who can answer that question. It’s really up to you, your budget and which option you think will represent the best value for money.

For example, while lowering your excess will reduce the financial strain at claims time, it means you’ll need to pay more to purchase cover in the first place. On the other hand, increasing your excess makes cover more affordable but could put pressure on your budget if you ever need to make a claim.

Whether you decide to increase your excess, lower it or even keep it at the same level, make sure that you’ll be able to afford to pay premiums whenever they’re due, and that the excess payable when you need to claim won’t put you under significant financial strain.

Go to site