Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our content.
M1 Finance vs. Robinhood
The best platform depends on whether or not you prefer to pick and choose your own securities.
Both platforms offer commission-free trades, but are designed to attract two very different types of investors.
Which one is better?
- Choose M1 Finance if you’d like to have a robo-advisor manage your portfolio for you.
- Choose Robinhood if you prefer to buy and sell your own securities, or if you want early access to IPOs.
M1 Finance and Robinhood are two of the best-priced investment platforms on the market. It’s tough to compete with free, and that’s what these platforms provide – trades free from commissions and account management fees.
But outside their rock-bottom pricing, these platforms have little in common. And that’s because they’re designed to serve different types of investors.
For investors who want a robo-advisor for hands-off investing, M1 Finance stands at the ready. Among its perks are entirely customizable portfolios, automatic rebalancing and a healthy lineup of account options, including individual, retirement, joint and trust accounts. But the platform lacks tax-loss harvesting options and doesn’t offer portfolio recommendations.
Investors who want to execute their own trades and perform their own research will want to explore Robinhood. This beginner-friendly platform offers an intuitive user interface, access to the cryptocurrency market and instant deposits of up to $1,000. Plus, Robinhood has pre-IPO investing, a feature that gives Robinhood traders early access to IPO shares.
But investors should be aware of Robinhood service outages and its limited analysis software.
How do M1 Finance and Robinhood compare?
A look at fees, features, pros and cons for these two investment platforms:
|Overview||M1 Finance is a robo-advisor that puts you in the driver’s seat with fully customizable portfolios. It strikes a balance between automated investing and personalization, making it a good fit for hands-on, long-term investors.||Robinhood is a trading platform for beginners that offers easy-to-navigate software, no account minimums and no commission fees. Research and analytics tools are somewhat limited, but investors can bump up their brokerage account to Robinhood Gold for $5 monthly to receive Morningstar research reports, Nasdaq Level II Market Data and instant access to deposits of $5,000 to $50,000.|
|Minimum deposit to open||$100||$0|
|Tools and research|
|Reputation and customer reviews|
|Apple App Store reviews|
|Google Play Store reviews|
M1 Finance vs. Robinhood on fees and transparency
M1 Finance and Robinhood need to make money to stay in business. And while these two platforms earn money in similar ways, they have different attitudes on transparency.
Robinhood profits from payment for order flow
A commission-free platform means that Robinhood doesn’t profit from trades, right? Well, no — not exactly. At least, not the way you might think. Robinhood profits from a practice called payment for order flow (PFOF):
- Brokers route investor orders to middlemen called market makers.
- Market makers fill the order at a slightly better price and pocket the difference.
- As thanks for investor orders, market makers pay brokerages a fee.
That’s payment for order flow. And it’s been criticized for failing to serve the best interests of the investor. Now, this might not be quite so bad if Robinhood were up front about it. But it hasn’t been.
There is information on how Robinhood makes money on its website, but it’s difficult to find. You need to dig — deep. But it’s there.
Now, full disclosure: Robinhood published an article on PFOF that said it earned an average of $0.0023 per equity share traded in the fourth quarter of 2020. Fractions of a cent may not sound like much, but Robinhood has over 18 million accounts to its name.
M1 Finance profits from membership fees and payment for order flow
Like Robinhood, M1 Finance offers the use of its platform for free. And like Robinhood, it profits from payment for order flow — among other things, like membership fees and lending out investor cash holdings.
But unlike Robinhood, M1 Finance is transarent about it. In fact, it has a dedicated page on its website titled, “How M1 makes money.” On this page, it dives into detail on each of its revenue streams and says it makes about $0.002 per share from PFOF — roughly the same as Robinhood.
M1 Finance and Robinhood cater to two very different investors. Traders looking to buy and sell their own securities may benefit from Robinhood’s commission-free trades, but will need to be wary of service outages. Those ready to have a robo-advisor manage their assets will want to explore M1 Finance’s offerings, but should be prepared to devise their own asset allocation strategy.
Review your platform options with numerous providers to find the account best suited to your investment goals.
More guides on Finder
Sofi vs. Robinhood
Two trading platforms for beginners with no commission fees or bells and whistles. But which one comes out on top?
What a $70M fine means for Robinhood’s IPO and its users
While $70 million is a substantial fine, it doesn’t change the overall economics of the IPO. The company generated $522 million in revenue in the first quarter of 2021.
The best stock trading apps and platforms in the US
The best trading apps come with low fees and are easy to use.
Vanguard Digital Advisor review
Features and feedback to consider before you sign up for Vanguard Digital Advisor.
A beginner’s guide to retirement investing
What you need to know to start building your retirement nest egg.
Pros, cons and features to consider before you sign up with FutureAdvisor.
Coinbase vs Robinhood
Discover which exchange is better suited to cryptocurrency trading after comparing things like fees, security and features.
Best Roth IRA accounts of 2021
These Roth IRAs stand out for their competitive fees, intuitive platforms and practical research tools.
Fast trades, advanced tools and low commissions for experienced traders.
4 best trading apps of 2021
The best trading apps come with low fees and are easy to use.
Ask an Expert