Lying on an insurance application
11.8 million Americans admit to telling fibs when buying.
Honesty is the best policy. But not all Americans believe it gets them the best insurance policy, according to a recent study from finder.com.
Roughly 11.8 million American adults admit to lying to their insurer, which equates to about 4.61% of Americans. This number is way down compared to a 2018 Finder survey, which found that roughly 35 million Americans have played fast and loose with the facts when applying for insurance — about a 66.35% decrease in liars nationwide.
What types of insurance are Americans lying about?
Car insurance comes out on top, with nearly a third of people who said they lied to their insurance admitting it was to their auto insurer.
The next most common insurer that Americans have tried to deceive is their health insurer, with 27% fudging their applications. In third is life insurance at close to 15%.
|Type of insurance||% of lies||Estimated total insurance lies|
Why are Americans lying to their insurers?
Most Americans lie to their insurer for one simple reason: money. Roughly 29% of those who lied to an insurance company say their reason for doing so was because they’re higher risk and would have had to pay more for their premiums if they’d told the truth.
The second most common reason cited by Americans is they didn’t want to pay a higher premium, because they want to save money (23.75%) — which, if we’re being honest, is the same reason as the first but stripped of the self-conscious reasoning. Rounding out the top three is those who are unable to get insurance without lying — the reason cited by almost 19% of Americans.
Men are more likely than women to lie to insurers
Women have long been called the fairer sex, and it looks like they’re also more honest. Roughly 6.6 million men said they’d lied on an insurance application compared to 5.2 million women.
While women are less likely overall than men to lie on an insurance application, women lie more than men when it comes to their car, health and renters insurance.
On the other hand, men are far more likely than women to lie on applications for life, home, disability, travel, pet and income protection insurance.
|Type of insurance||% of men||% of women|
Does your age affect your willingness to lie to your insurer?
It turns out that the younger you are, the more likely you are to lie on your insurance application, with 6.33% of Gen Z saying they aren’t always truthful with their insurers. The trend continues with each generation more honest the older they get — millennials at 6.11%, Gen X at 4.53%, baby boomers at 3.95% and the silent generation as most honest at 1.22%.
Northeast is home to the most insurance fibbers
Those in the Northeast are most likely to take liberties with the truth when filling out an insurance application, with 5.54% saying they’d lied to their insurer. Those in the West are the most honest at 3.33%.
For media inquiries:
Public Relations Manager
More guides on Finder
Best and worst states for women in the US
How states compare on employment, earnings, poverty, education, health and wellbeing.
Black unemployment rates by state
Finder analyzes which states have the highest and lowest rates of employment for Black and African Americans.
Financial infidelity in America
Have you ever lied to your S.O. about your finances?
Which payment method do Americans prefer?
Finder analyzes which payment methods Americans prefer to use during the global health pandemic, finding that cash is no longer king.
Birth rates by state
Are birth and fertility talk the elephant in the womb? Finder research looks at birth rates, fertility rates and the average age of mothers in America.
64% of Americans admit to buyer’s remorse after they shop ’til they drop.
Which US states are hit most often by hurricanes?
We took a stroll down hurricane alley to learn which states are the most at risk for being hit, what time of year is the most active and which violent storms cost the most.
Processing fees and campaigns: How much are Americans spending?
Finder uncovers how much Americans are spending on payment processing fees for political campaign donations, who pays the fees and which companies are benefiting the most.
How would you spend your savings?
In the age of #adulting, Finder asks Americans what their financial priorities are and what they’re most willing to dip into their savings for.
Tipping in America
Cows and the Titanic aren’t the only ones who tip. Finder analyzes which Americans are the best tippers, where they live and how old they are.
Ask an Expert