These five repayment plans are designed to help you afford the monthly cost of your federal student loans if you have a high debt load compared to your salary. But they’re not right for everyone — in some cases, they could be more expensive than other options. And changing plans can come with an added cost.
What's in this guide?
What’s an income-driven repayment plan?
An income-driven repayment (IDR) plan is a type of federal plan to pay off your student loans that’s based on your income. Depending on which you choose, you’ll pay anywhere between 10% to 20% of your monthly discretionary income, based on annual updates. The government forgives any remaining balance after 20 or 25 years. You must sign up for one of these plans to qualify for Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF).
Which option is best for you depends on factors like your degree, loan type, when you took out your loans, your career plans, if you’re married and even how you file your taxes.
Can I update my income if my job has changed?
Yes. While you’re required to update your income each year, you can also make updates whenever your income has changed — like after you lose your job.
You can update your income on StudentAid.gov by clicking the link to annually recertify your income. Under Reason for income-driven repayment plan request, select “I am submitting documentation early to have my income-driven payment recalculated immediately.”
5 types of income-driven repayment plans
|Plan||Best for||Monthly repayment||Term|
|Revised Pay As You Earn (REPAYE) Plan||10% of your monthly discretionary income||Read more|
|Pay As you Earn (PAYE) Plan||20 years||Read more|
|Income-Based Repayment Plan||Read more|
|Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR) Plan||20% of your monthly discretionary income||25 years||Read more|
|Income Sensitive Repayment Plan||4% to 25% of your gross monthly income||Up to 10 years||Read more|
How do I calculate my monthly discretionary income?
Your monthly discretionary income is the difference between your pretax income and 150% of the poverty guideline in your state for the number of people in your family.
Here’s how to calculate it:
- Find the poverty guideline for your family size in your state on the Department of Health and Human Services website.
- Multiply that number by 1.5.
- Subtract the result from your annual salary before taxes.
- Divide the result by 12.
Pay attention to your plan if you’re married. Some might consider your individual income, while others might count you and your spouse’s income together.
Let’s take a look at an example …
Say you’re single and live in Texas. The poverty guideline for your state and family size is $12,490.
If you multiply that by 1.5, you get $18,735. If you make $50,000 a year, your annual discretionary income would be $50,000 minus $18,735 — or $31,265.
Divide that by 12 and you get a monthly discretionary income of $2,605.42.
Why sign up for an IDR plan?
You might want to sign up for an income-driven repayment plan if any of the following ring true for you:
- Want to qualify for PSLF. Only repayments under an IDR plan count toward this popular forgiveness program.
- Looking for lower monthly repayments. If you have a high debt-to-income ratio, signing up for an income-driven repayment plan can make your student loans more affordable in the short term.
- Want to have your loans forgiven at end of term. Any remaining balance on your student loans is forgiven at the end of the term — with the exception of the Income Sensitive Repayment Plan.
What are the drawbacks?
Consider these potential drawbacks before signing up for income-driven repayments:
- Not cheaper for everyone. If you owe less than you make in a year, you could actually end up paying more on an IDR plan compared to the alternatives.
- Interest capitalizes if you switch plans. This means that any unpaid interest that added up on an IDR plan gets added to your loan balance, increasing both the short- and long-term cost of your loan.
- Extra paperwork. You have to recertify your income each year to stay eligible for an IDR plan.
- Forgiveness might be taxable. The IRS generally considers forgiven debt taxable income, meaning you might get stuck with a higher tax bill — unless you qualify for PSLF or another forgiveness program with a work requirement.
How much will different IDR plans cost me?
You can find out which IDR plans you qualify for and how much each will cost you by using the Repayment Estimator on the Federal Student Aid (FSA) website.
Log in with your FSA ID and enter information about your family size, salary and state of residence. From there, you can see how much you might pay each month, the total cost of your loan, projected loan forgiveness and how long it’d take you to get out of debt.
Can I qualify for an IDR plan?
It depends on the income-driven repayment plan you’re interested in. You might need to meet some or all of the following criteria:
- Loan type. Not all federal loans are eligible for all IDR plans. Make sure yours qualify before you sign up.
- Debt-to-income ratio. For some plans, your IDR repayments must be lower than what they’d be on the 10-year Standard Repayment Plan. This all depends on how much debt you have in relation to your annual salary.
- Loan issue date. Some IDR plans don’t accept older student loans.
- Outstanding debts when loans were issued. Even if your loans were issued recently enough, you might not qualify if you were paying off older federal loans when you received those funds.
- Consolidation. Some types of loans must be consolidated before they can qualify for income-driven repayments, like Parent PLUS and FFEL Loans.
How do I sign up for an income-driven repayment plan?
You can sign up for an IDR plan by filling out a form on the Federal Student Aid website or completing the form by hand and mailing it to your loan servicer. The FSA recommends applying online, since it’s generally faster and simpler than applying by mail.
How long does it take to sign up?
It takes 10 minutes to half an hour to fill out the IDR application online. How long it takes for you to be enrolled in an IDR plan depends on your servicer, however. Since the coronavirus outbreak began, this process has slowed down — it can take as long as 30 days to make changes to your repayment plan or sign up for forbearance.
However, you don’t need to sign up for either until 2021. That’s because the Department of Education not only lowered the interest rate on federal student loans to 0%, but also paused repayments until December 31, 2020. You can still make repayments toward your principal during this time, but you don’t have to.
You can learn more with our guide to managing your student loans during the coronavirus.
How do I update my income?
Every year you’re required to recertify your income by updating information on your IDR form. You can also do this on the same FSA page you visited when you signed up for income-driven repayments.
3 alternatives to an income-driven repayment plan
Not sold on income-driven repayments? Consider one of these alternative plans instead:
- Standard Repayment Plan. While this 10-year plan will cost you the most up front, you’ll pay the least in interest and get out of debt the fastest than any other federal repayment plan.
- Graduated Repayment Plan. If you’re starting a career with the potential for a serious pay increase in the next decade, this plan allows you to start with low repayments that increase every two years.
- Extended Repayment Plan. This plan stretches out your loan term to 25 years with fixed or graduate repayments. In some cases, it could give you lower monthly repayments than any of the IDR plans.
Income-driven repayments are ideal if you have a high student debt load compared to your income — and they’re required if you want to apply for PSLF. But they might come with a higher monthly cost than other plans if you have a high income. And your interest capitalizes if you ever decide to switch plans.
You can learn more about your repayment options with our guide to student loan repayment plans.
Frequently asked questions
More guides on Finder
Student loan payment pause set to continue: What you need to know
President-elect Joe Biden plans to extend the pause on federal student loan payments and interest past January 31st — and may cancel some debt.
SBA reopens PPP loan applications — but not for everyone
First Draw loans are now available through nonprofit lenders, with Second Draw loans following shortly behind.
How to use life insurance to pay for retirement
A permanent life insurance policy’s cash value can be used as a retirement income supplement, though using it reduces your policy’s death benefit.
Student Freedom Initiative ISA review
An alternative to high-cost students loans for STEM majors at qualifying HBCUs.
Lendio reopens PPP loan application for small businesses
While you can get started on your loan application today — you’ll still need to wait for funding.
What the second stimulus means for student loans
No relief planned for borrowers after January 31, 2021 — but there are ways to keep costs down.
What the second stimulus means for your small business
You might be able to apply for more funding on your PPP loan, get a second PPP loan or take advantage of a new grant program.
Disability insurance for business owners
Getting a policy can be complicated, but it offers protection for you and your employees.
What’s in the second stimulus package for COVID-19 relief?
Find out who’s getting checks, unemployment benefits, student loan relief and more.
Wise Loan review
Wise Loan may be an expensive choice, but it’s upfront about its costs.
Ask an Expert