Compare: Casper vs. Purple mattress

Two top brands go head to head in the online mattress game.

Without the ability to try out your mattress before you buy it, you’re taking a shot in the dark on a big purchase — even with the risk-free trials most online companies now offer. So you’re on point for comparing contenders before committing to a decade of sleeps on your new bed.

Casper and Purple are two of the more popular online mattress brands manufactured in the States, yet you’ll find a few notable differences to factor into your decision.

Compare Casper vs. Purple features

Overview of Casper

Casper launched in 2014 as Casper Sleep, and it’s been on the up and up ever since. Though plenty of other brands like it abound, Casper remains one of the more popular and financially successful online mattress companies around.Buy everything from your new mattress to your dog’s new bed from Casper, plus sheets, pillows, mattress protectors, bed frames and even a subscription to its magazine, Woolly. Casper offers three mattress models, each made of varying layers of foam. The Wave, its newest and most expensive model, includes an extra layer of high-resiliency gel to help your body contour to your bed.

Overview of Purple

Purple was founded by two brothers in 2015, with its now patented hyper-elastic polymer material at the center of its mission: to help people sleep better without spending more. Hyper-elastic polymer is a fancy way of referring to a stretchy material that’ll relaxes under pressure points, so you don’t feel like you’re sleeping on a rock.You now have two Purple mattress models to choose from: the Original Purple and the New Purple. Other than price, the main difference between the two is that the new model adds a spring-coil supportive base to the bottom, as well as a customizable foam layer.

Compare Casper vs. Purple financing

Casper and Purple both offer a range of sizing and price options. But Purple is slightly more expensive. Casper mattresses range from $350 to $2,395, whereas Purple ranges from $699 to $3,499.

If you’d rather not pay for your new bed in one chunk, both brands offer nearly identical financing solutions through Affirm.

Shipping and returns

Casper and Purple both offer free shipping and returns on all mattress purchases, as well as a risk-free 100-night trial. If you’re not in love with your bed after 100 days, contact customer support for a free pickup.

Note that Casper and Purple mattresses are both available through Amazon, but mattresses purchased through the online marketplace adhere to Amazon’s return policy, not the mattress company’s.

Trial periods

Enjoy 100 nights of risk-free sleeping to learn if your new Casper or Purple mattress or pillow is the right fit. Both companies will arrange a free pickup of your mattress if you don’t love it.

All Casper products qualify for this same 100-night trial and free return policy. But Purple doesn’t accept returns on sheets, mattress protectors or bases.

Positive online reviews

According to online reviewers, Purple’s biggest compliment is that it sleeps cooler than many of other foam-based mattresses out there. Purple also gets kudos for providing plenty of support and being downright comfortable.

Casper’s claim to fame is durability, as well as being a good choice for people with back pain. Plus, folks online rave about how smooth and easy the ordering, delivery and setup process was with Casper.

Customer service experience

Casper customer service holds steady with great online reviews, even during the return process. Some online reviewers said that although they ended up returning the product, they were pleased with the service.

Online reviews for Purple, on the other hand, aren’t quite as stellar. Some customers report problems with long waits for mattress deliveries, unanswered emails and phone calls and a stressful return process.

Bottom line

Casper and Purple mattresses have lots of similarities, including the same trial period, warranty and free shipping and returns policies. They differ in how they’re made of, price and customer service ratings.

If neither Casper nor Purple sound like the right fit for you, compare other online mattress options to find your dream bed.

Frequently asked questions

• Which lasts longer: Casper or Purple?

  Purple might last slightly longer, but we can’t say for sure. Both of these brands are fairly new to the market, so there isn’t much long-term data on how long they might hold up. Some experts expect Purple’s specialized polymer material to be a bit more durable than Casper’s foam, though. Both companies offer 10-year warranties.

• Is Purple a nontoxic mattress?

  Yes. Purple claims there’s no off-gassing with its mattresses, and the company only uses CertiPUR-US–certified foam in its products.

• Is Casper a nontoxic mattress?

  Yes. Casper says that every layer of foam is made with CertiPUR-US–certified materials.

• Do Casper mattresses sleep hot?

  They might. Some online reviews say that Casper mattresses sleep on the hot side, although the company advertises that a layer of breathable comfort foam keeps the mattress cool.