Our top pick: Metromile
- Start with low rates at $29/month, plus pennies per mile
- Mileage over 250 in a day is free
- Intuitive app that helps with claims, ID cards and car health updates
- 24/7 customer support for help around the clock
Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our content.
Metromile vs. American Family: Discounts, quotes, and comparison
Metromile vs. American Family
Guides
Vehicle Guides
Need Financing?
Sign up & start saving!
Get our weekly newsletter for the latest in money news, credit card offers + more ways to save
Metromile and American Family may not be as visible as State Farm, Geico or Allstate. However, they offer surprising benefits that might make them worth your while.
Many consumers may not know that American Family is one of the largest auto insurers in the United States. The company has been around for 90 years, so it may be the right pick if you’re looking for an experienced player in the insurance market.
On the opposite side of the spectrum is Metromile . Founded in 2011, it’s a very young company. It’s been gaining attention, however, because of its pay-by-mile insurance. With this type of coverage, you pay a flat monthly rate and a per-mile rate.
|
|
|
|---|---|
| Pay only for the miles you drive, plus enjoy app services you won’t find everywhere like claims and car health updates. | American Family Insurance aims to gain the trust of their customers through top-notch customer service and protection. |
| AZ, CA, IL, NJ, OR, PA, VA, WA | AZ, CO, GA, ID, IL, IN, IA, KS, MN, MO, NE, NV, ND, OH, OR, SD, UT, WA, WI |
| Optional | Optional |
| Yes | Yes |
| No | Yes |
| No (they used to offer the service but they are no longer accepting new applications) | Yes |
| Yes |
Yes |
| Online Phone |
online phone |
| monthly |
12 months monthly custom |
| Yes | Yes |
| Yes | Yes |
| No | No |
| No | Yes |
| Yes | Yes |
| Yes | Yes |
| Yes | Yes |
| Yes | Yes, up to 10% |
| No | No |
| No | Yes |
| Yes | Yes |
|
|
|
Bottom line
Metromile may be the right choice if you want pay-by-mile insurance. Through the insurer, you may pay low premiums if you drive very little. American Family doesn’t offer pay-by-mile coverage, but it gives discounts for drivers who accumulate less than 7,500 miles per year.
For a large insurer, American Family scores quite well on claims satisfaction. It received a four-out-of-five score from J.D. Power — a higher grade than what most large insurers earn. Though Metromile hasn’t received a J.D. Power rating, many of its customers report a slow claims process.
If you’re on the hunt for discounts, American Family may be the right pick. It offers promotions like good-student, defensive-driver, low-mileage and young-volunteer discounts. It also gives vehicle discounts for airbags and auto-safety equipment. Metromile offers discounts only if you insure multiple vehicles.
Compare your car insurance options to find the best insurance company for you.
Compare alternatives to Metromile and American Family
More guides on Finder
-
Best cashback credit cards
The top cards often have cashback rewards of 5% or more. But which one is the best for you depends on how you spend.
-
Which payment method do Americans prefer?
Finder analyzes which payment methods Americans prefer to use during the global health pandemic, finding that cash is no longer king.
-
How much does health insurance cost?
Most working Americans pay around $1,489 in premiums each year. Compare costs now.
-
Processing fees and campaigns: How much are Americans spending?
Finder uncovers how much Americans are spending on payment processing fees for political campaign donations, who pays the fees and which companies are benefiting the most.
-
Compare the best auto and renters insurance bundles
The best companies blend wide auto and renters coverage, free perks and strong value.
-
Senior driving stats
Compare the good and the risky sides of driving when you’re a senior.
-
Compare the best online car insurance companies
Compare the 5 best digital-focused car insurance companies.
-
Best disability insurance companies of 2021
Compare the best disability insurance companies in the US and learn how to apply for a policy.
-
How does coronavirus affect car insurance?
The virus won’t change coverage, but it could affect claims and communication with your insurance company.
-
Can I get car insurance premium forgiveness during the coronavirus outbreak?
Car insurance companies are chiming in with payment extensions or waived fees for financial relief.
Ask an Expert