We value our editorial independence, basing our comparison results, content and reviews on objective analysis without bias. But we may receive compensation when you click links on our site. Learn more about how we make money from our partners.
Who has better benefits than USAA car insurance?
USAA offers a well-balanced package, but other providers stand out in key areas.
USAA has a longstanding reputation for its customer service and low rates, and it works a lot like a AAA membership for the military. Most competitors don’t include the exact member offerings that USAA does. However, you have other choices if you’re looking for solid coverage and cheaper rates or want to compare military benefits.
What's in this guide?
Pros
- Member benefits. Discounts and member benefits for insurance, banking and investing and active military support for overseas car purchases.
- Dividend policies. Get an annual check or policy rebate for that year’s profits.
- Flexible payments. Adjust payment to fit your military pay schedule.
- Steep discounts. Find savings for low mileage, accident forgiveness and storing your car on base. Plus, reduce your premium up to 60% for a storage policy while on active duty.
Cons
- Military-affiliated drivers only. Coverage made for the military and their families only.
- Online claims focus. You can’t file a claim by phone, a personal touch that many customers prefer. However, there is a general support number.
- Doesn’t cover other vehicles directly. What about your motorcycle or RV? You might have to use third-party coverage to bundle with your USAA policy.
Other car insurance similar to USAA
Geico
Comparable to USAA, this company offers government-minded service with military benefits like a dedicated customer service team. However, Geico covers drivers outside of the military, and has steep discount opportunities that could lead to a premium lower than USAA.
Pros
- Discounted rates. Geico offers discount opportunities like bundling with home coverage, safety equipment and a good driver discount.
- Diverse customer base. The company caters to a variety of customers including federal employees and high-risk drivers.
- Military benefits. Geico offers exclusive military benefits, including 24/7 customer service, worldwide coverage and military discounts.
- Flexible payments. The company lets you choose your payment schedule from one to six installments. Military members also have a military pay plan available.
Cons
- Online claims focus. The company encourages customers to use its online customer service and claims primarily. However, it offers a convenient app.
- Low customer reviews. Negative reviews on Trustpilot and the Better Business Bureau, complain about the company’s claims process and settlements.
- Limited in-person locations. Geico has physical offices in several locations. But you might not get the facetime you’re looking for if you don’t live within a reasonable distance.
Esurance
Like USAA, this company stands out for competitive rates. However, you might find its payment options stingy and hidden billing fees unhelpful.
Pros
- Low rates. Customers enjoy the company’s competitive costs for standard and optional coverage like rental car and customized parts coverage.
- Helpful website and online tools. Esurance provides you with quick online quotes and helpful resources for understanding coverage and lowering your premium.
- No cancellation fees for military. The company helps its military customers by waiving fees and staying flexible with policy cancellations and reinstatement for active military.
Cons
- Other possible hidden fees. Customers complain about charges for check payments and billing statements.
- No local agents. The company keeps business dealings online or by phone — a deal-breaker for those wanting a personal experience.
- Automatic payments. Setting up automatic payments might conflict with your payment schedule.
- Negative customer reviews. Over 300 customer complaints on the Better Business Bureau website, include negative reviews about premium increases, billing problems and customer service. However, many drivers tend to only leave reviews after a negative experience.
Progressive
Similar to USAA, this top national provider is a transparent company that helps you purchase only the coverage you need at a price that matches your budget. However, it doesn’t offer the military benefits that USAA advertises.
Pros
- Many points of contact. Contact the company with your questions or account needs by phone, mail or online via your account, chat, email, social media or app.
- Insightful rate tools. Stay inside your budget by using the company’s coverage and comparison tools. These tools let you find the coverage you need at your named price and compare rates with competitors.
- Accident forgiveness. Get small claims or your first major accident waived.
- Top national insurer. Progressive is a top insurance name with decades of underwriting experience.
Cons
- Negative feedback. Although the company closes out its complaints, Progressive has over 2,000 complaints filed with the Better Business Bureau.
- Standard six-month terms. The company keeps a six-month standard policy term, which could mean rate increases sooner than longer-term policies. However, this short term could help active military members on the verge of deployment.
- No military benefits. The company doesn’t advertise any military discounts or benefits, although it might work to meet these honored customers’ needs on a case-by-case basis.
Compare car insurance providers
Who has cheaper insurance than USAA?
These top companies compete with USAA in value for coverage, and a few may be cheaper depending on your area, age or driving record.
Cheaper across many age groups.
In our comparison, Esurance beat USAA in California and New York across all age groups. But this provider might not bring the lowest rates by age in other states like Texas or Georgia.
In our comparison, Esurance beat USAA in California and New York across all age groups. But this provider might not bring the lowest rates by age in other states like Texas or Georgia.
Cheapest for specific geographic areas.
Many customers tout this provider’s cheap rates above all other providers. We found that Geico had lower rates than USAA especially for New York drivers.
Many customers tout this provider’s cheap rates above all other providers. We found that Geico had lower rates than USAA especially for New York drivers.
Possibility in high-density areas.
This top provider had the lowest cost in New York compared to other providers listed here. So it might be a strong option for highly populated areas or states with high average premiums. On the downside, there’s no military discount for extra savings.
This top provider had the lowest cost in New York compared to other providers listed here. So it might be a strong option for highly populated areas or states with high average premiums. On the downside, there’s no military discount for extra savings.
On par with Progressive, plus a military discount.
Rates here mirrored Progressive’s low rates for highly populated areas, but it also includes a military discount and is bent toward high-risk drivers.
Rates here mirrored Progressive’s low rates for highly populated areas, but it also includes a military discount and is bent toward high-risk drivers.
How we compared rates.
We compared rates from several USAA competitors using quotes from similar driver profiles. Profile details included:
- Single
- Good credit
- Sedan
- State minimum insurance
- Currently insured
- Driver ages 18, 25, 35, 45, and 56
- Men and women
Which providers have military benefits like USAA?
USAA beats many competitors with military benefits because of its wide range of products and membership savings. But Geico and Esurance caters to the military crowd with several benefits also:
Geico
- 24/7 military-dedicated customer service
- Custom insurance card
- Military pay plan
- Worldwide coverage
- Military discount up to 15%
- Emergency deployment discount up to 25%
Esurance
- No cancellation fees
- Simple policy reinstatement with proof of deployment
- No reinstatement surcharges
- Help finding a new policy if you move outside Esurance service areas
Providers with military discounts
A handful of insurers also extend a thank you with a discount for military service:
- Arbella
- Electric Auto
- Geico
- Liberty Mutual
- Progressive
- Titan
- The General
Which providers have flexible payments like USAA?
| Company | Payment options |
|---|---|
| Ameriprise | 6-month or customized |
| Arbella | Annual or customized |
| Auto-Owners | Annual or customized |
| Cameron | Annual or customized |
| Chubb | Annual or customized |
| Country Financial | 6-month, annual or customized |
| Farmers | Monthly or customized plans |
| Geico | 1 to 6 installments, annual or customized |
| Michigan Farm Bureau | Monthly, 3-month, 6-month or annual |
| National General | 6-month, annual or customized |
| Safeco | Monthly or customized |
Bottom line
You might not find an exact match to USAA for insurance products, banking and investing products. However, you can compare other car insurance providers to find the flexibility, low rates and military benefits you’re looking for.
Read more on this topic
-
Noblr car insurance review Noblr car insurance offers monthly premium discounts based on your safe driving habits.
-
Compare carshare car insurance Make sure the free insurance offered by carshare services is enough protection for you.
-
Compare car insurance for self-employed drivers Self-employed drivers need to balance getting the best rates with protecting their business.
-
Compare Allstate car insurance discounts You could save well over 30% by taking advantage of Allstate’s numerous car insurance discounts.
-
Compare Liberty Mutual car insurance discounts Save extra money with Liberty Mutual by taking advantage of its numerous car insurance discounts.
-
Which gas should you use in your car? When should you use regular, premium or E85 gas? And what if you use the wrong kind?
-
How does car insurance cover additional drivers? Insurance should cover drivers listed on your policy, but double-check how your company handles unnamed drivers.
-
Compare car insurance with accidental death benefits An accidental death benefits rider can help cover funeral expenses after a fatal car accident.
-
Does driver assist technology affect car insurance? Driver assist technology won’t discount your insurance premium, but it could save your life.
-
Ferrari LaFerrari car insurance rates You can expect to pay a lot to buy — and insure — this hybrid hypercar from Ferrari.