Sign up & start saving!
Get our weekly newsletter for the latest in money news, credit card offers + more ways to save
Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our content.
Who has better car insurance coverage than Progressive?
Drive away with value car insurance coverage that suits you best.
Guides
Vehicle Guides
Need Financing?
What's in this guide?
This company shows confidence and customer care with transparent rates and coverage tools, to help you find the policy that’s right for you. Plus, you can get add-ons and safe driving rewards that you won’t see matched with every provider. Although Progressive stays a top choice for many, consider all your options for wide coverage and low rates.
Pros and cons of Progressive
Pros
- High transparency. To show customer needs come first, progressive lets you compare coverage and rates from its own website.
- Wide coverage options. All the basics, plus coverage for custom parts, pet injuries and SR-22 drivers.
- Steep safe driver discount. Safe drivers could ride with a 31% lighter premium than riskier drivers.
- Top market pick. The company lands in the top three of the largest car insurers in the market, making it a top choice for customers.
Cons
- Priced higher than competitors. If budget is a main concern for you, it’s not the cheapest option.
- Six-month terms come standard. These short terms don’t lock in your rates like an annual policy.
- Many customer complaints. Progressive has over 2,000 complaints filed with the Better Business Bureau (BBB), while its a high number the insurer has taken care of these complaints..
Providers with wide coverage like Progressive
State Farm
4.5 / 5 ★★★★★
Like Progressive, State Farm holds the top spot for the most market share and premiums written, a testament to its experience. However, the company may have higher insurance rates and has many complaints despite its push for personalized customer service.
- Number one in the market
- Local agents
- Wide coverage, including travel interruption and ridesharing
- Nearly 1,500 BBB complaints filed
- Possibility for upselling products
- Higher rates than many providers
| Available states | All 50 states |
|---|---|
| Roadside assistance | Optional |
| Payment schedule | 12 months, 6 months, Monthly |
| New car protection | |
| Claims method | Online, Phone |
| Accident forgiveness | Yes |
| New car protection coverage | Yes |
|---|---|
| Roadside assistance | Optional |
| Accident forgiveness | Yes |
USAA
5 / 5 ★★★★★
Much the same as Progressive, this company also has helpful coverage, wide membership benefits that rival AAA and flexible payments. But USAA also niches its customer base to members of the military and their families, a possible win for customized service but a downside for many drivers.
- Wide membership benefits
- Dividend policies
- Payment flexibility
- Cheap storage policies for active military
- Online-only claims
- Limited to the military and their families
- Uses third parties for other insurance products
| Available states | All 50 states |
|---|---|
| Roadside assistance | Optional |
| Payment schedule | 12 months, 6 months, custom |
| New car protection | |
| Claims method | Online, Phone |
| Accident forgiveness | Yes |
| New car protection coverage | No |
|---|---|
| Roadside assistance | Optional |
| Accident forgiveness | Yes |
Amica
4.5 / 5 ★★★★★
Comparable to Progressive, this provider lands top Finder ratings for its customer service and wide coverage, including high-risk driver coverage and a platinum package that includes full glass and identity theft protection, plus high limits for rental cars. While Amica doesn't make the cheapest car insurers list, it could be a solid pick if you're looking for better customer service than Progressive.
- Highly rated customer service
- Wide coverage and benefits
- Safe driving rewards
- Dividend policies
- High rates
- Mixed customer reviews
- Not available in Hawaii
| Available states | Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming |
|---|---|
| Roadside assistance | Optional |
| Payment schedule | 6 months, monthly |
| New car protection | |
| Claims method | online, email, phone |
| Accident forgiveness | Yes |
| New car protection coverage | Yes |
|---|---|
| Roadside assistance | Optional |
| Accident forgiveness | Yes |
Geico
4 / 5 ★★★★★
Much like Progressive, this company has a famous reputation for cheap car insurance rates, and it even follows up those low rates with more discount opportunities. Yet Geico does hold a whopping 3,000 customer complaints filed with the BBB.
- Low rates
- Steep safety discounts
- Customized payment schedule
- Helpful add-ons
- Online-focused service
- Limited local agents
- Poor customer reviews
| Available states | All 50 states |
|---|---|
| Roadside assistance | Optional |
| Payment schedule | 12 months, 6 months, custom |
| New car protection | |
| Claims method | Online, Phone, Agent |
| Accident forgiveness | Yes |
| New car protection coverage | Yes |
|---|---|
| Roadside assistance | Optional |
| Accident forgiveness | Yes |
Who has cheaper insurance than Progressive?
Progressive has middle-of-the-road rates compared to other providers, though some customers can find the cheapest rates from Progressive. If you’re looking for the best value for coverage, look at these cheaper options:
| Provider | Average monthly rate |
|---|---|
| Progressive | $143.66 |
| Geico | $115.91 |
| USAA | $116.58 |
| Esurance | $123.16 |
| 21st Century | $141.75 |
| Kemper | $143.58 |
Which providers are also popular choices?
Progressive ranks at the top, but consider other top providers on the list who have the standout features you’re looking for. Providers who write the most premiums:
- State Farm: $41.8 billion
- Geico: $29.6 billion
- Progressive: $22.8 billion
- Allstate: $21.4 billion
- USAA: $13.2 billion
Which providers also have steep safe driver discounts?
Nearly every provider on the market offers discounts or rewards for safe drivers, but they’re not all as competitive as Progressive. Keep in mind that your savings will vary based on your specific driving record.
Providers with the best-known discounts (some providers don’t specify):
| Provider | Safe driver discount | Usage-based discount |
|---|---|---|
| Progressive | Up to 31% | Yes |
| Esurance | Up to 40% | No |
| Geico | Up to 25% | Yes |
| AAA | Up to 20% | No |
| American Family | Up to 10% | No |
| Direct Auto | Up to 10% | No |
| Allstate | Yes | Yes |
| Farm Bureau Mutual | Yes | Yes |
| Liberty Mutual | Yes | Yes |
| Metromile | No | Yes |
| Mile Auto | No | Yes |
| Nationwide | Yes | Yes |
| Titan | Yes | Yes |
| USAA | Yes | Yes |
Compare car insurance like Progressive
Bottom line
Drawn to Progressive’s transparent pricing and wide coverage? The company leads the pack as a top customer choice, but there are other provider choices to consider with similar coverage and unique features.
More guides on Finder
-
Compare full coverage vs. liability car insurance
Which type of car insurance policy fits your car and driving needs?
-
2020 shakes up the car insurance industry in a good way
A company you’ve never heard of just made it to the top for customer satisfaction. Here’s who did what to better serve their customers.
-
Car insurance for drivers 25 to 40 years old
Take advantage of the lowest minimum coverage rates by earning all the discounts you can.
-
Heacock Classic car insurance review March 2021
Insure your classic car or race car at agreed value with Heacock Classic, but you’ll have to look elsewhere if you have recent claims or major violations.
-
Doggo pet insurance review Mar 2021
With round-the-clock support, customer experience and policy perks are this company’s claim to fame.
-
Driving without car insurance
Since driving uninsured comes with steep penalties, look at your coverage options or consider alternatives.
-
Say car insurance review Mar 2021
Offers a transparent look at your premiums and rewards renewal with a better insurance score.
-
Compare telehealth physical therapy
Compare insurance coverage and treatment options and find a telehealth physical therapist online.
-
Acceptance car insurance review Mar 2021
Consider Acceptance if you’re a high-risk driver, but prepare for the possibility of a negative customer service experience.
-
Root home insurance review March 2021
Put down roots with discounted coverage for car and home insurance in 12 states.