Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our content.
Is it a good idea to buy a rental car?
Consider whether that low sticker price outweighs extra mileage and wear.
If you’re considering buying a used car, you might want to consider your rental car options first. You can often find newer models at more competitive prices than you’d get through a used car dealership or private seller. But with that lower price tag comes higher mileage — and a lower resale value — should you choose to sell it down the road.
Why should I consider buying a rental car?
With well-maintained options at competitive price points, choosing to buy a rental car comes with 4 key benefits.
1. Regular routine maintenance
Most rental car companies maintain their fleets regularly. This means you can trust the car has received servicing for any damages as well as for regular mileage upkeep. Reputable companies will follow manufacturer-suggested maintenance and keep qualified mechanics on hand to ensure that vehicles continue to run smoothly.
Fleet cars also receive regular cleaning between rentals and are typically inspected thoroughly before they’re put on the market. While no rental company can control how a renter drives its cars, many take steps to ensure the car is in the best possible condition when you buy it.
2. Competitive prices
2 factors affect the price of rental cars: the general stigma against them and the frequent influx of similar models into the market.
Because of this, rental companies tend to sell these cars at no-haggle prices set below market value. You typically can’t negotiate the price down, but you’ll often get a better deal than if you’d bought a similar model from a dealership or private seller.
Look for average prices on sites like CARFAX Canada or the Canadian Black Book to confirm you’re getting a competitive offer.
3. Simplified shopping experience
A car rental company’s inventory is generally limited to base models from the previous year. So, instead of spending a lot of time comparing trivial factors between many cars, you can focus on major differences in the mileage and vehicle history report.
If you manage to find a car with a competitive price tag, low mileage and minimal flaws, your shopping experience is that much simpler.
4. Newer models
Rental car companies attract customers by offering models that are only 12-18 months old. This is ideal for buying a used car, especially if you opt for a manufacturer that allows you to transfer the warranty to a second owner. You’ll enjoy relatively new technology and safety features at a fraction of the price of a similar model from a dealership or private seller.
What to watch out for when buying a rental car
Though you can often snag a competitive price when buying a rental car, consider 4 potential drawbacks.
1. Increased wear and tear
Rental cars aren’t always treated kindly by renters, which can result in a lot of damage over a short time. Issues can range from minor issues like extra stains and scratches to bigger problems caused by renters pushing the car to its limits. While reputable rental car companies perform regular maintenance and cleaning, a year or two of constantly changing hands can take its toll on any vehicle.
2. Higher mileage
Most rental cars come with higher mileage than a similarly aged used car from a private seller or dealership. Larger rental car companies typically sell vehicles in their fleet after they’ve reached 40,000 to 65,000 km, which may be racked up in just 12-18 months. But because rental cars are often well maintained, you may decide that high mileage isn’t such a big deal.
3. Limited inventory
The downside to a simplified shopping experience is that your selection is limited to the makes and models on hand. And because rental companies don’t often opt for upgrades and add-ons, most cars are base models.
However, rental companies experience frequent turnover, so you might find what you’re looking for by continually checking back on new options that are available.
4. Lower resale value
Rental cars have lower resale values than other used cars — mainly due to the stigma that landed you a good deal in the first place.
A large number of rental cars on the market can also affect your car’s resale value. If you plan to keep your rental car for the long term, this won’t matter. But if you’re thinking of trading in your car in a few years, you won’t get as much money as you would have if you’d opted for a traditional used car.
4 tips for buying a rental car
Follow trusted pointers to shopping for a former rental without getting stuck with a lemon:
- Take a test drive. Beyond inspecting the car for obvious signs of body and interior damage, ask to take it for a test drive. Make note of how it drives, the car’s performance and any features that don’t appear to work properly.
- Request a history report. Any used car you buy should come with a vehicle history report, which details accidents the car has been in and repairs made. If you’re on the fence between 2 cars, you might want to opt for the one with a cleaner report.
- Look up recalls. Rental car companies are required to fix recalls that apply to cars in their fleets. The vehicle history report should list recalls for your vehicle, and you can check Transport Canada’s Road Safety Database with the car’s VIN to confirm.
- Schedule an inspection. The rental car company should allow you to get the car inspected by a third-party mechanic before you buy. That way, you can make sure there aren’t major mechanical issues that can affect you down the road.
Compare car loan options
If you’re looking to save money on a used car, a former rental car may offer a better deal than a traditional used car from a dealership. But consider the higher mileage and extra wear and tear that typically comes with rental cars before making a decision.
Ready to make a purchase? Compare your car loan options before hitting the rental car lot.
Frequently asked questions
More guides on Finder
Apple vs Tesla stocks
We compare the price performance, dividends and business models behind two of the biggest companies on Wall Street.
How to buy Hello Inc. (HELO) stock in Canada when it goes public
Everything we know about the Hello Inc. IPO, plus information on how to buy in.
Biden plans another boost for electric car stocks
Biden’s plan to replace the federal fleet with American-made electric vehicles gives another boost to a red-hot sector led by Tesla.
How to invest $10k
Grow your wealth the smart way with these top 6 picks.
Compare cheap pet insurance
Compare the cheap pet insurance with low deductibles, coverage limits and plan features.
How to lower car insurance costs
You don’t need to pay more for car insurance than necessary. Find out the 9 easiest ways to pay less and save on your monthly car insurance bill.
How to buy Proterra (PTRA) stock in Canada when it goes public
Here’s everything we know so far about the Proterra IPO.
Canada Drives car loan review
Canada Drives simplifies the process of buying a car, showing you how much you can borrow along with a list of vehicles you’ve already qualified for based on your approved financing.
aha home insurance review
Consider aha insurance if you’re searching for a simple, affordable and fast home insurance solution.
Onlia car insurance review
Onlia auto insurance is a favourable solution for individuals that want quick, easy-to-understand coverage.
Ask an Expert
You must be logged in to post a comment.