Example: Natasha chooses between a gold and platinum credit card
Natasha is interested in getting a premium credit card to earn rewards points. She immediately recognizes that she doesn’t earn enough to receive an invitation to apply for a black credit card, so she will choose between a gold and platinum card. To help her make a decision, Natasha decides to compare a credit card from each of these categories.
Card | APR | Annual fee | Points per $ | Min.income | Additional benefits |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Scotiabank Gold American Express Card | 20.99% | $120 | 1–5 points per $1 spent | $12,000 | 40,000 welcome bonus points, travel and car rental insurance coverage, and access to concierge services and airport lounges. |
American Express Platinum Card | N/A | $699 | 1–3 points per $1 spent. | Not listed. | 80,000 welcome bonus points, $200 in annual credit, airport lounge access, concierge and dining program, car rental, travel, medical and emergency insurance and much more. |
With these details in mind, Natasha considers her own circumstances and spending habits:
- She regularly uses a credit card for everyday purchases.
- She spends around $5,000 per month on her credit card.
- Her annual salary is $85,000.
- She takes 1 overseas vacation per year.
- She aims to pay her balance in full each month.
- Her credit score is excellent.
Since Natasha meets the spend requirement for both credit cards, she could potentially be eligible for both. The Scotia card allows her to earn more points on everyday expenses such as gas, groceries, dining and entertainment, while the Amex offers fewer points for specific categories such as dining and travel. Natasha only goes overseas once a year so she decides to go for the much cheaper Scotiabank Gold American Express Card. Had she travelled more regularly throughout the year, she would have chosen the powerful American Express Platinum Card.
* This is a fictional, but realistic, example.