Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our opinions or reviews. Learn how we make money.

Bonanza vs. eBay: Costs and features compared

Find the best e-commerce marketplace for online sellers with our head-to-head comparison.

Posted

Fact checked

In 1995 eBay began as an e-commerce pioneer and remains one of the world’s most popular online marketplaces. Bonanza was established in 2007 as an eBay alternative and now boasts more than 25,000 online sellers.

But which of these marketplaces is the best choice for your e-commerce business? We compared Bonanza and eBay side by side across four key categories to find out.

Quick verdict

Which has lower fees?

Bonanza

Bonanza’s transaction fees are based on how much your sells item for, or the final offer value (FOV).

  • FOV less than $500: 3.5% fee
  • FOV over $500: 3.5% + 1.5% of the amount over $500

Pricing increases when you add advertising tiers:

  • Basic program: Up to 9% fee
  • Standard: Up to 13% fee
  • Superior: Up to 19% fee
  • Elite: Up to 30% fee

Pay for a membership for access to features like Stripe Checkout, Facebook advertising and more.

  • Silver: $12 monthly
  • Gold: $25 monthly
  • Platinum: $55 monthly
  • Titan: $167 monthly
  • Titan Ad Pro: $250 monthly

eBay

Individuals looking to list less than 40 listings a month will pay a flat fee of 10.9% on each sale.
If you plan to list more than 40, opening a store may make more sense. The fees for Membership prices are based on monthly or annual subscriptions — with slightly cheaper fees for a year-long commitment.

  • Starter: — $7.95 or $4.95 monthly
  • Basic: $27.95 or $21.95 monthly
  • Premium: $74.95 or $59.95 monthly
  • Anchor: $349.95 or $299.95 monthly
  • Enterprise: $2,999.95 a year

Other fees include:

  • Final value fees: Fees range from 4% to 10%, for most listings. But it’s a complicated fee system, so use eBay’s calculator to find out how much you could pay.
  • Managed payments fee: Another fee to look out for involves payments processing. The company charges two types of fees for managing your payments:

    Processing rate. A fee equal to 2.7% of your total order amount.
    Dispute fee. A fee of $20, excluding taxes, if you’re found responsible for a chargeback or other disputed amount.
    You can avoid these charges by receiving buyer payments to a PayPal account, but PayPal itself will charge a fee based on completed sales and method of payment.

Trophy icon
Winner: Bonanza

Mostly for its simple fee structure. Open a Bonanza account for free and potentially pay just a 3.5% sales commission.

Which has more shoppers?

Bonanza

According to SimilarWeb:

  • Bonanza was ranked 9,247 in global traffic
  • Bonanza had received almost five million visits in the past six months
  • More than 74% of desktop visitors to Bonanza were from the US

eBay

According to SimilarWeb:

  • eBay is ranked 29 in global traffic
  • eBay received more than 867 million visits in the past six months
  • More than 78% of desktop visitors to eBay were from the US

Trophy icon
Winner: eBay

eBay’s superior customer reach and global brand recognition mean it comes out on top in this category.

Which has better seller tools?

Both eBay and Bonanza offer a wide range of tools to sellers.

BonanzaeBay
Shop analytics
Sponsored products
Ratings system and reviews
Fixed prices
Sell at auction
Fulfilment service
Import listings from other marketplaces
Discounts and coupons
Live chat support

Trophy icon
Winner: Tie

Both platforms offer a host of convenient features to help online sellers, so there’s no clear winner here — it all comes down to your store’s needs.

Which is easier to use?

Bonanza

  • Simple and straightforward sign up process.
  • Choose an advertising program to promote your shop.
  • Buyers can pay for purchases via PayPal or Stripe.
  • You’re responsible for storing and shipping your items.

eBay

  • Decide if you want to sell as an individual or store.
  • Compare features the different membership plans’ features and prices.
  • Link your PayPal account to your store during the signup process.
  • Buyers can pay with PayPal, credit or debit card, bank transfer and more.
  • You’re responsible for shipping or choose a third-party fulfillment provider.

Trophy icon
Winner: Bonanza

Registering for an account and creating a store is a little easier with Bonanza.

How does it work?

Bonanza

This online marketplace offers a platform for you to sell a range of goods. Sell from a personalized booth, or set up a store that’s customized to your brand. List your items manually, or import them from other marketplaces like Amazon, eBay, Etsy or Shopify.

eBay

One of the largest and oldest online marketplaces, eBay offers a platform for sellers to list a range of products at fixed prices or sell as an auction. PayPal is the most accepted payment method and is a required option for listings.

Compare alternative e-commerce providers

Data indicated here is updated regularly
Name Product Products Monthly fees start at Processing fees start at Hosting
BigCommerce
Payment processing, Website builder, Inventory tracking, Shopping cart software, Shipping software
$29.95/month
2.9% + $0.30 per transaction
Hosted
BigCommerce is an all-in-one e-commerce platform created to help you sell more.
Helcim
Payment processing, POS software, POS hardware, Website builder, Inventory tracking
$20/month
1.92% + $0.08 per transaction
Hosted
Conveniently packaged into three service tiers for in-person and online sales.
Square E-commerce
Payment processing, Website builder, Inventory tracking, Shopping cart software, Shipping software
None
2.9% + 10¢
Hosted
Create an online store with beautiful layouts to help drive business.
Shopify
Payment processing, Website builder, Inventory tracking, Shopping cart software, Shipping software
$29/month
2.9% + $0.30 online; 2.7% in person
Hosted
Shopify offers both e-commerce and in-person POS systems designed to help you build a new online store from the ground up.
loading

Compare up to 4 providers

Bottom line

If you’re new to online selling and want something straightforward and affordable, try Bonanza for its simple fee structure. But if you’re looking to reach more people and sell more items, eBay has a selection of membership plans to meet the needs of online stores.

If you’re still deciding on a e-commerce marketplace to sell your goods, compare other options.

Related Posts

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder.com provides guides and information on a range of products and services. Because our content is not financial advice, we suggest talking with a professional before you make any decision.

By submitting your comment or question, you agree to our Privacy and Cookies Policy and finder.com Terms of Use.

Questions and responses on finder.com are not provided, paid for or otherwise endorsed by any bank or brand. These banks and brands are not responsible for ensuring that comments are answered or accurate.
Go to site