Finder is committed to editorial independence. While we receive compensation when you click links to partners, they do not influence our content.
BigCommerce vs. Shift4Shop vs. Shopify
Are you ready to start an online store, but not sure which e-commerce platform to use?
There are a lot of good e-commerce platforms out there. Three top contenders are BigCommerce, Shift4Shop and Shopify — and they’re constantly duking it out for new customers.
But which is best for you depends on your business needs. We've broken down all the ways these e-commerce giants compare to help you decide.
Which platform should you pick?
Comparing BigCommerce, Shift4Shop and Shopify across five main categories, Shopify comes out in the lead, with Shift4Shop in a close second.
That said, the overall winner for you will be the one that works best for your store and will depend heavily on the size of your business.
Lowest price for a standard plan:
Lowest monthly price for a micro plan:
Best for unlimited products:
Best for unlimited sales volume:
Best for POS hardware:
Shift4Shop and Shopify
Best for transaction fees:
BigCommerce and Shift4Shop
Best Micro and Enterprise plans:
Best for themes:
How much do they cost?
Let’s lay out the pricing for each platform’s main paid plans.
Technically, Shift4Shop comes out on top, but only for those who sign up for its End-to-End plan. Shift4Shop's End-to-End plan is free to use but only if you opt into payment processing from its parent company, Shift4 Payments. Otherwise, you're looking at one of its paid plans which start at $29 monthly — the same as BigCommerce.
You’ll want to look at other features to compare, of course. But if you plan on using Shift4 Payments as your payment processor, Shift4Shop wins this battle.
$299.95 for first $400,000 in sales
+ $150 for each additional $200,000 in sales
$0 — if you use Shift4 Payments
Comparing the features
We compare entry-level plans for each of the three e-commerce platforms: BigCommerce’s Standard plan, Shift4Shop’s Basic plan and Shopify’s Basic Shopify plan.
None with Shopify Payments; 2% with external payment gateways
Abandoned cart recovery
Real-time shipping calculation
Each platform allows you to stock unlimited products.
Winner: 3-way tie
Both BigCommerce and Shift4Shop set sales limits on their service tiers — a limitation Shopify doesn't impose on any of its plans.
You’ll pay credit card transaction fees of between 2% and 3%, regardless of which payment gateway you use. However, some e-commerce platforms charge additional transaction fees.
Shopify, for example, charges a transaction fee if you accept credit card payments outside of Shopify Payments — 2% on the Basic Shopify plan, with a smaller percentage on the upper-tier plans. Meanwhile, neither BigCommerce nor Shift4Shop charge additional fees for any payment gateway.
Winner: It’s a tie — BigCommerce andShift4Shop
Micro and enterprise plans
Some e-commerce platforms offer a micro plan that comes with few features at a low price. Most e-commerce platforms also offer enterprise plans for very large brands. Let’s compare these plans among BigCommerce, Shift4Shop and Shopify.
Winner: 3-way tie
BigCommerce and Shift4Shop don’t offer micro plans, while Shopify does. Each company’s enterprise plan is highly capable, making it tough to anoint a winner here. Consider contacting BigCommerce, Shift4Shop and Shopify support teams for platform demos.
BigCommerce doesn’t offer a micro plan. Its lowest-level plan is the Standard plan.
BigCommerce’s Enterprise plan comes with such features as:
- Unlimited yearly sales volume
- Priority customer support
- Special credit card rates (2.2% + $0.30 or lower)
- Abandoned cart saver
- Product filtering
- Dedicated SSL
- Unlimited API calls
Shift4Shop does not offer a micro plan anymore — its lowest-tier plan is now the Basic plan.
But it does have an Enterprise plan that comes with:
- Dedicated support team
- Unlimited sales volume
- Unlimited monthly visitors
- Unlimited staff users
- Unlimited email hosting
- Unlimited disk space
- DDOS protection
Shopify’s micro plan is Shopify Lite, which is only $9 a month. This plan doesn’t come with an online store — instead, Shopify Lite lets you sell on your own website or on Facebook, Pinterest or other social media.
If you’re an established brand or running a store that sells at a heavy volume, take a look at Shopify Plus. With this enterprise plan, you get:
- Unlimited bandwidth
- Unlimited sales transactions
- Dedicated support manager
- Multichannel sales
- Unlimited email hosting
- Infrastructure to handle product launches, flash sales and special events
- Fraud detection
In addition to selling online, you might also want to sell in person. All three e-commerce platforms offer this capability.
BigCommerce integrates with Square’s point-of-sale (POS) platform, but it doesn’t offer its own POS hardware.
However, Shift4Shop and Shopify do offer POS hardware, including:
- Cash drawers
- Receipt printers
- Barcode scanners
- iPad stands
Winner: Shopify and Shift4Shop
Shopify and Shift4Shop have their own POS software, making it easy to integrate your online and brick-and-mortar stores.
Let’s see how BigCommerce, Shift4Shop and Shopify stack up for free and paid themes.
Looking only at the number of free themes offered, Shift4Shop comes out on top. As of February 2021, it offers more than 100 free themes. Compare this with BigCommerce's 12 and Shopify's eight and the winner is clear.
Since picking a number one depends on your personal preferences, check out the platforms’ theme pages for yourself.
BigCommerce offers 12 free themes that include:
If you’re willing to pay for a theme, you’ll find many more options — around 100 of them. Prices for the paid themes are typically between $150 and $300.
Shift4Shop offers over 100 free themes, including:
Shopify offers eight free themes, including:
You can choose from over 70 paid themes, typically ranging from $140 to $180.
Compare e-commerce providers
To compare providers, try sorting by products, monthly fees, processing fees or hosting services. You can also choose the Go to site button for more information.
Frequently asked questions
Do any of these three e-commerce platforms come with contracts?
No, none of the standard plans with Shopify, BigCommerce or 3dcart come with contracts. However, you may be asked to sign a contract if you register for an enterprise plan.
Do I need my own web hosting when I sign up for one of the e-commerce platforms?
No, each platform provides web hosting. You’ll need your own website only if you want to add buy buttons or if you’re on the Shopify Lite plan, which doesn’t offer a standalone e-commerce store.
More guides on Finder
Shopify vs. Amazon
Comparing Shopify and Amazon? Here’s how these platforms measure up.
Shopify vs. Squarespace
Both can help you open an online store, but only one offers in-house payment processing.
Shopify vs. WordPress
The right platform for you depends on where and how you sell.
Adobe Commerce vs. Shopify
You can build your own website with Adobe Commerce or choose a prebuilt solution with Shopify
5 Square alternatives that combine point-of-sale and e-commerce features.
Alternatives to Shopify
3 online selling platform alternatives to Shopify.
Adobe Commerce review
An open source e-commerce platform that requires advanced technical skill — or a dev team.
Wix vs. Shopify
Consider how you want to scale your business when deciding between Wix and Shopify.
Big Cartel vs. Shopify
Big Cartel and Shopify set up businesses with an online storefront. But they have vastly different features.
Volusion vs. Shopify
Both Volusion and Shopify help businesses with no coding experience build a digital storefront.
Ask an Expert