The cheapest and most expensive car insurance across the US

Relaxed requirements and low-risk drivers translate into fewer accidents and lower premiums.

Last updated:

couple driving a car in the city

We value our editorial independence, basing our comparison results, content and reviews on objective analysis without bias. But we may receive compensation when you click links on our site. Learn more about how we make money from our partners.

Your city’s weather, traffic, cost of living and accident rates all affect the condition of the roads you drive, which sways your premium higher or lower. If you’re wondering about the cheapest statewide insurance, you’ll find it in open-aired Ohio. But towering rates more consistently land in nearby Michigan, where state requirements mean drivers pay through the roof.

Car insurance costs by state

Cheapest states for car insurance

These states with cheaper insurance have a running theme of rural areas, low coverage requirements and low underinsured driver rates.

Ohio

Ohio’s average annual premium is $1,000, making it the cheapest in the nation. Low costs may be due to the state’s at-fault laws, which don’t require coverage outside of liability. The lower liability limits required also help drivers stay legal with less coverage.

South Dakota

In the Mount Rushmore State, expect to pay around $1,050 a year for car insurance. That low cost may be attributed to its less populated cities and low underinsured driver rate, decreasing the risk of an accident considerably.

Connecticut

Connecticut drivers pay an average annual premium of $1,100, despite the state requiring extra coverage. It likely keeps premiums low because of strict penalties for driving without insurance, which lead to fewer underinsured drivers. The state also sets its liability limits at 20/40/10, which is lower than many states.

Delaware

The average annual car insurance premium in the Diamond State is $1,100, possibly due to the state’s low population and unusually low liability maximums of 15/30/10. Delaware requires PIP coverage, however.

Iowa

Iowa also keeps its average premium at $1,100 a year. This at-fault state doesn’t require insurance at all if drivers prove financial responsibility, but it also has a low underinsured driver rate.

Nebraska

The Cornhusker State’s average premium too is some $1,100 per year — which makes sense, given its low underinsured driver rate. Plus, with a population of just under 2 million compared to Georgia’s 10 million and Florida’s 20, you’re less likely to run into anyone on the road. Or experience traffic congestion at all.

Most expensive states for car insurance

Cheapest cities for car insurance

The homes of the lowest premiums nestle mostly in tea-sippin’ Southern towns, but even Idaho’s B-Town could conjure up lazy images of porch swings in Mayberry. The small-town ties to a low premium are probably due to fewer cars on the road, meaning fewer accidents.

Boise, Idaho

This city’s low average premium of $590 a year are supported by its more desolate roads, compared with other cities. Plus, it’s in a state where even first offenses of drunk driving come with heavy consequences.

Greensboro, North Carolina

Combine rural roads and low underinsured driver rates, and you get Greensboro’s average premium of $750 a year.

Birmingham, Alabama

This large Alabaman city attracts leisurely tourists along with residents who enjoy the city’s low cost of Southern living. That atmosphere could mean fewer zippy drivers and lower repair costs, providing the city with a low average premium of $806.

Charlotte, North Carolina

It’s the state’s most populated city, and yet Charlotte’s average car insurance premium stops at $814. That rate could reflect fewer accidents in the area along with a low cost of living, which may keep car accident costs down around town.

Mobile, Alabama

This rural city comes with open roads free from city traffic and driving dangers. That translates into fewer car accidents and the city’s low $856 average premium.

Most expensive cities for car insurance

When steering clear of an expensive premium, you’ll want to avoid major cities with high congestion that leads to more accidents more often.

Detroit, Michigan

This heavily populated city offers the worst average premium: $4,714 a year. The reason? Steep insurance requirements and its location in a state with the highest premiums.

Brooklyn, New York

Residents boast things are bigger in Brooklyn — but that appears to include sky-high insurance rates. Drivers on this New York City borough’s roads number into the millions. Combine that with high costs for car repairs, and you’ve got a whopping average premium of $4,239 annually.

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

The City of Brotherly Love can’t love its high car insurance premiums — around $3,793 a year. It’s got a million drivers on the road and requires higher coverage if drivers choose no-fault insurance.

New Orleans, Louisiana

You’re at a high risk for natural disasters in the Big Easy, the city sitting under sea level and within hurricane territory. Drivers can expect to budget some $3,025 a year for car insurance.

Las Vegas, Nevada

Residents of this desert city pay a high average car insurance premium of $2,947 a year, possibly due to having more accidents and tourist traffic compared with other cities.

How much is car insurance in every state?

The average premium nationwide stands at $1,300 a year, but yours may vary widely depending on where you live.

Here’s why premiums differ between states, cities and even ZIP code:

Accident risk

Your area might trend toward more accidents, putting you at higher risk, even if you’re a safe driver.
Insurance requirements

Some states require extra coverage or higher limits than others. For example, Michigan requires personal injury protection with unlimited medical coverage, skyrocketing rates in the state.
Cost of living

Areas with a high cost of living could translate into higher repair costs or medical expenses — part of the reason California is more expensive than Kentucky.
High-risk drivers

An influx of underinsured or young drivers can make road safety uncertain.
Inclement weather

Are hurricanes, hail or flooding common where you live? That could mean higher prices for comprehensive coverage.
Traffic conditions

Congested cities can be riskier than roads in the free-flowing countryside.

Bottom line

Fewer drivers on the road can mean a lower chance of accidents. But many factors drive a high or low premium, such as weather, insurance laws and underinsured drivers on the road.

No matter where you live, the best car insurance policy combines the coverage, benefits and value that fits your lifestyle and budget.

Methodology: How we got these rates

The Finder team compared rates from all 50 states and the top cities across the US with quotes from hundreds of insurers using our quoting tool.

Was this content helpful to you? No  Yes

Ask an Expert

You are about to post a question on finder.com:

  • Do not enter personal information (eg. surname, phone number, bank details) as your question will be made public
  • finder.com is a financial comparison and information service, not a bank or product provider
  • We cannot provide you with personal advice or recommendations
  • Your answer might already be waiting – check previous questions below to see if yours has already been asked

Finder.com provides guides and information on a range of products and services. Because our content is not financial advice, we suggest talking with a professional before you make any decision.

By submitting your comment or question, you agree to our Privacy and Cookies Policy and Terms of Use.

Questions and responses on finder.com are not provided, paid for or otherwise endorsed by any bank or brand. These banks and brands are not responsible for ensuring that comments are answered or accurate.
Go to site